Should You Trust the Two Fingers in Elden Ring?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The Lands Between are a treacherous and enigmatic place, rife with conflicting ideologies and power struggles. At the heart of this conflict lie the Two Fingers, enigmatic entities that serve as the primary interface with the Greater Will. So, should you trust them? The answer is a resounding, it depends. Trust in the Two Fingers necessitates a deep understanding of their purpose, the motives of the Greater Will, and the alternative paths available to the Tarnished. Blind faith is rarely rewarded in Elden Ring, and aligning with the Two Fingers is no exception. They represent a specific vision for the Lands Between, one that may or may not align with your own desires or moral compass. Ultimately, the decision to trust the Two Fingers is a personal one, born from your own interpretation of the lore and your desired outcome for the game.
Understanding the Two Fingers and the Greater Will
The Two Fingers are essentially interpreters of the Greater Will’s inscrutable intentions. They communicate (or attempt to) a destined path to the Empyreans, those chosen to potentially become gods and restore the Elden Ring. However, this communication isn’t always clear, and the Fingers often fall silent, leaving many, like Enia in Roundtable Hold, waiting indefinitely for guidance. This silence, and the general lack of transparency surrounding the Greater Will, is a major cause for concern.
The Greater Will, as far as we can discern, seeks to maintain the Golden Order, a specific set of principles governing the Lands Between. This order emphasizes control, hierarchy, and a cyclical system of rebirth and death. But is this order inherently good? The game presents ample evidence to suggest otherwise. The Golden Order, enforced by the Greater Will, has led to stagnation, oppression, and the suffering of many inhabitants of the Lands Between.
Therefore, trusting the Two Fingers is tantamount to trusting the Greater Will and its vision for the future. Before pledging your allegiance, consider the consequences of maintaining the status quo, the potential for alternative, more equitable futures, and the true cost of order.
Examining the Alternatives
Elden Ring isn’t a game of simple good versus evil. Instead, it presents a spectrum of choices, each with its own merits and drawbacks. The Three Fingers, representing the Frenzied Flame, offer a radical alternative to the Golden Order. While seemingly destructive and chaotic, the Frenzied Flame promises to burn away the existing order and usher in an age of equality, albeit through immense suffering.
Then there’s Ranni the Witch, whose questline leads to the Age of Stars ending. This ending seeks to sever the influence of the Greater Will entirely, ushering in an age of freedom and self-determination, albeit one fraught with uncertainty.
Each of these paths presents a different vision for the future of the Lands Between, and each requires careful consideration. Before blindly following the path laid out by the Two Fingers, explore these alternatives and decide which best aligns with your own values and aspirations.
The Moral Ambiguity of Elden Ring
One of the most compelling aspects of Elden Ring is its moral ambiguity. There are no clear-cut heroes or villains, only individuals and entities pursuing their own goals, often at the expense of others. The Two Fingers, as representatives of the Greater Will, are no exception.
While they may believe they are acting in the best interests of the Lands Between, their actions often have unintended consequences, perpetuating a cycle of violence and oppression. Consider the Shattering, a direct result of the demigods vying for power after the Elden Ring was broken. This event, sanctioned by the Greater Will’s system of succession, plunged the Lands Between into chaos.
Therefore, trusting the Two Fingers requires a critical understanding of the complexities of the world and a willingness to question the motives of even the most seemingly benevolent entities. Remember, in the Lands Between, appearances can be deceiving, and true intentions are often shrouded in mystery. The Games Learning Society can provide a better understanding of the mechanics behind complex games like Elden Ring.
Making Your Choice
Ultimately, the decision of whether to trust the Two Fingers rests solely with you, the Tarnished. There’s no right or wrong answer, only choices with varying consequences. Take your time, explore the world, speak with its inhabitants, and uncover the truth behind the various factions vying for power. Only then can you make an informed decision about the future of the Lands Between and your own role in shaping it.
Consider these points before deciding:
- What are the long-term consequences of upholding the Golden Order?
- Are you willing to sacrifice individual freedom for the sake of order?
- Do you believe the Greater Will has the best interests of the Lands Between at heart?
- Are there alternative paths that offer a more equitable or desirable future?
- What is the cost of each ending, both in terms of individual sacrifice and societal impact?
Elden Ring offers a rich and rewarding experience for those willing to delve into its lore and grapple with its complex moral dilemmas. Choose wisely, Tarnished, for the fate of the Lands Between hangs in the balance. This game provides valuable insight into learning through problem-solving and the application of game mechanics, as noted by the GamesLearningSociety.org.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Are the Two Fingers inherently evil?
The Two Fingers are not inherently evil in the traditional sense, but their allegiance to the Greater Will and the Golden Order means they uphold a system that perpetuates suffering and inequality. Their actions are driven by a specific ideology, which may be seen as oppressive depending on your perspective.
2. What is the Greater Will’s ultimate goal?
The Greater Will’s ultimate goal is to maintain the Golden Order and ensure its continued dominance over the Lands Between. Its specific motives are largely unknown, but it appears to prioritize control and stability above all else.
3. Can I communicate directly with the Greater Will?
Direct communication with the Greater Will is not possible within the game. The Two Fingers serve as the intermediary, but their interpretation of the Greater Will’s intentions may be flawed or incomplete.
4. What happens if I choose not to follow the guidance of the Two Fingers?
Choosing not to follow the guidance of the Two Fingers opens up alternative questlines and endings, allowing you to shape the future of the Lands Between in your own way.
5. Is the Frenzied Flame a viable alternative to the Golden Order?
The Frenzied Flame is a radical alternative that promises to burn away the existing order and usher in an age of equality. However, this comes at the cost of immense suffering and destruction.
6. What is the Age of Stars ending?
The Age of Stars ending, achieved through Ranni’s questline, seeks to sever the influence of the Greater Will entirely, ushering in an age of freedom and self-determination, albeit one fraught with uncertainty.
7. Is Ranni a trustworthy character?
Ranni, like all characters in Elden Ring, is morally ambiguous. While her goals may be noble, her methods are often ruthless and her motivations are not always clear.
8. Can I change my mind after accepting the Frenzied Flame?
Once you accept the Frenzied Flame, you are locked into the Lord of Frenzied Flame ending, unless you undertake a specific and difficult questline to reverse the process.
9. What are the consequences of letting Melina sacrifice herself?
Letting Melina sacrifice herself allows you to maintain the status quo and potentially become Elden Lord, but it comes at the cost of her life and her disapproval.
10. Is there a “good” ending in Elden Ring?
Whether an ending is “good” is subjective and depends on your own values and aspirations. Each ending has its own merits and drawbacks, and none offer a perfect solution to the problems of the Lands Between.
11. What is the hardest ending to achieve?
The Lord of Frenzied Flame ending is generally considered the hardest to achieve due to the esoteric nature of the questline required.
12. How many endings are there in Elden Ring?
There are six main endings in Elden Ring, with variations based on specific choices made during the game.
13. Who is the Elden Beast?
The Elden Beast is the final boss of Elden Ring and a manifestation of the Greater Will’s power. It represents the ultimate challenge to becoming Elden Lord.
14. Why are fingers so important in Elden Ring?
Fingers are a symbolic representation of communication and authority in Elden Ring, particularly in the context of the Greater Will and its influence over the Lands Between.
15. What is the significance of Melina’s closed eye?
The significance of Melina’s closed eye is debated, but theories suggest it may be tied to the Dark Moon or Ranni’s influence, representing a hidden truth or a suppressed aspect of her being.