Should You Hand Damien Over to Carl in Dying Light 2? A Moral Quandary
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The city of Villedor in Dying Light 2 throws you into a world rife with difficult choices, and the “Missing Persons” side quest presents one of the most agonizing: should you hand Damien over to Carl, or should you cooperate with him? The short answer is a resounding NO. Turning Damien over to Carl ends the quest prematurely and results in Damien’s death. Cooperating with Damien, though morally ambiguous, allows you to complete the questline and potentially save him. It’s a decision that forces you to weigh the consequences of your actions against the potential for a “better” outcome in a world desperately short on hope.
The Consequences of Your Choice
Handing Damien Over to Carl
The game makes it clear that if you choose to hand Damien over, the mission ends immediately. Damien faces lethal punishment for his crimes, and you lose the opportunity to explore the full story and potentially influence its outcome. From a gameplay perspective, you miss out on quest rewards and narrative depth. More importantly, from a moral standpoint, you become an instrument of Carl’s justice, even if that “justice” is brutal and potentially misinformed.
Cooperating with Damien
Cooperating with Damien opens up the full questline, allowing you to aid him in his search for his brother, Cliff. This path is fraught with its own ethical considerations, as Damien is undeniably involved in questionable activities. However, it provides you with the chance to learn more about the situation, potentially uncover hidden truths, and possibly influence Damien’s fate. In essence, you gain agency and the ability to shape the narrative.
Saving Damien: A Guide
Even after deciding to cooperate, Damien’s life isn’t guaranteed. Later in the quest, during a key scene, you’ll be presented with the option to interrupt Damien. You absolutely should interrupt him. If you do nothing, Damien will incriminate himself, leading to a grim fate.
Further down the line, Damien becomes suicidal. Talk him out of it! Choosing the dialogue options that emphasize the value of life and offering a shared pact will prevent him from taking his own life.
FAQs: Navigating the Moral Maze of Dying Light 2
Here are some frequently asked questions to help you navigate the complexities of Dying Light 2 and its difficult choices:
1. Is it possible to save Damien in Dying Light 2?
Yes, it is possible to save Damien. You need to cooperate with him throughout the “Missing Persons” side quest, interrupt him during a crucial scene where he’s about to admit his guilt, and talk him out of suicide.
2. What happens if I let Damien jump?
If you let Damien jump, the quest will likely fail, and you’ll miss out on the rewards and the narrative resolution. It’s a definitively negative outcome.
3. Who is Carl in relation to Damien?
Carl is likely a person seeking justice or revenge against Damien for his actions. The exact nature of their relationship and Carl’s motives are revealed through the questline.
4. Are there any missable side quests in Dying Light 2?
Yes, there are missable side quests. It’s recommended to complete side quests as they appear on the map before progressing through the main story. Getting close to areas can trigger hidden side quests.
5. What are the best choices for the “good” ending in Dying Light 2?
The “good” ending is subjective, but many consider it to be keeping Hakon alive, giving the VNC Tower to Frank, saving Mia, and letting Lawan detonate the missiles.
6. Is there a canon ending for Dying Light 2?
Dying Light 2 strongly implies that the Infected Option is canon, because the Nuclear Option would have presumably prevented the spread of the virus.
7. Should I trust Sophie in Dying Light 2?
The decision to trust Sophie is complex and depends on your preferred faction alignment. Siding with her leads to the Survivor faction’s storyline, which involves taking the Water Tower.
8. Who killed Lucas in Dying Light 2?
Hakon reveals that he killed Lucas. Your reaction to this revelation and your subsequent actions will influence your relationship with Hakon.
9. Should I save Aitor or side with Sophie?
Both choices ultimately lead to the Water Tower quest. Siding with either Aitor or Sophie won’t drastically alter the overall outcome. The best choice boils down to personal preference and faction alignment. Saving Aitor nets better rewards overall.
10. What happens if Aiden becomes fully infected?
Aiden can enter a “Volatile Mode” when fully infected. You will become stronger and faster, but your time will be limited.
11. Who should I save: Lawan or Mia?
Saving Lawan is considered the bad ending of Dying Light 2 and letting her detonate the bombs gives players the good ending in Dying Light 2.
12. How do I get the secret good ending in Dying Light 2?
To get the secret good ending spare Hakon in Old Villedor, give the radio tower to Frank, save Frank in Breakthrough, spare Hakon and stop Lawan from killing him in No Mercy, and Let Lawan Detonate The Bombs In X13.
13. Can you talk the dodger out of turning you in?
No, you can’t. If you want to complete the quest, you have to go along with Dodger’s plan and inform on Hubert or stay silent about it. Either way, you’ll learn that Dodger’s thugs were the ones who jumped you in the parking lot.
14. Where is the missing supplier?
Hubert can be found on a tall set of buildings that border Trinity and Houndfield to the immediate northwest, between the Rooftop School and Trading Post settlements.
15. Are Mia and Aiden siblings?
Mia and Aiden aren’t related and that she was Waltz’ daughter,
Dying Light 2: Choices and Consequences
The decision to hand Damien over to Carl is just one example of the many difficult choices you’ll face in Dying Light 2. The game constantly challenges your moral compass, forcing you to weigh the potential consequences of your actions and consider the lesser of two evils. There’s rarely a “right” answer, and the ambiguity is what makes the game so compelling. Embrace the grey areas, consider the long-term implications, and make choices that align with your own sense of justice and morality.
Games like Dying Light 2 offer more than just entertainment; they provide opportunities for learning and reflection. Understanding the impact of video games on education and society is an important area of research. Organizations like the Games Learning Society (GamesLearningSociety.org) are dedicated to exploring these connections. Consider learning more about their work at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.