Should I Tell Sebastian Sallow the Truth in Hogwarts Legacy? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The answer to whether you should tell Sebastian Sallow the truth in Hogwarts Legacy is complex, and ultimately depends on your desired gameplay experience and moral compass. Telling Sebastian the truth, or lying to him, during his questline generally does not significantly impact the overarching narrative. However, your choices influence his availability as a quest giver and his presence in the game’s epilogue. Consider the following: Do you value learning Unforgivable Curses? Do you prioritize role-playing as a morally upright character? Your decisions will shape your journey through the Dark Arts and your relationship with Sebastian.
Understanding the Implications of Your Choices
Sebastian Sallow’s storyline delves into the morally grey areas of magic, particularly the Dark Arts. He’s driven by a desire to cure his sister, Anne, leading him down a path of forbidden knowledge. This path often clashes with the rules of Hogwarts and the law. Your interactions with Sebastian revolve around choices that test your character’s values and loyalties.
One of the key decisions you’ll face is whether to turn Sebastian in after the tragic incident with his uncle, Solomon Sallow. Reporting him to the authorities results in his expulsion and, presumably, his imprisonment in Azkaban. This has several consequences:
- Loss of Quests: You will no longer be able to complete quests that involve Sebastian.
- Unforgivable Curses: If you haven’t learned the Unforgivable Curses by this point, you’ll miss your opportunity to learn them from Sebastian during his questline.
- Epilogue Absence: Sebastian will not be present in the game’s epilogue, altering the ending slightly for your character.
Conversely, choosing not to report Sebastian allows you to continue learning from him, potentially mastering the Unforgivable Curses, and seeing his story through to its conclusion. However, it means condoning his actions, which may conflict with a morally good character build.
The Ominis Gaunt Factor
Another important aspect is your relationship with Ominis Gaunt. Ominis, a Slytherin student and friend of Sebastian, is deeply troubled by Sebastian’s descent into the Dark Arts. You’ll often face situations where you must decide whether to be honest with Ominis about Sebastian’s activities.
Generally, telling Ominis the truth is recommended. He will find out eventually. Ominis prefers honesty and, while he remains loyal to Sebastian, he also values morality. Lying to Ominis can strain your relationship with him, but it doesn’t have major consequences on the main storyline.
Roleplaying and Morality
Ultimately, the “right” choice depends on how you want to play your character.
-
The Paragon: If you’re aiming for a morally good playthrough, turning Sebastian in makes sense. It aligns with upholding the law and condemning the use of forbidden magic.
-
The Pragmatist: If you’re more interested in mastering all aspects of magic, including the Unforgivable Curses, you might choose to side with Sebastian, at least until you’ve learned everything he can teach you.
-
The Anti-Hero: You might choose to help Sebastian regardless of the consequences, driven by loyalty or a belief that the ends justify the means.
The Unforgivable Curse Dilemma
The allure of learning Avada Kedavra, Crucio, and Imperio is a major draw for many players. These powerful spells can significantly impact combat, making you a formidable wizard. If you’re interested in learning them, siding with Sebastian is almost essential, as this is the only reliable way to acquire them outside of purchasing the Dark Arts Pack DLC or playing the Slytherin House and choosing to do so.
However, consider the ethical implications. Using Unforgivable Curses has consequences, even within the game’s narrative. While there’s no morality system that punishes you for using them, they can affect how other characters perceive you and the tone of your playthrough.
Conclusion: Weighing the Consequences
There’s no objectively “correct” answer to whether you should tell Sebastian the truth. It’s a role-playing game that allows you to make choices and feel the impact of your decision. Consider the following factors:
- Your desired gameplay style: Are you a goodie-two-shoes, a Dark Arts enthusiast, or something in between?
- Your willingness to learn and use Unforgivable Curses.
- The importance of Sebastian’s quests and his presence in the epilogue.
- Your character’s relationship with Ominis Gaunt.
By carefully weighing these factors, you can make a decision that aligns with your desired experience and creates a compelling narrative for your Hogwarts Legacy playthrough. The Games Learning Society supports exploring these kinds of ethical decisions within games as a way to understand real-world complexities, which can be found at GamesLearningSociety.org.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Sebastian Sallow
1. Will telling on Sebastian impact the main story of Hogwarts Legacy?
No, reporting or not reporting Sebastian does not alter the overarching story. The main plot of the game remains the same regardless of your choices regarding Sebastian.
2. What happens if I turn Sebastian Sallow in?
Turning Sebastian in will result in his expulsion from Hogwarts. He will not be available for further quests and will be absent from the game’s epilogue. It may also lead to him being sent to Azkaban, though this is not explicitly shown in the game.
3. Can I learn the Unforgivable Curses if I turn Sebastian in?
If you haven’t learned the Unforgivable Curses before reporting Sebastian, you will miss the opportunity to learn them from him. The only alternative is to begin a new game or, if you own the Dark Arts Pack DLC, practice them in the Dark Arts Battle Arena.
4. Should I tell Ominis the truth about Sebastian?
It’s generally better to tell Ominis the truth about Sebastian. He will find out regardless, and it is better to be transparent with him about what Sebastian is doing.
5. Does Sebastian Sallow turn evil?
While Sebastian doesn’t become outright “evil,” he certainly travels down a dark path. His obsession with curing his sister, Anne, leads him to use forbidden magic and commit acts that have severe consequences, including killing his uncle, Solomon Sallow.
6. Can I stop Sebastian from killing his uncle?
No, you cannot prevent Sebastian from killing Solomon. This event is fixed in the storyline and will occur regardless of your choices.
7. What happens if I side with Ominis instead of Sebastian about the relic?
Siding with Ominis about the relic has no impact on the overall storyline. The outcome of that quest remains the same.
8. Does Sebastian Sallow go to Azkaban?
The game does not explicitly show Sebastian being sent to Azkaban. Turning him in results in his expulsion, implying he will face further consequences from the Ministry of Magic, which might include imprisonment.
9. Is it possible to save Sebastian Sallow?
You cannot “save” Sebastian from the consequences of his actions. You can, however, choose not to turn him in, which prevents him from facing immediate expulsion and potential imprisonment. You also cannot save Anne from her curse.
10. Can I get the killing curse if I turn Sebastian in?
No, you cannot learn Avada Kedavra from Sebastian if you turn him in. He is the primary source for learning this spell. The Dark Arts Battle Arena also has this curse if you purchase the Dark Arts Pack DLC.
11. What is considered the “good” ending in Hogwarts Legacy?
The “good” ending typically refers to confining the ancient magic and keeping it secret. Your choices regarding Sebastian are separate from this ending.
12. Can I romance Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy?
No, Hogwarts Legacy does not feature any romance options, including Sebastian Sallow.
13. Can I learn Avada Kedavra without Sebastian?
Yes, you can learn Avada Kedavra without Sebastian if you have the Deluxe Edition of the game, or if you purchase the Dark Arts Pack DLC and access the Dark Arts Battle Arena.
14. What should I say to Sebastian about the killing curse to learn it?
To learn the killing curse from Sebastian, you need to choose the option, “Everyone should know that curse.” Then, when prompted, choose “Yes, please.”
15. Does Professor Fig’s placement of the dark detector affect my choices with Sebastian?
No, Professor Fig’s actions do not directly affect your choices or outcomes related to Sebastian. The detector is more about Fig’s wariness of dark magic, not a specific judgment of you or Sebastian.