What Are the Consequences of Being a Dark Wizard in Hogwarts Legacy?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The burning question for many players diving into the magical world of Hogwarts Legacy is: what are the consequences of embracing the dark arts? The short answer is, surprisingly, very few. While the game tantalizes with the forbidden allure of Unforgivable Curses and a talent tree dedicated to the dark arts, the narrative consequences for wielding such power are minimal, primarily affecting character interactions and very limited story variations. In essence, you can become a powerful dark wizard, slinging Avada Kedavra and Crucio left and right, with little more than a few raised eyebrows and a bit of dialogue change from your companions.
The Illusion of Choice: Morality in Hogwarts Legacy
Hogwarts Legacy presents itself as a game where choices matter, particularly those involving morality. The introduction of the Unforgivable Curses — Crucio, Imperio, and Avada Kedavra — suggests a path of darkness and significant repercussions. However, the game’s mechanics fail to deliver on this promise. While you can indeed learn and utilize these potent spells, their impact on the main storyline is practically non-existent.
Minimal Story Impact
Your decision to learn and use dark magic has very little effect on the core narrative of Hogwarts Legacy. Whether you’re a benevolent witch or a power-hungry dark wizard, the main plot points, from unraveling the ancient magic to battling Ranrok, remain the same. This means that your character will go through the same fundamental experiences, even with the frequent use of unforgivable curses, and the main story will not be affected based on whether you use dark magic or not. You will face the same challenges and ultimately arrive at the same conclusion, regardless of your moral compass.
Companion Reactions and Dialogue Changes
The main impact of embracing the dark arts is seen in the reactions of your companions. For instance, Natsai Onai, a Gryffindor companion, will voice her disapproval whenever you use Unforgivable Curses during combat. She will express her concerns about you casting such spells on your enemies and it will make her disapprove of your actions. These dialogue changes add a layer of dynamism to your relationships but don’t translate into a material shift in the game’s plot. Other characters may react similarly, but these interactions are limited and do not significantly alter the game’s overall story or ending.
No Permanent Repercussions
Unlike other RPGs where choices can lead to different alliances, character deaths, or branching storylines, Hogwarts Legacy does not operate this way. No matter how dark your magical practice becomes, you won’t be expelled, sent to Azkaban, or forced to face long-term negative consequences. You are free to use the full range of spells, from the most benevolent to the most heinous, without facing any game-altering setbacks for your choices. This can come as a disappointment to players expecting a more dynamic impact to the game based on their decisions.
The Case of Sebastian Sallow
One notable exception to this rule involves Sebastian Sallow, a fellow student who delves deep into the dark arts. His storyline is intertwined with the use of Unforgivable Curses, and your choices concerning him have some bearing on his quest line. For instance, you can choose whether or not to turn him in after the death of his uncle. However, even this plot line does not dramatically change the ending of the game and does not affect the main story, but rather it mainly affects the way Sebastian’s companion quest line concludes.
Gameplay Advantages Only
The primary consequence of using dark magic is, paradoxically, its effectiveness in combat. The Unforgivable Curses provide distinct gameplay advantages: Crucio inflicts damage over time, Imperio turns enemies against each other, and Avada Kedavra is an instant-kill spell. Combining these spells with a dark arts-focused talent tree can make your character incredibly powerful, almost to the point of being overpowered. These gameplay benefits are the main reason many players use unforgivable curses in the game.
The Good, The Bad, and The Undecided
Hogwarts Legacy technically has three endings, although these are more accurately described as variations on the same ending. These endings are decided by two dialogue choices regarding whether the main character will keep ancient magic contained forever or not. However, none of these endings are affected by the use of Dark Arts during gameplay. While you can have dialogue variations regarding Sebastian’s storyline, these do not affect the main plot of the game. Therefore, the morality of your actions has very limited impact on the ending of the game.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions to help clarify the consequences of being a dark wizard in Hogwarts Legacy:
1. Can I be expelled for using Unforgivable Curses?
No, you cannot be expelled from Hogwarts for using Unforgivable Curses. The game does not have a system in place for expelling students for dark magic practices.
2. Does using dark magic affect my house?
No, your choice of Hogwarts house does not affect the consequences of using dark magic. Regardless of whether you’re a Gryffindor, Slytherin, Ravenclaw, or Hufflepuff, the impact of dark magic on your story will be the same.
3. Does being evil change the ending of Hogwarts Legacy?
While there is an “evil” ending variation, your choices regarding dark magic do not directly dictate it. Your dialogue choices regarding your future plans to contain ancient magic decide which of the three variations you get at the end.
4. Does learning dark magic prevent me from getting a good ending?
No, learning and using Unforgivable Curses does not prevent you from getting any specific ending, good or bad. Your ending is only determined by two dialogue choices, not your actions throughout the game.
5. Can I learn Avada Kedavra and turn Sebastian in?
You can learn Avada Kedavra and turn Sebastian in, but you must learn it from him before you turn him in. If you choose not to learn it from him, and turn him in, the spell is lost to you for that playthrough and you will need to start a new game. You will only be able to access this spell via the Dark Arts Battle Arena if you have a DLC.
6. Can I go to Azkaban for using dark arts?
No, you cannot be sent to Azkaban in Hogwarts Legacy for your own actions. The only way to visit Azkaban is through the Hufflepuff-exclusive quest, which is completely unrelated to your own actions.
7. Does using dark magic make me a “bad” character in the story?
Your character will not be canonically considered “bad” in the story. While you can make morally questionable choices, you will not become a proto-Voldemort. However, you will see some dialogue changes, which can impact your relationship with some characters in the game.
8. Are there any benefits to using dark magic in the game?
Yes, the primary benefit is in combat effectiveness. The Unforgivable Curses offer potent advantages, and the dark arts talent tree can make you incredibly powerful.
9. What happens if I don’t learn the Unforgivable Curses?
If you don’t learn the Unforgivable Curses during Sebastian’s questline, you will be able to learn them later via the Dark Arts Battle Arena if you purchased the Deluxe Edition or Dark Arts Pack DLC. If you do not have a DLC that includes the battle arena, you will need to begin a new playthrough if you decide you want to learn them at a later time.
10. Does using dark magic affect my relationships with other characters?
Yes, your relationships with some characters will change. Characters like Natasi Onai will express disapproval of your use of dark magic. However, these reactions are primarily dialogue changes and do not alter your relationships significantly.
11. Can I avoid Sebastian killing his uncle?
No, Sebastian killing his uncle is a fixed event in the game. Your choices do not change this particular event. The only decision you will have regarding his uncle’s death is whether to turn Sebastian in or not.
12. Is it better to turn Sebastian in or not?
That is ultimately a decision based on your own preferences. If you value learning all of the Unforgivable Curses, you should not turn him in. If you are uncomfortable with his actions, you can turn him in, but you will not be able to learn the unforgivable curses through him.
13. Can you make choices that lead to bad outcomes for others?
While your choices may lead to negative consequences for other characters, these consequences are not directly tied to whether you use the dark arts. They are rather part of the plot set by the game developers and do not rely on your actions of casting unforgivable curses.
14. Can you become a dark wizard in Gryffindor?
Yes, you can become a dark wizard in any of the Hogwarts Houses. There are no restrictions on your actions or your choice of house in Hogwarts Legacy and you will be able to learn the unforgivable curses regardless of your house.
15. What is the main point of contention around being a dark wizard in the game?
The main point of contention is the lack of significant consequences for using dark magic. Players were expecting more moral repercussions and narrative shifts for embracing the dark arts, as well as more consequences for using dark magic, but that is simply not the case for this game.
In conclusion, becoming a dark wizard in Hogwarts Legacy is a path largely devoid of meaningful consequences beyond dialogue changes and gameplay advantages. While the game offers the illusion of choice regarding morality, the impact on the overall narrative is minimal. Embrace your dark side if you choose, but know that its impact on the story will be very limited.