Should you tell Omnis about the relic or not

Table of Contents

Hogwarts Legacy: Should You Tell Ominis About the Relic? A Comprehensive Guide

Quick answer

This page answers Should you tell Omnis about the relic or not? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

The burning question on every Hogwarts Legacy player’s mind, caught between loyalty and morality, is: Should you tell Ominis Gaunt about the relic? The straightforward answer is: it doesn’t significantly impact the overall storyline. Regardless of your choice, Sebastian will ultimately take the relic. Your decision primarily affects Ominis’s immediate reaction and shapes your relationship with him in that particular moment. However, the long-term consequences are minimal. Let’s delve deeper into the implications of this crucial choice.

The Relic Dilemma: Sebastian, Ominis, and You

The “In The Shadow Of Time” quest presents a significant crossroads. Sebastian, driven by the desire to cure his sister Anne, seeks a powerful relic mentioned in Salazar Slytherin’s Spellbook. He asks you to keep his search a secret from Ominis, fearing Ominis’s disapproval of his descent into dark magic. This places you squarely in the middle of their complex friendship.

The Consequences of Silence

Choosing to remain silent and support Sebastian means siding with his ambition and his belief that the relic is the only hope for Anne. While this aligns you with Sebastian’s immediate goals, it strains your relationship with Ominis. He’ll be disappointed and express his concern over Sebastian’s growing obsession with the dark arts. This path acknowledges Sebastian’s autonomy and allows him to pursue his objective without immediate intervention.

The Consequences of Truth

Confiding in Ominis, on the other hand, demonstrates your trust in him and acknowledges his concerns about Sebastian’s dangerous path. It highlights your commitment to protecting Sebastian from himself and potentially mitigating the risks associated with the relic. While Ominis will appreciate your honesty, it doesn’t stop Sebastian from obtaining the relic. This choice prioritizes honesty and attempts to involve Ominis in a situation that directly affects him and his friends.

The Underlying Truth: Your Choice Matters, But Not That Much

Despite the moral weight of the decision, the game mechanics reveal a crucial truth: Sebastian will obtain the relic regardless of your input. This can feel anticlimactic, as the narrative tension built around the choice doesn’t fully translate into branching storylines. Your decision mainly influences the immediate dialogue and Ominis’s reaction, shaping the tone of your interaction with him. Therefore, the deciding factor should be your role-playing preference: do you prioritize loyalty to Sebastian or honesty with Ominis? The Games Learning Society acknowledges the power of narrative choice in video games and how it shapes the player’s experience. To learn more, visit GamesLearningSociety.org.

The Bigger Picture: Sebastian’s Arc and the Unforgivable Curses

The relic quest is a significant milestone in Sebastian’s character arc. It solidifies his descent into darker magic and sets the stage for the tragic events that follow. Whether you support him or not, his path is largely predetermined. Your choices concerning the relic are more about navigating your relationships than fundamentally altering Sebastian’s destiny.

Furthermore, siding with Sebastian, in general, opens the door to learning the Unforgivable Curses: Crucio, Imperio, and Avada Kedavra. If you aim to master these dark arts, maintaining a good relationship with Sebastian is crucial. Turning him in will prevent you from learning these curses directly from him.

Navigating the Moral Maze

Ultimately, the decision of whether to tell Ominis about the relic depends on your personal preferences and your desired gameplay experience. There is no “right” or “wrong” answer. Consider the following questions:

What kind of character are you playing? Are you a loyal friend, a moral compass, or someone driven by ambition?
What are your priorities? Do you value honesty, loyalty, or the pursuit of forbidden knowledge?
How do you want to shape your relationships with Sebastian and Ominis?

By reflecting on these questions, you can make a decision that aligns with your personal gameplay style and enhances your enjoyment of Hogwarts Legacy.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are 15 frequently asked questions to further clarify the implications of your choice:

What happens if I tell Sebastian not to take the relic?

Regardless of your advice, Sebastian will take the relic. Your dialogue choice only influences his immediate reaction.
If I tell Ominis about the relic, will he stop Sebastian?

No, Ominis cannot prevent Sebastian from taking the relic. The storyline remains consistent.
Will telling Ominis affect my relationship with Sebastian?

Not significantly. Sebastian might be slightly annoyed if he finds out, but it won’t have lasting negative effects on your relationship with him.
Can I learn Avada Kedavra if I turn Sebastian in?

No. Turning Sebastian in prevents you from learning Avada Kedavra directly from him. You’ll need to access it through the Dark Arts Battle Arena (Deluxe Edition or Dark Arts Pack DLC).
Does siding with Ominis or Sebastian affect the main storyline?

Very minimally. The main storyline remains consistent, with minor variations in dialogue and character interactions.
What does Ominis say if I don’t turn Sebastian in?

He expresses concern and disappointment but ultimately acknowledges Sebastian’s regrets and tries to convince Anne of the same.
Can you mess up Sebastian’s questline entirely?

No. Key events in Sebastian’s questline, such as his confrontation with his uncle, are predetermined.
What happens if I cast Imperio on Ominis?

Casting Imperio on Ominis has no long-term consequences beyond learning the spell itself.
Can I still learn Crucio if I initially decline Sebastian’s offer?

Yes. You can learn Crucio later in the game, even if you initially decline.
Who is really behind Anne’s sickness?

Sebastian discovers that the Goblins are not responsible for Anne’s curse. The search for the true cause drives his actions.
What are the benefits of siding with Sebastian?

Siding with Sebastian allows you to learn the Unforgivable Curses and experience the darker aspects of magic.
Is it better to betray Sebastian?

“Better” is subjective. If you prioritize learning the Unforgivable Curses, it’s best not to betray him. If you prioritize moral integrity, it might be.
What happens if Sebastian doesn’t take the relic?

Sebastian always takes the relic, regardless of your dialogue choice.
Why didn’t Crucio work on Bellatrix in the Harry Potter series?

Bellatrix explained that the curse requires a true desire to inflict pain, not just righteous anger.
Can you get Avada Kedavra after saying no initially?

No. You can only learn the unforgivable curse when you accept it and choose “We must not turn Sebastian in”.

In conclusion, while the decision to tell Ominis about the relic seems weighty, its long-term impact is minimal. Choose based on your role-playing preferences and enjoy the rich narrative that Hogwarts Legacy offers. Remember, your journey through the wizarding world is your own.