Should I Wish for Ayaka or Raiden? A Comprehensive Genshin Impact Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The age-old question plagues every Genshin Impact player during their respective banners: Ayaka or Raiden? Both are incredibly powerful, meta-defining characters capable of carrying teams through the toughest content the game has to offer. So, who should you pull for?
The straightforward answer is: it depends on your current team composition, desired playstyle, and future team-building plans. If you desperately need a hypercarry and prefer a freeze-centric team that delivers consistent, high Cryo damage, then Ayaka is the better choice. Her ability to infuse her attacks with Cryo makes her a dominant force in permafreeze teams, which control enemies and deal massive damage. However, if you need a versatile character who can function as a hypercarry, sub-DPS, or battery for your team, providing significant Energy Recharge and amplifying damage with her Elemental Burst, then Raiden Shogun is the more valuable pick. Raiden excels in multiple team compositions, making her a consistently strong and future-proof investment. Ultimately, Raiden is the safer, generally more impactful choice for most players.
Ayaka: The Cryo Queen of Inazuma
Ayaka is a Cryo DPS character who specializes in dealing consistent, high damage with her Cryo-infused Normal Attacks and her devastating Elemental Burst. Her unique Alternate Sprint allows her to apply Cryo to enemies effortlessly and provides a significant damage bonus upon reappearing.
Ayaka’s Strengths:
- Exceptional Cryo DMG: Her Cryo infusion, combined with artifacts like the 4-piece Blizzard Strayer set, maximizes her Cryo damage output.
- Permafreeze Potential: She excels in permafreeze teams, synergizing well with Hydro applicators like Xingqiu, Mona, and Kokomi.
- High Single-Target DMG: While she also has AoE capabilities, her damage is especially potent against single targets, making her effective against bosses.
- Accessibility: While she benefits from her signature weapon, she can still perform exceptionally well with craftable options and other 4-star weapons.
Ayaka’s Weaknesses:
- Energy Dependence: Her Elemental Burst is crucial for her damage output, requiring efficient Energy Recharge management.
- Burst Reliant: Most of her damage comes from her Elemental Burst, so missing it can severely impact her damage potential.
- Limited Team Compositions: Her reliance on Cryo makes her less flexible in team building compared to Raiden.
- Mobility Issues: The Alternate Sprint requires good control as it can make her vulnerable if not used correctly.
Ideal Ayaka Team Compositions:
- Permafreeze: Ayaka, Xingqiu/Yelan, Kazuha, Diona/Layla
- Mono Cryo: Ayaka, Shenhe, Kazuha, Kokomi
Raiden Shogun: The Electro Archon and Energy Battery
Raiden Shogun is an Electro character known for her versatility and ability to provide both high damage and Energy Recharge to her team. Her Elemental Burst allows her to deal significant Electro damage while simultaneously restoring Energy to the entire party, making her invaluable in many team compositions.
Raiden’s Strengths:
- Versatility: She can function as a Main DPS, Sub-DPS, or Energy Battery, fitting into various team archetypes.
- Energy Recharge: Her Burst restores Energy to the entire team, making her incredibly valuable for teams with high Energy costs.
- Consistent DMG: Her Electro application enables consistent Electro-related reactions.
- Future-Proof: Her kit is designed in a way that will most likely be relevant for a long time.
Raiden’s Weaknesses:
- Burst Dependent: While she’s more flexible than Ayaka, her damage still relies heavily on her Elemental Burst.
- Limited Normal Attack Scaling: Outside of her Burst, her Normal Attack scaling is relatively low.
- Synergy Conflicts: Some characters like Beidou have synergy issues with Raiden because Raiden’s Burst counts as Burst damage, and not normal attack damage.
Ideal Raiden Team Compositions:
- Raiden National: Raiden Shogun, Xiangling, Xingqiu, Bennett
- Raiden Hypercarry: Raiden Shogun, Kujou Sara, Kazuha/Sucrose, Bennett
- Electro-Charged: Raiden Shogun, Yae Miko, Kokomi, Kazuha
Making the Decision: Ayaka or Raiden?
Consider these points when making your decision:
- Your Current Roster: Do you already have a strong Cryo DPS like Ganyu? Do you have a reliable Energy Battery or need one?
- Your Preferred Playstyle: Do you enjoy the control and consistent damage of permafreeze teams, or do you prefer more flexible team compositions?
- Your Investment Level: Are you willing to invest heavily in specific weapons and artifacts to maximize either character’s potential?
- Future Characters: Do you have any upcoming characters in mind who might synergize better with either Ayaka or Raiden?
If you’re still unsure, Raiden is generally the safer pick because of her versatility. However, if you’re committed to building a permafreeze team and love Ayaka’s playstyle, she can be an incredibly powerful asset.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is Ayaka a “must-pull” character?
No, Ayaka is not a “must-pull” character in the sense that you can’t clear content without her. However, she is undoubtedly one of the strongest DPS characters in the game, and if you enjoy her playstyle and have the resources to invest in her, she’s definitely worth pulling.
2. Is Raiden Shogun a “must-pull” character?
Raiden Shogun is much closer to being a “must-pull” character than Ayaka due to her incredible versatility and Energy Recharge capabilities. She is a strong addition to many teams and can significantly improve your account’s overall strength.
3. Can Ayaka and Raiden Shogun be used on the same team?
While technically possible, Ayaka and Raiden Shogun don’t have strong synergy. The Electro application from Raiden doesn’t benefit Ayaka’s Cryo-focused teams, and vice-versa. There are better team options for both characters. The article actually disagrees with itself, since it says earlier to pull Ayaka if you have a team of Kazuha, Mona, and Ghongli.
4. Which character is better at C0 (Constellation 0)?
At C0, Ayaka generally deals more damage than Raiden Shogun, when built correctly, particularly in a dedicated freeze team. However, Raiden’s versatility and Energy Recharge make her valuable even at C0.
5. Which character benefits more from constellations?
Both characters benefit significantly from constellations. Ayaka’s C4 reduces enemy DEF, increasing her DMG potential. Raiden’s C2 is considered one of the most powerful constellations in the game, greatly increasing her DPS. The value is subjective, but many consider Raiden’s C2 to be better.
6. What are the best weapons for Ayaka?
Her best weapon is her signature weapon, Mistsplitter Reforged. However, good alternatives include the Primordial Jade Cutter, Haran Geppaku Futsu, and even the craftable Amenoma Kageuchi.
7. What are the best weapons for Raiden Shogun?
Her best weapon is her signature weapon, Engulfing Lightning. Other good options include Staff of Homa, Skyward Spine, and The Catch (a F2P option).
8. What artifact sets are best for Ayaka?
The 4-piece Blizzard Strayer is the undisputed best-in-slot artifact set for Ayaka, maximizing her Cryo DMG and Crit Rate against frozen enemies.
9. What artifact sets are best for Raiden Shogun?
The 4-piece Emblem of Severed Fate is the best artifact set for Raiden Shogun, increasing her Energy Recharge and Elemental Burst DMG.
10. Is Ayaka worth pulling in 2024?
Yes, Ayaka is still an excellent character and worth pulling in 2024 if you enjoy her playstyle and need a strong Cryo DPS. Her performance in the Spiral Abyss remains top-tier.
11. Is Raiden Shogun worth pulling in 2024?
Absolutely. Raiden Shogun remains a highly valuable and versatile character in 2024. Her ability to provide Energy Recharge and amplify damage makes her a consistent and future-proof choice.
12. How does Raiden Shogun improve a team?
Raiden Shogun improves a team by providing significant Energy Recharge, which allows other characters to use their Elemental Bursts more frequently. She also amplifies the damage of her teammates’ Bursts and deals substantial damage herself during her Burst duration.
13. Is Raiden Shogun hard to build?
Raiden Shogun is relatively easy to build. The most important stats are Energy Recharge, Crit Rate, and Crit DMG. A good weapon like “The Catch” and the Emblem of Severed Fate artifact set make her accessible to most players.
14. What is the best way to use Ayaka’s Alternate Sprint?
The best way to use Ayaka’s Alternate Sprint is to time it carefully to apply Cryo to enemies, avoid damage, and position yourself for optimal attacks. Practice using it to get a feel for the timing and distance.
15. Where can I learn more about Genshin Impact strategy and team building?
There are many resources available online, including guides, videos, and community forums. Learning about game mechanics can be made fun by reading the Games Learning Society, which offers a framework for exploring fun and education: GamesLearningSociety.org.
Conclusion
Ultimately, choosing between Ayaka and Raiden Shogun depends on your individual needs and preferences. Both are incredibly powerful characters who can significantly enhance your Genshin Impact experience. Consider your current roster, preferred playstyle, and future team-building plans to make the best decision for your account. Whichever you choose, you will not regret pulling for these characters!