Should you free the thing under the tree Witcher 3?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The decision to free the thing under the tree in Witcher 3 is a complex one, as it ultimately comes down to a moral choice between saving the orphans and protecting the village of Downwarren, with no clear “best” choice. By freeing the tree spirit, you will be saving the orphans from being eaten by the Crones, but at the cost of destroying the village and its inhabitants, highlighting the difficult moral dilemmas that are characteristic of the Witcher series.
Understanding the Consequences
To make an informed decision, it’s essential to understand the consequences of freeing the tree spirit versus killing it.
Related FAQs
1. What happens if you free the spirit in the whispering hillock?
If you free the creature, it destroys the nearby village of Downwarren. The orphans escape into the swamp, but locals believe they will die alone out there. Gran, who is the Baron’s wife, Anna, will be transformed into a Water Hag and ultimately die.
2. Should I free the tree spirit or not?
If you agree to free the tree spirit, she will agree to help you and will save the orphans, but she will destroy the village (and the villagers) nearby. If you refuse to free her and kill her instead, the village will remain intact and the villagers will live, but the orphans will die.
3. Is the tree spirit evil Witcher 3?
It involves an evil spirit inside a tree (which might not be so evil after all depending on your point of view). Go inside the cave and dive beneath the roots. Pop back up and walk deeper into the cave. The source of the voice is revealed as a creepy tree spirit.
4. What is the best outcome for the Ladies of the Wood?
While there’s no clear “best” choice, you are able to save more lives by choosing to kill the spirit rather than free it, but it is up to you whether or not those lives are actually worth saving.
5. What happens if I don’t free the tree spirit in Witcher 3?
If you agree to free the tree spirit, she will agree to help you and will save the orphans, but she will destroy the village (and the villagers) nearby. If you refuse to free her and kill her instead, the village will remain intact and the villagers will live, but the orphans will die.
6. Should I free the spirit in the whispering hillock?
If you free the creature, it destroys the nearby village of Downwarren. The orphans escape into the swamp, but locals believe they will die alone out there. Gran, who is the Baron’s wife, Anna, will be transformed into a Water Hag and ultimately die.
7. Can you free the spirit and save Anna?
IF you have not seen the Crones yet, you can kill or free the spirit and Anna will be spared, because she hasn’t (in their eyes) broken any promise, which is what happens if you speak to them and then let the spirit go.
8. What are the consequences of the whispering hillock choices?
The Consequences: If you choose to release the spirit, it’ll hold up its end of the agreed bargain and whisk the orphans away from the Crones, ultimately saving them from becoming a meal. You can find them later under the care of Marabella in Novigrad.
9. Should I free the whispering hillock in Witcher 3?
If you free the creature, it destroys the nearby village of Downwarren. The orphans escape into the swamp, but locals believe they will die alone out there. Gran, who is the Baron’s wife, Anna, will be transformed into a Water Hag and ultimately die.
10. How do you save Anna and orphans?
Killing the Crones and freeing the spirit will save the children (and Anna). However, this comes with a price: the people of downwarren village will be slaughtered. There is no black or white outcome, you should decide between the lesser evil, following the philosophy of the Witcher books.
11. How do you save the Baron’s wife?
1) Free the tree spirit, so she can save the orphan, but at the same time she destroys a nearby village. 2) Kill the spirit, the orphans are eaten… but the Baron’s wife/family is safe, and the nearby village is safe too.
12. What did the Crones do to the kids?
People from Velen who were unable to feed their children would also send their children on the ‘sweet path’ which led to a village in the bog. There, the children were expected by the Crones who gave them food. However, once the children were fed they would eventually be eaten by the Crones.
13. Should I help the Crones or the tree?
Which should you choose? There’s no clean or tidy outcome for this quest, but the most generally positive solution is to kill the Ghost in the Tree.
14. Can the bloody baron survive?
The Baron Dies: For the Baron to perish after the events of “Return to Crookback Bog,” all Geralt needs to do is release the spirit in the tree during “The Whispering Hillock.” While this decision guarantees The Baron’s demise, Geralt will affect exactly how it all plays out.
15. What happens if you trick the tree in Witcher 3?
If you choose to trick it, Geralt will start the ritual but then refuse to stab the heart, letting the spirit die without a fight, finishing the quest. If you changed your mind completely and wish to kill it, a fight will break out like if you had chosen to kill it before gathering all the required items.