The Witcher 3: Blood and Wine – Syanna or Orianna? Decoding the Choices and Consequences
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The quest “Blood and Wine” in The Witcher 3 presents players with a crucial choice that significantly impacts the ending: should you free Syanna or seek out Orianna? The answer, like many things in The Witcher 3, isn’t straightforward. It depends on what kind of ending you’re aiming for. Seeking out Orianna first unlocks the path to the “good” ending, where both sisters, Anna Henrietta and Syanna, survive. However, this path requires specific actions and dialogue choices. Choosing to free Syanna directly leads to different outcomes, some potentially tragic. Ultimately, the “best” choice is subjective and hinges on your personal values and desired narrative outcome. Let’s dive into the details.
Understanding the Critical Decision
The decision to either free Syanna or seek out Orianna occurs after the vampire attack in Beauclair. Regis presents Geralt with the choice: track down Syanna, the likely orchestrator of the attacks, or seek information from Orianna, a powerful vampire with knowledge of the Unseen Elder, who may be able to stop the attacks.
The Orianna Path: A Chance at Redemption
Choosing Orianna is the more involved and arguably more rewarding path. It unlocks the quest “Beyond Hill and Dale,” which takes Geralt into a fantastical, storybook world. Inside this world, you have the opportunity to:
- Learn Syanna’s side of the story: Understand the motivations behind her actions.
- Obtain the Ribbon: This crucial item, acquired by winning a Gwent match against the Little Flint Girl, protects Syanna from Dettlaff’s final strike.
- Set the Stage for Forgiveness: This path gives you a chance to convince Syanna to forgive Anna Henrietta for past grievances.
Successfully navigating this path and obtaining the ribbon sets the stage for the best possible ending, where both sisters reconcile and survive. However, it requires careful dialogue choices during the final confrontation.
The Syanna Path: A Direct Confrontation
Choosing to free Syanna leads you directly to her, bypassing the Land of Fables and the opportunity to obtain the ribbon. This path typically results in a more tragic ending. If you choose to have Syanna meet Dettlaff without having the ribbon, she will likely be killed, leading to either Dettlaff’s death or, if you spare him, Geralt’s imprisonment.
The Importance of the Ribbon
The enchanted ribbon is the key to Syanna’s survival. Without it, Dettlaff will kill her, regardless of your choices. This emphasizes the importance of the Orianna path if you are aiming for the “good” ending. The ribbon essentially acts as plot armor, shielding Syanna from Dettlaff’s wrath.
Consequences of Your Choices
The consequences of your decision ripple through the ending of “Blood and Wine,” impacting the fates of Syanna, Anna Henrietta, Dettlaff, and even Geralt himself.
The “Good” Ending: Reconciliation and Peace
Achieved by:
- Taking the Orianna path
- Acquiring the ribbon
- Convincing Syanna to forgive Anna Henrietta
This ending sees both sisters reconcile and survive, bringing peace to Toussaint. It’s considered the “best” ending by many, as it fulfills the desire for a happy resolution.
The “Bittersweet” Ending: Justice and Loss
Achieved by:
- Taking the Orianna path
- Acquiring the ribbon
- Failing to convince Syanna to forgive Anna Henrietta
In this scenario, Syanna is protected by the ribbon, but she still attempts to assassinate Anna Henrietta. Geralt must then decide whether to reveal Syanna’s intentions to Anna Henrietta. Depending on that choice, either Syanna is executed, or both sisters die. It brings justice but at the cost of the sisters’ relationship or lives.
The “Tragic” Ending: Death and Imprisonment
Achieved by:
- Taking the Syanna path
- Having Syanna meet Dettlaff without the ribbon
This ending is the most bleak. Dettlaff kills Syanna, and Geralt is imprisoned. Dandelion eventually rescues Geralt, but the ending is marked by loss and despair.
FAQs: Decoding the Nuances of Blood and Wine
Here are 15 frequently asked questions to help you navigate the complexities of Blood and Wine and make informed choices:
1. Can you save both Dettlaff and Syanna?
No, it is impossible to save both Dettlaff and Syanna. Dettlaff can only live if you let him kill Syanna and then don’t fight him. However, this results in a very dark ending for Geralt, with Anna Henrietta heartbroken and Toussaint left with a dangerous vampire still at large.
2. Is it better to free Syanna or fight Dettlaff?
Whether it’s “better” to free Syanna or fight Dettlaff depends on your desired outcome. Freeing Syanna (without the ribbon) leads to her death and potentially a tragic ending. Fighting Dettlaff is necessary to achieve the “good” ending.
3. Does sleeping with Syanna affect anything?
No, romancing Syanna has no impact on the rest of the game and doesn’t affect other romance options with Triss or Yennefer. It’s a self-contained encounter within the Blood and Wine storyline.
4. What happens if you let Dettlaff go?
If you let Dettlaff go after he kills Syanna, Regis will be exiled from Toussaint to maintain the peace between humans and vampires. Geralt will go to prison, and Dandelion eventually comes to the rescue.
5. Should you save Dettlaff?
Whether you “should” save Dettlaff is a matter of personal ethics. He committed terrible acts, but he was also manipulated. However, letting him live comes at the cost of Syanna’s life and risks future attacks.
6. Can you finish Blood and Wine without killing Dettlaff?
Yes, you can finish Blood and Wine without killing Dettlaff by allowing him to kill Syanna and then choosing not to fight him. However, this results in a very unsatisfactory and morally questionable ending.
7. How do you save both sisters in Blood and Wine?
To save both sisters, you must:
- Go to Orianna.
- Enter the Land of Fables.
- Obtain the ribbon from the Little Flint Girl.
- Convince Syanna to forgive Anna Henrietta.
8. How do you stop Syanna from killing the Duchess?
During the ceremony, reveal Syanna’s true intentions to Anna Henrietta. Express your opinion that Syanna is guilty but should be shown mercy. Successfully navigating this dialogue can lead to reconciliation.
9. Is Dettlaff more powerful than Geralt?
Dettlaff is one of the most powerful beings Geralt faces in The Witcher 3. While Geralt can defeat him, it’s a challenging and arduous fight, suggesting Dettlaff’s superior raw power.
10. Should I get Syanna the ribbon?
Yes, if you want the “good” ending where both sisters survive, getting the ribbon is essential. It protects Syanna from Dettlaff’s final blow.
11. Is Orianna a higher vampire?
Yes, Orianna is a higher vampire, as evidenced by her powers and abilities. Her existence is intertwined with the darker aspects of vampire society in Toussaint.
12. Should I tell the Duchess about Syanna?
Yes, you must inform the Duchess of Syanna’s intentions to trigger the reconciliation sequence. This allows you to try and convince Syanna to forgive her sister.
13. Is Dettlaff a good guy?
Dettlaff is not a “good guy.” While he was manipulated by Syanna, he chose to unleash his rage on innocent people, making him responsible for his actions.
14. Should you do Blood and Wine after the main quest?
It is recommended to play Blood and Wine after completing the main quest of The Witcher 3 and Hearts of Stone. This allows you to fully appreciate Geralt’s character development and the themes explored in the expansion.
15. What is the best ending in The Witcher 3?
The “best” ending is subjective, but many consider the ending where Ciri becomes a witcher to be the most satisfying. In Blood and Wine, the ending where both Syanna and Anna Henrietta reconcile is widely regarded as the optimal outcome. The impact of video games is a fascinating area of study, if you want to know more, check out the Games Learning Society at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.
Making Your Choice
Ultimately, the choice between freeing Syanna and seeking out Orianna is a deeply personal one. Consider what outcome aligns with your Geralt’s values and the kind of story you want to experience. The world of The Witcher 3 is rich with moral ambiguity, and Blood and Wine is no exception. Embrace the complexity, make your choice, and face the consequences.