Should I Sell or Dismantle Junk in The Witcher 3? A Master Witcher’s Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The eternal question facing every Witcher 3 player struggling to make ends meet: should you sell that pile of junk you’ve been lugging around, or dismantle it for crafting materials? The short answer is: it depends. Early game, when coin is scarce, selling is generally the better option. However, as you progress and crafting becomes more crucial, dismantling specific junk items for essential components becomes increasingly valuable. But don’t worry, we’ll delve deep into the nuances, giving you the definitive guide to managing your junk in the Northern Kingdoms.
The Early Game Struggle: Selling is King
During the initial hours of The Witcher 3, every crown counts. You’re constantly upgrading your gear, paying for repairs, and buying recipes. Dismantling junk early on can feel like a waste of money, as the cost of dismantling often outweighs the value of the resulting materials.
- Prioritize Selling: Focus on selling the majority of your junk to accumulate wealth quickly.
- Target Wealthy Merchants: Novigrad and Oxenfurt merchants, particularly Hattori the master blacksmith and the armorer in Hierarch Square, offer the best prices. They also have larger coin reserves.
- Weight Management: Sell heavier items with low value first, like common swords and armor dropped by bandits or soldiers. Boots and gloves often have a good cost-to-weight ratio, making them efficient to loot and sell.
- Cheap Dismantling Exceptions: Keep an eye out for junk items that are extremely cheap to dismantle, even in the early game. These might yield crafting components you need. Experiment and learn which items are worth the small investment.
- Repair is Critical: Don’t forget to regularly repair your gear! Broken gear has significantly reduced stats, affecting combat effectiveness.
Mid to Late Game: Shifting Towards Dismantling
As you level up and start tackling more challenging quests, crafting becomes essential. Higher-tier Witcher gear requires specific crafting materials that are often obtained through dismantling junk. This is when the balance shifts towards prioritizing dismantling certain items.
- Identify Essential Crafting Components: Learn which components are needed for your desired Witcher gear and weapon upgrades. Then, target junk items that yield those components when dismantled.
- Gem Dust is Golden: Any item that dismantles into gem dust (emerald, sapphire, diamond, ruby, amber) is usually worth dismantling, even if the item itself doesn’t seem valuable. Gem dust is crucial for high-level crafting.
- Rare Metals are Valuable: Keep an eye out for rare metals like dimeritium ore, meteorite ore, and silver ingot. These are vital for crafting Witcher gear.
- DLC Considerations: If you have the Hearts of Stone or Blood and Wine expansions, certain junk items become more valuable. Save jewelry with gems for dismantling, especially if you plan on using the Runewright in Hearts of Stone. Hold onto relic swords to sell to or dismantle for the Grandmaster Armorer in Toussaint from Blood and Wine for rare materials.
- Location, Location, Location: Remember that merchants in Toussaint from Blood and Wine are also worth keeping in mind when deciding whether to sell items for the best price.
Understanding Weight and Inventory Management
Inventory management is a constant struggle in The Witcher 3. Here’s how to manage weight effectively while deciding whether to sell or dismantle:
- Encumbrance Penalty: Over-encumbrance severely limits your movement speed, making exploration a nightmare.
- Prioritize Weight Reduction: Focus on selling or dismantling items that contribute the most to your overall weight, especially those with low value.
- Roach’s Saddlebags: Upgrade Roach’s saddlebags to increase your maximum carrying capacity. This is a worthwhile investment.
- Stash Your Loot: Use the stashes located at various inns and merchant locations to store excess items that you don’t need immediately. This allows you to hoard crafting components for later use.
- Alchemy is Key: Alchemical ingredients have no weight, so stock up on them.
Exceptions to the Rule
There are always exceptions to the general rules.
- Unique Junk Items: Some junk items have unique descriptions or lore. Consider keeping these for the sake of immersion or as collector’s items.
- Quest-Related Items: Certain junk items may be required for specific quests. Make sure to read quest descriptions carefully before indiscriminately selling everything.
- Roleplaying Considerations: Depending on your roleplaying style, you might choose to keep certain items for sentimental reasons, regardless of their monetary value.
Mastering the Art of Haggling
Don’t forget to haggle with merchants! Persuasion skills can significantly increase the selling price of your junk, making selling even more profitable.
- Practice Makes Perfect: The more you haggle, the better you’ll become at judging how far you can push a merchant without causing them to refuse the transaction.
- Consider Your Reputation: Your reputation can affect merchants’ willingness to negotiate. Maintaining a good reputation will make haggling easier.
- Take Advantage of Discounts: Some merchants offer discounts if you complete quests for them or have a high relationship level.
Ultimately, the decision to sell or dismantle junk in The Witcher 3 comes down to a careful balancing act between your immediate financial needs and your long-term crafting goals. By understanding the value of different crafting components, knowing where to find the best merchants, and managing your inventory effectively, you can maximize your profits and ensure you always have the resources you need to survive in the dangerous world of The Witcher. To learn more about the nuances of game mechanics and the impact of gaming on society, visit the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What junk items should I always dismantle in The Witcher 3?
Items that yield valuable gem dust (like emerald dust, diamond dust, and ruby dust) and rare metals (like dimeritium ore) are almost always worth dismantling, regardless of your current financial situation. These components are crucial for high-level crafting and can be difficult to obtain otherwise.
2. Where is the best place to sell junk in The Witcher 3?
Merchants in Novigrad and Oxenfurt generally offer the best prices for junk. Specifically, Hattori (the master blacksmith in Novigrad) and the armorer in Hierarch Square (also in Novigrad) have the highest coin reserves and replenish them quickly. For the DLC locations, make sure to check out the merchant in Toussaint.
3. Is there any point in keeping junk in The Witcher 2?
No. In The Witcher 2, junk has no purpose and only adds weight to your inventory. It’s best to avoid picking it up altogether.
4. Does it matter who I sell to in The Witcher 3?
Yes! Different merchants specialize in different types of goods and offer varying prices. Blacksmiths pay more for weapons, armorers pay more for armor, and general merchants are best for miscellaneous junk.
5. Should I sell weapons and armor I’m not using in The Witcher 3?
Absolutely. There’s no reason to hoard old gear, especially early in the game. Sell it to free up inventory space and earn some much-needed crowns.
6. What’s the difference between dismantling and removing upgrades in The Witcher 3?
Dismantling destroys the entire item to extract crafting components. Removing upgrades allows you to salvage runes or glyphs from an item without destroying the item itself. Choose removal if you want to reuse the runes/glyphs on a different item.
7. How do I manage weight effectively in The Witcher 3?
Prioritize selling or dismantling heavy, low-value items. Upgrade Roach’s saddlebags to increase your carrying capacity, and use stashes to store excess items. And always consider that alchemical ingredients have zero weight.
8. What should I do with junk in The Witcher 3 early game?
Focus on selling the majority of your junk to accumulate wealth. Look for merchants in Novigrad and Oxenfurt for the best prices.
9. What should I do with junk in The Witcher 3 mid to late game?
Prioritize dismantling specific items that yield essential crafting components for your desired Witcher gear and weapon upgrades. Gem dust and rare metals become increasingly important.
10. Is it better to sell or dismantle in Assassin’s Creed Odyssey (related question from the source)?
In Assassin’s Creed Odyssey, selling is generally better, especially at higher levels. You can use the drachmae to buy materials from a blacksmith directly, often a more efficient method than dismantling.
11. What are the most expensive items to sell in The Witcher 3?
Relic weapons and rare armor pieces fetch the highest prices. Be sure to check the value of each item before selling it, and don’t be afraid to haggle.
12. Who is Hattori in The Witcher 3, and why is he important?
Hattori is a master blacksmith located in Novigrad. He is a reliable source of income in the main game.
13. Can I change Ciri’s armor in The Witcher 3?
Yes, with the additional DLC that added Netflix-based appearances, you can change Ciri’s outfit in the game’s menu.
14. Should I repair weapons and armor in The Witcher 3?
Yes! Repairing gear is crucial to maintaining its effectiveness in combat. Damaged gear has significantly reduced stats.
15. Are there any specific merchants I should avoid selling to in The Witcher 3?
While Yoanna (Master Armorer in Crow’s Perch) isn’t the worst merchant, she’s generally known to offer lower prices for items compared to blacksmiths in larger cities. Consider dismantling instead of selling to her.