Should You Spare The Fake Witcher in The Witcher 3? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The decision to spare or execute Aryan La Valette (in The Witcher 2) has ripple effects that extend into The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. Whether you choose to let him live or sentence him to death directly influences a subsequent quest. So, should you spare the fake Witcher? Generally, it’s more beneficial to spare Aryan La Valette in The Witcher 2. While this choice leads to a confrontation with Mary Louisa in The Witcher 2, the ultimate reward in The Witcher 3, the “Ghosts of the Past” side quest, makes sparing him the more rewarding option. This quest features Letho of Gulet, a character whose presence significantly enriches the narrative and provides a unique gameplay experience.
The Consequences of Your Actions
The most significant outcome of sparing Aryan La Valette is the availability of the “Ghosts of the Past” quest in The Witcher 3. If you choose to kill Aryan, Letho will not appear in the game, effectively locking you out of this side quest. “Ghosts of the Past” involves a complex storyline where Geralt encounters Letho and potentially aids him in resolving a personal conflict. This quest offers opportunities for combat, exploration, and dialogue-driven decisions that significantly impact the outcome. More than just a simple quest, it’s a chance to reconnect with a character from The Witcher 2 and delve deeper into his motivations and history. The quest concludes with a potential alliance, giving the player more support.
Why Sparing Aryan Is the ‘Better’ Choice
-
Access to “Ghosts of the Past”: The most compelling reason is unlocking this fantastic side quest. It’s a well-written, engaging, and rewarding experience that adds depth to the world of The Witcher 3.
-
Letho’s Character Arc: Letho is a complex and compelling character. Seeing him again allows you to further explore his motivations and understand his perspective. He’s far from a simple villain, and “Ghosts of the Past” offers a nuanced exploration of his character.
-
Gameplay Variety: “Ghosts of the Past” introduces unique combat encounters and investigation sequences, providing a break from the main storyline. This adds gameplay variety and keeps the experience fresh.
-
Potential Alliance: Depending on your choices during the quest, you can secure Letho as an ally. Having him by your side during certain situations in the game can be a significant advantage, especially as the quests get harder and harder in the game.
-
Moral Ambiguity: The Witcher series thrives on morally grey choices. Sparing Aryan, despite his actions, and seeing the consequences unfold adds to the complexity and realism of the game world.
Considering the Alternative: Killing Aryan
While sparing Aryan is generally recommended, there’s still an argument for killing him based on role-playing considerations. If Geralt adheres to a strict code of justice and believes Aryan deserves punishment for his crimes, then killing him aligns with that characterization. However, from a gameplay perspective, the benefits of sparing Aryan outweigh the satisfaction of seeing him punished. Killing him gives you no quests to play, characters to interact with, or experience points.
The Impact of Witcher 2 Save Simulation
The Witcher 3 allows you to simulate a Witcher 2 save file, enabling you to import your past decisions and see how they affect the world around you. If you choose not to simulate a save, the game defaults to certain decisions, often resulting in negative outcomes. In the case of Aryan, choosing not to simulate a save will likely result in him being considered dead, locking you out of the “Ghosts of the Past” quest.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions about the Aryan La Valette decision and its impact on The Witcher 3.
What exactly does “Ghosts of the Past” entail?
“Ghosts of the Past” is a side quest in The Witcher 3 where Geralt encounters Letho of Gulet, a Witcher from the Viper School. The quest involves helping Letho deal with mercenaries who are hunting him down. You’ll need to investigate, fight, and make choices that will determine Letho’s fate.
If I spare Aryan, does that mean I approve of his actions?
Not necessarily. Sparing Aryan doesn’t equate to condoning his behavior. It’s a choice that opens up new narrative possibilities and allows you to engage with a compelling storyline featuring Letho.
Is Letho a good guy or a bad guy?
Letho is a complex character with morally ambiguous motivations. He’s not a purely evil villain but also not a flawless hero. “Ghosts of the Past” allows you to delve deeper into his character and form your own opinion. For a deeper understanding of the impact of video games on moral reasoning, explore resources available at the Games Learning Society using the URL: https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/. You can find more information on the topic on their website.
What happens if I fail “Ghosts of the Past”?
If you fail to protect Letho during “Ghosts of the Past,” he will die. This will permanently remove him from the game and prevent you from accessing any potential future interactions with him.
Can I import a save from The Witcher 2 instead of simulating?
Yes, if you have a Witcher 2 save file on your PC, you can import it into The Witcher 3. This will ensure that all your decisions from the previous game carry over, including the fate of Aryan La Valette.
Will Letho help me in the main quest if I spare Aryan?
While Letho doesn’t directly participate in the main quest, he can offer valuable assistance and information, especially when the quests are most difficult.
Can I romance Letho?
No, Letho is not a romance option in The Witcher 3.
Is “Ghosts of the Past” a long quest?
“Ghosts of the Past” is a relatively lengthy side quest, offering several hours of gameplay. It involves multiple stages, including investigation, combat, and dialogue sequences.
Does sparing Aryan affect my relationship with any other characters?
Sparing Aryan has a minor impact on your initial interaction with Mary Louisa in The Witcher 2. However, it doesn’t significantly affect your relationships with other key characters in The Witcher 3.
What if I don’t like Letho as a character? Should I still spare Aryan?
Even if you don’t particularly like Letho, “Ghosts of the Past” offers a unique and engaging gameplay experience that is worth exploring. It’s a well-crafted quest with interesting challenges and a compelling narrative.
Are there any downsides to sparing Aryan?
The only real downside is the initial negative reaction from Mary Louisa in The Witcher 2. However, this is a minor consequence compared to the benefits of unlocking “Ghosts of the Past.”
Can I complete “Ghosts of the Past” even if I make other negative choices in The Witcher 3?
Yes, “Ghosts of the Past” is a self-contained quest that is not directly affected by other decisions you make in The Witcher 3.
Is it possible to miss “Ghosts of the Past” entirely?
Yes, if you choose not to simulate a Witcher 2 save and the game defaults to Aryan being dead, you will miss “Ghosts of the Past.” Also, if you don’t explore the map, the quest never appears.
How important is it to play The Witcher 2 before The Witcher 3?
While not essential, playing The Witcher 2 provides valuable context for the characters and events in The Witcher 3. It allows you to better understand Letho’s motivations and appreciate the significance of “Ghosts of the Past.”
Can I replay “Ghosts of the Past” if I make a mistake?
No, once you complete “Ghosts of the Past,” the decisions you made are permanent. You would need to start a new game to replay the quest.
Ultimately, the decision to spare or kill Aryan La Valette comes down to personal preference. However, from a gameplay perspective, sparing Aryan and unlocking the “Ghosts of the Past” quest offers a more rewarding and enriching experience. It allows you to reconnect with a compelling character, explore a complex storyline, and add depth to your Witcher 3 adventure. By sparing Aryan, you open the door to a rewarding quest. Remember to consider the consequences of your actions and the impact they have on the world around you.
By sparing Aryan, you enhance the overall experience, adding depth, character development, and thrilling gameplay to your Witcher 3 playthrough. Consider your choice carefully, as it carries significant weight in shaping the narrative and providing a truly immersive journey. For more insight into how game design impacts decision-making, visit GamesLearningSociety.org.