Should You Keep the Legendary Fish? A Comprehensive Guide to Legendary Catches

▶

The decision of whether to keep or sell your legendary fish hinges on a few key factors: the game you’re playing, your in-game priorities, and your personal preferences. Generally, if the game offers a unique benefit for keeping them such as displaying them in an aquarium or using them for a special quest, it’s worth considering. However, if your primary need is in-game currency, selling them can provide a significant financial boost. Always weigh the pros and cons based on the specific game mechanics.

Legendary Fish: To Keep or Not to Keep?

The allure of a legendary fish is undeniable. These creatures, often rare and difficult to catch, represent a significant accomplishment in any game that features them. But once you’ve landed that prized catch, the question arises: what do you do with it? The answer isn’t always straightforward and depends heavily on the game mechanics and your personal goals within the game. Let’s break down the factors influencing this decision.

Understanding the Value Proposition

Before deciding, consider these aspects of keeping vs. selling:

• Financial Gain: Legendary fish often fetch a high price. If you’re struggling for in-game currency, selling is an obvious choice.
• Decorative Purposes: Some games allow you to display your legendary fish in an aquarium or as a trophy. This adds a unique aesthetic element to your virtual space.
• Quest Completion: Certain quests might require you to possess a specific legendary fish. Selling it beforehand could hinder your progress.
• Unique Abilities/Benefits: Rarely, consuming or interacting with a legendary fish might grant special abilities or buffs.
• Completionist Goals: For some, the act of collecting and displaying all legendary fish is its own reward.
• Game Mechanics: Some games, like Red Dead Redemption 2, have specific questlines tied to mailing legendary fish rather than physically keeping them.

Examples Across Different Games

Let’s look at a few popular games and how the decision to keep or sell a legendary fish plays out.

• Stardew Valley: In Stardew Valley, legendary fish are incredibly valuable for their high selling price, especially early in the game. They can also be used in a Grange Display at the Stardew Valley Fair for a significant point boost. However, they cannot be used in fish ponds to produce roe. Ultimately, the choice is yours, but early-game cash can be extremely valuable.
• Red Dead Redemption 2: Red Dead Redemption 2 takes a different approach. You can only catch each legendary fish once, and the primary goal is to mail them to Jeremy Gill as part of a quest. Keeping them offers no real benefit beyond delaying the quest completion and reward. The update allowed players to save their fish in their home.
• Animal Crossing: While Animal Crossing doesn’t have “legendary” fish in the traditional sense, it does have rare and valuable fish. These are generally best sold, especially to C.J. the fishing enthusiast, to maximize your Bells. However, donating the first catch of each species to the museum is crucial for completing your collection.

The Psychological Factor

Beyond the tangible benefits, there’s also the psychological aspect to consider. Catching a legendary fish can be a deeply satisfying experience. For some players, the sense of accomplishment outweighs the financial gain or decorative potential. They might choose to keep the fish simply as a memento of their achievement.

Making the Right Choice

Ultimately, the decision to keep or sell a legendary fish is a personal one. Consider your priorities within the game, the specific mechanics involved, and your own personal preferences. Weigh the pros and cons carefully before making your choice. If you are trying to decide if education and games have some common ground, you might want to check out the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Legendary Fish

Here are some frequently asked questions to help you navigate the world of legendary fish:

1. Can you catch more than one legendary fish of the same type?

   In most games, no. Legendary fish are typically unique and can only be caught once per save file. However, some games might offer exceptions during special events or quests.

2. What happens if you throw back a legendary fish?

   In some games, throwing back a legendary fish might allow you to re-catch it later. However, this is not a universal mechanic. Check the specific game’s rules.

3. Can legendary fish be used in fish ponds (Stardew Valley)?

   No, legendary fish in Stardew Valley cannot be placed in fish ponds. They will not produce roe or any other benefits.

4. What is the best lure to use for legendary fish?

   Many games feature special lures designed specifically for catching legendary fish. These lures often increase your chances of hooking the rare creature. Check in-game guides or online resources for specific recommendations.

5. Are legendary fish always the hardest to catch?

   While often challenging, not all legendary fish are the most difficult to catch. Some might require specific conditions or locations, making them rare but not necessarily difficult.

6. Can you duplicate legendary fish?

   Generally, no, duplicating legendary fish is not possible through normal gameplay. Glitches or mods might exist, but these are often unreliable and can potentially corrupt your save file.

7. What happens when you catch all the legendary fish in a game?

   The rewards for catching all legendary fish vary. Some games offer a special quest, a unique item, or simply an achievement/trophy.

8. Can you display legendary fish in an aquarium?

   Some games, such as Animal Crossing, Minecraft, or with mods Stardew Valley, allow you to display fish in aquariums. This is often a popular option for showcasing your rare catches.

9. Do legendary fish produce better quality items when processed?

   In some games, processing a legendary fish might yield higher quality items compared to regular fish. This could include better sashimi, roe, or other crafted goods.

10. Are legendary fish worth more than regular fish?

    Yes, legendary fish are almost always worth significantly more than regular fish. This makes them a valuable source of income, especially early in the game.

11. Does time of day affect the chance of catching a legendary fish?

    Yes, some legendary fish are only available during specific times of day or in specific weather conditions. Refer to in-game guides to determine when to fish.

12. Can you catch legendary fish with a low fishing skill level?

    It is typically more difficult to catch legendary fish with a low fishing skill, but it depends on the game. Some games may only allow players with higher fishing skills to access the legendary fish.

13. Can you catch legendary fish in multiplayer?

    Whether or not you can catch legendary fish in a multiplayer game depends on the specific game. Some games allow players to compete for the same legendary fish, while others may have separate instances for each player.

14. Do legendary fish respawn?

    In most games no, once you catch the legendary fish, you cannot catch it again. Throwing it back might allow you to re-catch it later, but this is not a universal mechanic.

15. Are there any secret quests related to legendary fish?

    Some games feature secret quests or easter eggs that are triggered by catching specific legendary fish. These quests might offer unique rewards or unlock new areas.