Should You Play the Mother Series in Order? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The Mother series, known as EarthBound outside Japan, is a quirky, beloved, and deeply emotional trilogy of RPGs. The question of whether to play them in chronological order (Mother 1, EarthBound, Mother 3) is a common one, with no single definitive answer. However, for most players, starting with EarthBound is the recommended approach. This allows you to experience the series’ peak of popularity and accessibility, and subsequently decide how deep you want to dive into its history and connected themes. Playing in order can work, but it might not be the best way to fall in love with the series.
Why EarthBound First?
EarthBound, or Mother 2, is the most polished and accessible game in the series. It boasts a vibrant world, a captivating story, and a unique sense of humor that resonated with audiences worldwide. Its mechanics are refined, its presentation is charming, and it serves as an excellent entry point for newcomers to the RPG genre. It’s arguably the game that cemented the series’ legacy.
- Accessibility: EarthBound benefits from its release on the Super Nintendo Entertainment System (SNES), meaning its controls and gameplay are intuitive to pick up. The game has also received consistent re-releases on modern platforms like the Nintendo Switch Online service, making it readily available.
- Impact: EarthBound’s distinctive art style, memorable characters, and offbeat humor have had a profound impact on gaming culture. Starting with EarthBound gives you a strong grasp of what makes the series special and will prepare you for the subsequent entries.
- Series Foundation: EarthBound establishes many recurring themes, such as childhood innocence, the power of friendship, and the battle against overwhelming evil. Understanding these themes from EarthBound enriches the experience of playing both Mother 1 and Mother 3.
The Case for Chronological Order
Despite the reasons to start with EarthBound, there’s a valid argument for playing the series in chronological order:
- Narrative Progression: Experiencing the games in order allows you to witness the evolution of the Mother series firsthand. You’ll see how the mechanics, themes, and storytelling techniques developed over time.
- Appreciation for Mother 1: While Mother 1 (EarthBound Beginnings) can feel dated compared to its sequels, playing it first offers a unique perspective. You’ll gain a deeper understanding of the series’ origins and the inspirations behind EarthBound’s world and characters.
- Commitment to the Series: For dedicated RPG fans who appreciate retro gaming, tackling Mother 1 first can be a rewarding experience. It’s a test of your patience and appreciation for the series’ roots, ultimately making the subsequent games even more satisfying.
Mother 3: The Emotional Climax
Regardless of whether you start with EarthBound or Mother 1, Mother 3 is best experienced after playing at least one of the previous entries. Mother 3 has the most emotionally impactful story in the series. While it can stand alone, knowing the characters, themes, and world of the previous games adds layers of depth and resonance.
- Thematic Echoes: Mother 3 shares many thematic elements with its predecessors, such as the importance of family, the loss of innocence, and the struggle against oppressive forces. These themes resonate more powerfully if you’ve already experienced them in EarthBound or Mother 1.
- Recurring Characters: While not directly connected in terms of plot, Mother 3 features recurring characters and references to previous games. Spotting these connections enhances the experience and strengthens the feeling of a shared universe.
- Emotional Impact: Mother 3’s story is a rollercoaster of emotions. The subtle connections to the previous games amplify this experience, making it all the more meaningful.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while the chronological order is certainly an option, playing EarthBound first is generally the best way to introduce yourself to the Mother series. It provides an accessible and engaging entry point that will spark your interest in the world, characters, and themes that define the franchise. Once you’ve experienced EarthBound, you can then decide whether to explore the series’ origins with Mother 1 or delve into the emotionally complex world of Mother 3. Ultimately, the order in which you play the games is a matter of personal preference, but starting with EarthBound offers the most rewarding and accessible experience for most players. Game design plays an important role in how we learn, engage, and grow, and organizations like the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org are key in furthering the research into the fascinating interdisciplinary topic.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the chronological order of the Mother games?
The chronological order is: Mother (EarthBound Beginnings), EarthBound (Mother 2), and Mother 3.
2. Is Mother 1 the same as EarthBound?
No. Mother 1 (released in the West as EarthBound Beginnings) is the first game in the series. EarthBound is the second game (Mother 2).
3. Do I need to play Mother 1 before EarthBound?
No, it’s generally recommended to play EarthBound first. It’s more accessible and helps you appreciate the series.
4. Is EarthBound a sequel to Mother?
Yes. EarthBound (Mother 2) is the direct sequel to Mother (EarthBound Beginnings).
5. Is Mother 3 the last game in the series?
Yes, Mother 3 is the third and final installment in the series, with no official sequel released.
6. Are the Mother games connected?
Yes, but the connections are subtle. Each game can be enjoyed independently, but playing them in order reveals deeper thematic and character connections.
7. What makes EarthBound so special?
EarthBound’s charm lies in its unique humor, memorable characters, and quirky portrayal of Americana. It’s a heartfelt story with engaging gameplay.
8. Where can I play EarthBound?
EarthBound is available on the Super Nintendo Entertainment System (SNES), Wii U Virtual Console, New Nintendo 3DS Virtual Console, and Nintendo Switch Online.
9. Is Mother 1 (EarthBound Beginnings) worth playing?
For dedicated fans, Mother 1 is worth playing for its historical value and unique perspective. However, its gameplay can feel dated compared to the sequels.
10. Why wasn’t Mother 3 released in the West?
There’s no definitive answer, but speculated reasons include localization challenges, cultural differences, and perceived low market demand.
11. Is there a fan translation of Mother 3?
Yes, there’s a highly regarded fan translation of Mother 3 that allows English-speaking players to experience the game.
12. Are EarthBound and Mother 3 related in terms of plot?
Not directly. Mother 3 has its own independent storyline, but it includes recurring characters and thematic connections to EarthBound.
13. Why did EarthBound “flop” in the US initially?
Reasons include its simple graphics, unusual marketing, and lack of initial interest in the RPG genre among American audiences.
14. Is Ness from EarthBound in Mother 3?
Yes, Ness makes a cameo appearance in a movie theater in New Pork City in Mother 3.
15. Will there ever be a Mother 4?
Unfortunately, the series creator, Shigesato Itoi, has stated that there will not be an official Mother 4. However, fan-made projects like Oddity (formerly known as Mother 4) demonstrate the series’ enduring legacy.