Pistols vs. Revolvers in Red Dead Redemption 2: Which Reigns Supreme?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The age-old question, debated around virtual campfires since the dawn of Red Dead Redemption 2: Should you holster a pistol or a revolver? The answer, as with most things in the Wild West, is “it depends.” There’s no single “best” sidearm. The ideal choice hinges on your playstyle, preferred combat range, and the specific challenges you face in the vast and untamed world of RDR2. Both pistols and revolvers offer unique advantages, and understanding these nuances is crucial to maximizing your effectiveness as a gunslinger. Ultimately, experiment and find what works best for you.
Revolver Rhapsody: Power and Precision
Revolvers, the quintessential weapons of the Old West, exude a rugged charm and boast undeniable firepower. Their strengths lie in:
- Damage: Revolvers, especially the Volcanic Pistol (though technically a pistol, it behaves like a super-powered revolver), deliver significantly more damage per shot than most pistols. This makes them ideal for dispatching enemies with fewer rounds, conserving ammunition, and delivering devastating headshots.
- Accuracy: Many revolvers offer superior accuracy, particularly at medium ranges. The Schofield Revolver, for example, is renowned for its precision, making it a reliable choice for picking off distant targets.
- Intimidation Factor: Let’s be honest, there’s something inherently cool about fanning the hammer of a revolver, and in RDR2, style matters!
- Reliability: While all firearms in RDR2 benefit from regular cleaning, revolvers are historically less prone to jamming than early semi-automatic pistols (though the game doesn’t explicitly simulate this).
However, revolvers also have their drawbacks:
- Fire Rate: Generally, revolvers have a slower rate of fire compared to pistols. This can be a disadvantage in close-quarters combat against multiple opponents.
- Reload Speed: Reloading a revolver is a more deliberate process than swapping a magazine in a pistol. This can leave you vulnerable during intense firefights.
- Ammo Capacity: Revolvers typically hold fewer rounds than pistols, requiring more frequent reloads.
Top Revolver Contenders
- Schofield Revolver: The gold standard for revolvers. It offers an excellent balance of damage, accuracy, and fire rate, making it a versatile choice for various combat scenarios. It’s available relatively early in the game (Chapter 2) and remains a viable option throughout the story.
- Volcanic Pistol: Despite its name, this is essentially a super-charged revolver. It boasts the highest damage output of any sidearm, coupled with exceptional accuracy. However, its slow fire rate and reload speed make it a niche weapon best suited for deliberate, calculated shots.
- Cattleman Revolver: Arthur’s (and the Van der Linde gang’s) “default” revolver. It’s a decent all-rounder and is available from the very start of the game. While it’s not the best at anything, it’s a reliable and affordable option, especially in the early chapters.
- LeMat Revolver: This beastly revolver holds a whopping nine rounds and features a secondary shotgun barrel! It’s a powerful and versatile weapon, but its slower reload speed and higher cost may deter some players.
Pistol Power: Speed and Sustained Fire
Pistols in RDR2 prioritize speed and volume of fire. Their strengths include:
- Fire Rate: Pistols, particularly the Mauser Pistol and the Semi-Automatic Pistol, offer a significantly faster rate of fire than revolvers. This allows you to quickly suppress enemies and deal sustained damage in close-quarters combat.
- Reload Speed: Pistols generally reload much faster than revolvers, thanks to their magazine-fed design. This reduces downtime during firefights and allows you to stay in the action.
- Ammo Capacity: Pistols typically hold more rounds than revolvers, allowing you to engage multiple enemies without frequent reloads.
However, pistols also have their weaknesses:
- Damage: Pistols generally inflict less damage per shot than revolvers. This means you’ll need to land more hits to take down enemies, potentially wasting ammunition.
- Accuracy: Some pistols can suffer from reduced accuracy, especially at longer ranges. This makes them less effective for picking off distant targets.
Top Pistol Picks
- Mauser Pistol: The king of fire rate. The Mauser boasts an incredibly fast rate of fire and a high ammo capacity, making it ideal for overwhelming enemies in close-quarters combat. Its main drawback is its lower damage output and somewhat poor accuracy at range. Billy Midnight’s variant of the Mauser Pistol is definitely worth picking up in “The Noblest Of Man, And A Woman” quest.
- Semi-Automatic Pistol: A balanced pistol that offers a good blend of fire rate, accuracy, and reload speed. It’s a versatile choice for various combat scenarios, offering a reliable and consistent performance.
- Midnight’s Pistol: Found during “The Noblest of Men, and a Woman” questline, this is the closest thing RDR2 has to a golden gun.
The Dual-Wielding Dilemma
Red Dead Redemption 2 allows you to dual-wield sidearms, opening up exciting tactical possibilities. The optimal dual-wielding setup depends on your playstyle and the situation:
- Double Revolvers: Maximize firepower and accuracy. Dual-wielding Schofield Revolvers, for example, provides devastating damage output at medium ranges.
- Double Pistols: Unleash a hail of bullets. Dual-wielding Mauser Pistols offers an unparalleled rate of fire for suppressing enemies in close-quarters combat.
- Revolver and Pistol Combo: A versatile option that combines the power of a revolver with the speed of a pistol. The Volcanic Pistol (right hand) and Schofield Revolver (left hand) combo is a popular choice, offering a balance of damage and accuracy.
Factors Beyond the Firearms
Beyond the raw stats of pistols and revolvers, several other factors influence your effectiveness in combat:
- Dead Eye: Mastering Dead Eye is crucial for maximizing your accuracy and damage output. This ability allows you to slow down time, target multiple enemies, and land precise shots, regardless of your chosen weapon.
- Weapon Maintenance: Regularly cleaning your firearms is essential for maintaining their performance. A dirty weapon will suffer from reduced accuracy and increased reload time.
- Ammunition Type: Different ammunition types offer varying levels of damage, penetration, and accuracy. Experiment with different ammo types to find what works best for your preferred weapons and combat style. For instance, Express rounds are generally a good choice for maximizing damage.
- Character Skills: As you progress through the game, Arthur’s skills will improve, enhancing his accuracy, reload speed, and other combat abilities. Repeated use of the same weapon will further enhance its stats.
The Verdict: A Matter of Preference
Ultimately, the choice between pistols and revolvers in Red Dead Redemption 2 comes down to personal preference and playstyle. If you prefer deliberate, accurate shots and prioritize damage output, revolvers are the way to go. If you prefer a faster rate of fire and sustained damage, pistols are a better choice. Experiment with different weapons, find what suits your style, and become a legend of the West. Remember to check out the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org for more insights on learning through games.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the best overall sidearm in RDR2 story mode?
There isn’t a single “best” sidearm, but the Schofield Revolver is widely considered the most versatile due to its excellent balance of damage, accuracy, and fire rate.
2. Is the Volcanic Pistol worth the high price?
Yes, if you value raw damage output and accuracy. The Volcanic Pistol inflicts the most damage of any sidearm, making it a powerhouse for taking down enemies with fewer shots.
3. How do I unlock the second holster for dual-wielding?
You unlock the second holster after completing the “Blessed Are The Meek?” quest.
4. Which pistol has the fastest fire rate?
The Mauser Pistol boasts the fastest rate of fire among all sidearms in RDR2.
5. Does weapon familiarity affect accuracy and reload speed?
Yes! The more you use a specific weapon, the more Arthur Morgan (or your Red Dead Online character) will improve in handling it, leading to enhanced accuracy and reload speed.
6. What’s the best ammunition type to use with revolvers?
Express rounds are generally recommended for revolvers to maximize their damage output.
7. How often should I clean my weapons?
Clean your weapons regularly, especially after prolonged use or exposure to the elements. A dirty weapon will suffer from reduced accuracy and increased reload time.
8. Can I customize my sidearms?
Yes, you can customize your sidearms at gunsmiths with different engravings, grips, and finishes. These customizations are purely cosmetic.
9. Is it better to dual-wield revolvers or pistols?
It depends on your playstyle. Dual-wielding revolvers maximizes firepower, while dual-wielding pistols maximizes fire rate.
10. What is Arthur Morgan’s preferred weapon?
While Arthur uses many guns, the Cattleman Revolver is the most common sidearm used by the Van der Linde gang.
11. How do I get Midnight’s Pistol?
You acquire Midnight’s Pistol by completing the “The Noblest Of Man, And A Woman” quest.
12. Which is easier to use, a revolver or a pistol?
Revolvers are often considered easier to use in high-stress situations due to their simpler design and lower likelihood of jamming.
13. Do revolvers have more recoil than pistols?
Generally, yes. Revolvers transmit more felt recoil to the user because semi-automatic actions absorb some of the rearward force.
14. Which is a good choice to use as a hunting sidearm?
The Mauser is good for hunting smaller animals because it is fast to reload and has a lot of ammo. The semi-auto is more accurate, but has less ammo.
15. What’s the best sidearm combo for dual wielding?
The Volcanic Pistol in one hand and Schofield in the other is great. The Volcanic offers high damage, while the Schofield is an all-around great weapon.