Squirtle vs. Bulbasaur: The Ultimate Kanto Starter Showdown
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Choosing your first Pokémon is a rite of passage. For many, that journey begins in the Kanto region, with Professor Oak presenting you with a choice that will define your early game experience: Squirtle, the water-type turtle Pokémon, or Bulbasaur, the grass/poison-type seed Pokémon. While Charmander, the fire-type lizard, often steals the spotlight, the real strategic decision lies between these two.
So, should you choose Squirtle or Bulbasaur? The answer, as with most things Pokémon, depends on your play style and priorities. However, for new players and those seeking an easier early game, Bulbasaur is generally the superior choice. Its type advantages against the first two gym leaders, Brock (Rock-type) and Misty (Water-type), provide a significant head start. While Squirtle can handle Brock adequately, Misty poses a much greater challenge.
That said, experienced players might favor Squirtle for its late-game potential and well-rounded stats. Ultimately, both are excellent Pokémon capable of carrying you through the game, so consider the nuances outlined below before making your decision.
Early Game Domination: Bulbasaur’s Advantage
The early game in Pokémon Red, Blue, and Yellow (and their remakes FireRed and LeafGreen) can be surprisingly challenging, especially for newcomers. Bulbasaur shines during this period.
Triumphant Against Tough Gyms
As mentioned, Bulbasaur’s Grass-type attacks are super effective against both Brock’s Rock-types and Misty’s Water-types. This means you can breeze through the first two gyms with relative ease, earning badges and valuable experience. Squirtle can handle Brock’s Geodude and Onix with Water-type moves, but faces a tougher challenge against Misty’s Staryu and Starmie due to their high Special stat and potential for Water Absorb.
Navigating the Early Routes
Outside the gyms, Bulbasaur’s dual-typing is beneficial against many early-game Pokémon, such as those found in Viridian Forest and on Route 3. Poison-type moves like Poison Powder can inflict status conditions, while Grass-type moves like Vine Whip provide solid damage.
Overcoming Team Rocket in Moon Mountain
According to the article above, one of Bulbasaur’s greatest strengths is that it can “cut a path through Moon Mountain like a lawnmower”. In the same vein, Bulbasaur is effective against the various Pokémon used by Team Rocket, such as Poison-type and Ground-type.
Late-Game Viability: Squirtle’s Resurgence
While Bulbasaur dominates the early game, Squirtle becomes a more formidable force as the game progresses.
Balanced Stats and Movepool
Squirtle boasts balanced stats, making it a versatile Pokémon capable of handling various threats. It learns a variety of Water-type moves, including Surf, Hydro Pump, and Ice Beam (via TM), providing excellent coverage against different types.
Resilience Against Powerful Opponents
As Blastoise, Squirtle’s final evolution, it possesses high Defense and Special Defense, making it resistant to physical and special attacks. This allows it to withstand powerful attacks from gym leaders and the Elite Four.
Less Type Weakness in the Elite Four
Although Squirtle might not have a massive type advantage against the Elite Four, research suggests it has less not very effective tendencies against those same trainers than Bulbasaur and Charmander.
Consider These Factors Before Choosing
Beyond the type advantages and stats, several other factors can influence your decision.
- Your Previous Pokémon Experience: If you’re new to Pokémon, Bulbasaur’s easier early game can be a significant advantage. Experienced players might enjoy the challenge of Squirtle’s more balanced approach.
- Your Play Style: Do you prefer a straightforward, type-advantage-based strategy, or a more versatile approach? Bulbasaur favors the former, while Squirtle allows for greater flexibility.
- Your Team Composition: Consider the other Pokémon you plan to use on your team. If you already have a strong Water-type, Bulbasaur might be a better choice to diversify your team.
- Personal Preference: Ultimately, the best starter Pokémon is the one you enjoy using the most. Don’t be afraid to choose based on your favorite design or personality.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is Squirtle better than Bulbasaur in Pokémon FireRed/LeafGreen?
There’s no universally “better” starter. Bulbasaur excels in the early game, making the first two gyms easier. Squirtle is more balanced and becomes stronger later on. Choose based on your play style and experience.
2. Which starter is the easiest to use for a beginner in Pokémon Red/Blue/Yellow?
Bulbasaur is generally considered the easiest starter for beginners due to its type advantages against the first two gym leaders.
3. Does Squirtle evolve into a strong Pokémon?
Yes, Squirtle evolves into Wartortle and then Blastoise, which is a powerful Water-type Pokémon with high defense and special defense.
4. Can Bulbasaur learn Surf?
No, Bulbasaur cannot learn Surf. Only Water-type Pokémon and some other specific Pokémon can learn it.
5. Is Bulbasaur good in the late game?
Bulbasaur’s usefulness diminishes slightly in the late game compared to the early game, but it can still be a valuable member of your team with its Grass and Poison-type moves. It does have an advantage against the Tower of Water, according to the source article.
6. Does the choice of starter affect the storyline?
No, the choice of starter does not affect the storyline in Pokémon Red, Blue, Yellow, FireRed, or LeafGreen.
7. Which gym leaders are Squirtle effective against?
Squirtle is effective against Brock (Rock-type), but has a harder time against Misty (Water-type). It’s neutral against Lt. Surge (Electric-type), effective against Blaine (Fire-type) and neutral against Giovanni (Ground-type).
8. What are Bulbasaur’s weaknesses?
Bulbasaur is weak to Fire, Flying, Psychic, and Ice-type moves.
9. Can I get the other starters in the game if I don’t choose them at the beginning?
Yes, you can obtain the other starters later in the game. After beating Erika at the Celadon City Gym, the player can get Bulbasaur. And after defeating Koga at the Fuchsia City Gym, the player can get Squirtle. The third starter, Charmander, is accessible by beating Lt. Surge at the Vermilion City Gym.
10. What is the best moveset for Blastoise?
A good moveset for Blastoise includes Surf (or Hydro Pump), Ice Beam, Earthquake, and Rapid Spin. This provides good type coverage and utility.
11. What is the best nature for Bulbasaur?
The best nature for Bulbasaur and its evolutions, Ivysaur and Venusaur, is Modest (increases Special Attack, decreases Attack) or Timid (increases Speed, decreases Attack). This enhances its special attacking capabilities.
12. Can I solo the game with Bulbasaur or Squirtle?
Yes, it’s possible to solo the game with either Bulbasaur or Squirtle, although it may be challenging. You’ll need to strategize carefully and utilize type advantages effectively.
13. Is Venusaur a good Pokémon to use competitively?
Venusaur can be a viable choice in competitive play, especially with its Mega Evolution, which boosts its stats and ability. Its Chlorophyll ability in sunny weather allows it to outspeed many opponents.
14. How does Mega Blastoise compare to regular Blastoise?
Mega Blastoise has significantly higher stats than regular Blastoise, making it a much more powerful Pokémon. Its Mega Launcher ability also boosts the power of pulse moves like Aura Sphere and Dark Pulse.
15. Are there any real world applications of learning about Pokémon?
Absolutely! Beyond the fun and engagement, Pokémon teaches valuable strategic thinking, resource management, and pattern recognition skills. The Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org explores the educational potential of games like Pokémon, highlighting how they can foster critical thinking and problem-solving abilities.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the choice between Squirtle and Bulbasaur comes down to personal preference and play style. Bulbasaur’s early game dominance makes it an excellent choice for new players, while Squirtle’s balanced stats and late-game potential appeal to more experienced trainers. Consider the factors outlined above, and choose the Pokémon that resonates with you the most. After all, the journey is just as important as the destination in the world of Pokémon!