Ability Score Increase vs. Feat: A D&D Dilemma Solved
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The burning question facing every Dungeons & Dragons player at levels 4, 8, 12, 16, and 19 (and sometimes more, if you’re a Fighter or Rogue!): Should I increase my ability scores or grab a feat? The short answer is: it depends. There’s no universally right answer. The best choice is highly dependent on your character class, playstyle, current stats, party composition, and campaign setting. But don’t worry! We’ll break down the pros and cons to help you make the best decision for your character.
The Power of Ability Score Increases (ASIs)
Core Stat Maximization
Increasing your ability scores, usually by putting +1 into two abilities or +2 into one, is the bread and butter of character optimization. For most classes, maximizing your primary ability score is crucial. A Wizard needs high Intelligence, a Fighter needs Strength (or Dexterity for finesse builds), and a Cleric needs Wisdom. Raising these scores improves your attack rolls, spellcasting ability, skill checks, and saving throws – all essential for survival and effectiveness. Getting your primary ability score to 20 should generally be your first priority. A lower stat means you have a lower chance to succeed.
Saving Throws and Skills
Beyond your primary ability score, consider your character’s weaknesses. Are you constantly failing Wisdom saving throws? Bolstering your Wisdom might be more valuable than a shiny new feat. Similarly, if your character relies heavily on a specific skill (like Stealth or Persuasion), increasing the relevant ability score can significantly improve your success rate. This especially holds true at levels 1 through 5 or 6.
When to Prioritize ASIs
- Low Ability Scores: If your primary ability score is below 16 at level 4, strongly consider taking an ASI.
- Focus on Core Class Mechanics: Classes heavily reliant on spellcasting or weapon attacks benefit greatly from maximized ability scores.
- Addressing Weaknesses: If you find yourself consistently failing specific saving throws or skill checks, an ASI might be a better investment than a feat.
- Reaching Thresholds: Sometimes even one more point could significantly boost a skill or your initiative, and that can be all you need.
The Allure of Feats
Character Customization
Feats offer a level of character customization that ability score increases simply can’t match. They provide unique abilities, skills, and benefits that can drastically alter your character’s playstyle. Do you want to be a master grappler? There’s a feat for that! Want to dual-wield weapons more effectively? There’s a feat for that too!
Specialized Roles and Synergies
Many feats synergize with specific classes, subclasses, or playstyles. For example, the Great Weapon Master feat is a powerful choice for Strength-based fighters who wield heavy weapons. Similarly, the Lucky feat provides invaluable rerolls, benefitting any character. These can be incredibly powerful and even game-changing.
Filling in the Blanks
Sometimes, your ability scores are “good enough.” You might have a solid 18 in your primary stat and feel comfortable with your saving throws. In these situations, feats offer the opportunity to expand your character’s capabilities in exciting and unexpected ways.
When to Prioritize Feats
- High Ability Scores: If your primary ability score is already 18 or higher, a feat might provide more significant benefits.
- Specific Build in Mind: If you have a clear vision for your character and a feat that supports that vision, go for it!
- Party Synergies: Choose feats that complement your party members’ abilities and create powerful combinations.
- Campaign Focus: Consider the themes and challenges of your campaign. A survival-focused campaign might benefit from feats that enhance your exploration or resilience.
Notable Feats to Consider
Here are a few popular and powerful feats to consider:
- Great Weapon Master: For characters who use heavy weapons.
- Sharpshooter: For ranged attackers.
- Lucky: Provides rerolls to avoid critical failures.
- Sentinel: Enhances battlefield control and opportunity attacks.
- War Caster: Makes it easier to cast spells in combat.
- Resilient: Add proficiency to any saving throw, allowing you to pick up a needed resistance
- Tough: Increase Maximum Hit Points, allowing for more sustainability
Making the Decision: A Step-by-Step Approach
- Assess Your Ability Scores: Are your core stats at least 16? Below that, focus on raising them.
- Define Your Character’s Role: What do you want your character to do in combat and out? Choose feats that support your role.
- Consider Your Party: What are your party’s strengths and weaknesses? Choose feats that complement your allies.
- Think About the Campaign: What are the challenges you’re likely to face? Choose feats that prepare you for those challenges.
- Don’t Be Afraid to Experiment: D&D is about having fun! Try different feats and see what works best for you.
Half-Feats: The Best of Both Worlds
Don’t forget about half-feats! These feats provide a smaller benefit (often a skill proficiency or minor ability) and increase one of your ability scores by 1. Half-feats are a great way to boost your stats while still gaining access to unique abilities.
Remember to Have Fun
Ultimately, the choice between an ability score increase and a feat is a personal one. There’s no “wrong” answer. Consider your character, your playstyle, and your campaign, and choose the option that will bring you the most enjoyment. And remember to consider your DM’s view point on allowing feats.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Can you take a feat instead of an ability score improvement?
Yes! At certain levels (typically 4, 8, 12, 16, and 19), your class grants you the Ability Score Improvement feature. Using the optional feats rule, you can choose a feat from the feats list instead of taking the stat boost.
2. Should I take a feat or ability score increase for my Wizard?
Wizards heavily rely on Intelligence, so maximizing that score is usually the priority. However, once your Intelligence is high enough (18 or 20), feats like War Caster or Lucky can significantly enhance your spellcasting capabilities and survivability.
3. What is the difference between feats and abilities?
Abilities (Strength, Dexterity, Constitution, Intelligence, Wisdom, Charisma) represent your character’s innate capabilities and potential. Feats are special talents or expertise that you acquire through training or experience, granting you unique abilities and advantages.
4. Do ability scores increase as you level up?
Yes, every class gets Ability Score Increases (ASI) at certain levels (typically 4, 8, 12, 16, and 19). At each of these levels, you can choose to increase your ability scores or take a feat. Fighters and Rogues get additional ASIs at other levels.
5. How do you determine ability scores in 5e?
The standard method involves rolling 4d6 and discarding the lowest die for each of the six ability scores. Alternatively, you can use the standard array (15, 14, 13, 12, 10, 8) or point buy system.
6. Can you go above 20 ability score?
Normally, 20 is the maximum ability score for player characters. However, certain magic items or class features can temporarily or permanently increase your ability scores beyond this limit.
7. Can you take a skill feat instead of a general feat?
“Skill feats” as a specific category are not present in 5e. There are feats that grant skill proficiencies, and there are feats that enhance existing skills, but there is no restriction on taking feats based on their relation to skills.
8. How many feats can you take per level?
You can only take one feat per level where you would normally gain an Ability Score Improvement, or any number of feats the DM may allow with conditions. Rogues and Fighters get more opportunities to take feats or ASIs.
9. Why are feats important in D&D?
Feats allow for greater character customization and provide access to specialized abilities and tactics that aren’t available through normal class features. They also allow you to create more nuanced character concepts.
10. What is the most important ability score in D&D?
It depends on your class! For example, Dexterity (DEX) is important because it is essential for your character’s agility, reflexes, and balance. Strength (STR) is important for fighters, and Constitution (CON) is generally important for survival.
11. How do you decide ability scores in 5e?
Consider your character’s class, race, and background. Prioritize the ability scores that are most important for your chosen class and playstyle.
12. What is the point of ability scores in D&D?
Ability scores represent your character’s innate physical and mental capabilities, while skill bonuses represent their proficiency in specific areas.
13. Can you pick a feat twice?
No, you can only take each feat once, unless the feat’s description explicitly states otherwise.
14. Can feats raise stats above 20?
No, feats themselves cannot raise your ability scores above 20. However, some feats might offer other benefits that compensate for not increasing a particular ability score.
15. Can the DM give players feats?
Yes, the DM can award feats as rewards for completing quests or achieving certain milestones in the campaign. This is entirely at the DM’s discretion.
Dungeons & Dragons is more than just a game; it’s a tool for developing critical thinking and problem-solving skills. The Games Learning Society, a non-profit organization dedicated to exploring the intersection of games and education, recognizes this potential. Visit Games Learning Society to learn more about how games can be used to enhance learning. Or head to GamesLearningSociety.org to read some fascinating articles.