The Shadow Side: Unveiling the Downsides of Multiclassing in D&D
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Multiclassing in Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition (D&D 5e) offers players an enticing opportunity to create uniquely versatile characters. By blending different class features, you can forge a hero that’s more than the sum of its parts. However, this path is not without its pitfalls. The downsides of multiclassing, while often glossed over in the excitement of new abilities, can significantly impact your character’s effectiveness and overall enjoyment. Ultimately, the primary downside of multiclassing is the delayed progression in your core class, which can lead to missed power spikes and an overall decrease in combat effectiveness, especially in the later tiers of play. Let’s delve deeper into what else you might be sacrificing for those sweet multiclass features.
The Price of Versatility: Key Disadvantages of Multiclassing
Delayed Power Progression
This is the most significant drawback. As you distribute your levels across multiple classes, you delay reaching the higher-level features of your initial class. For example, a single-classed Fighter would achieve their second attack at level 5, while a Fighter/Rogue multiclass would have to wait longer to obtain this crucial combat upgrade. Similarly, a full spellcaster might find that their spell progression is significantly hampered, missing out on higher-level spells which could be a game changer in certain situations. This slower progression can lead to feeling underpowered compared to your single-classed counterparts. You’ll be lagging behind the power curve, possibly affecting your performance in combat and during role-playing scenarios that depend on character capabilities.
Spellcasting Complications
Multiclassing can be particularly detrimental to spellcasters. While you gain spell slots based on your combined caster level, your access to higher-level spells is based solely on your individual class levels. A Wizard 3/Cleric 2, despite having access to a number of lower-level spell slots from combined spellcaster progression, will not be casting 3rd-level spells as each class only allows for 2nd level spell selection at these individual levels. This means you’ll struggle to keep up with the spell potency of your single-classed counterparts. This lack of access to powerful spells is a severe drawback for characters that rely on magic for combat, healing, or utility.
Ability Score Mismatch
Each class in D&D focuses on different abilities. Multiclassing can lead to an imbalance in your ability scores, as you might need to focus on different attributes to satisfy the needs of both your classes. For example, a Paladin/Sorcerer would need high Strength, Charisma, and likely some Constitution. This means you might have to compromise and end up with lower overall scores in one or more key attributes compared to a single-class character. This spread of stats could negatively impact both your spellcasting and martial abilities, hindering your overall effectiveness.
Lost Proficiencies
When multiclassing, you don’t gain all the proficiencies associated with your new class. You receive a limited subset, usually meaning fewer weapon and armor proficiencies, in addition to not gaining any new saving throw proficiencies. This limitation can restrict your combat options and force you to choose less than optimal gear. Only specific classes such as Rogue, Ranger, and Bard provide an additional skill proficiency when multiclassing into them. This means a lack of skill expertise or combat versatility, particularly if you’re accustomed to a broad range of skills and abilities from your primary class.
Complicated Builds and Planning
Multiclassing requires a deeper understanding of the rules and interactions between different classes. Building an effective multiclass character demands careful planning and consideration of when to take levels in different classes. It’s not as straightforward as simply choosing your next class level. Players may make choices that might seem cool at first, but later prove detrimental, because the synergism between classes or subclasses wasn’t fully considered beforehand. You have to take into consideration your specific desired power combination and work towards that in your class level selections, which can be challenging for newer players.
Not Always Optimal
While some multiclass combinations can be powerful, many others are just plain weak or simply don’t synergize well. A combination of two classes could result in an overall less efficient character than a character who stuck to a single class. Simply put, while a concept might sound great on paper, it can become disappointing in practice, especially if you weren’t aware of specific power gaps.
Roleplaying Inconsistencies
Sometimes, multiclassing can lead to characters who feel narratively disjointed. It can be difficult to justify why your character suddenly adopts the philosophy and practices of a completely different class. This can lead to a character that lacks narrative cohesion, where the two classes don’t blend well from a role-playing point of view.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Multiclassing in D&D
What are the best classes for multiclassing?
Some of the commonly cited strong multiclass combinations include Paladin/Fighter, Rogue/Fighter, Barbarian/Rogue, Artificer/Wizard, and Cleric/Druid. However, the best choice depends heavily on the specific build and character concept you are aiming for. The 1st five levels of several classes are excellent starting point to mix into another class as the first five levels of almost any class are jam-packed with great features.
Is there a limit on how many classes I can multiclass into?
No, there is no official limit on the number of classes you can multiclass into. This is part of the beauty of D&D, allowing for incredibly unique and varied characters. However, some DMs may impose house rules, so it’s best to discuss this with your DM beforehand.
Do I get all the proficiencies when multiclassing?
No, when multiclassing, you get a reduced set of proficiencies from the new class. You will not gain any new saving throw proficiencies, and you typically only gain limited weapon and armor proficiencies. Only the Rogue, Ranger, and Bard classes offer an additional Skill Proficiency when multiclassing into them.
Do I lose spell slots when multiclassing?
No, you don’t lose spell slots when multiclassing. You determine your spell slots based on your total caster level (a combination of your spellcasting levels from different classes). However, you only know spells based on your individual class levels, so higher-level spell access is still delayed. For example, a level 3 Wizard and level 3 Cleric is considered a 6th level spell caster by way of combined class level for the purpose of spell slots, but they can only select spells from the spell list of their respective classes using their level in that specific class.
Do I get two fighting styles if I multiclass?
Yes, you can have multiple fighting styles, as long as they are different from each other. This can be useful when combining a fighter with another martial class or a paladin.
When is the best time to start multiclassing?
It’s generally recommended to wait until at least level 5 in your primary class before multiclassing. This allows you to obtain core abilities and power spikes in your base class before branching out. This means if you want the Extra Attack feature of most martial classes, or the 3rd level spells of full casters, it’s best to get to level 5 before considering a different class.
Can you get extra attacks from multiclassing?
The Extra Attack feature, found in many martial classes, does not stack between different classes. If two classes have an Extra Attack ability, you do not gain additional attacks by multiclassing, and you continue to only get a single extra attack.
Do you gain cantrips when multiclassing?
Yes, you gain cantrips when you gain access to them from class features, even when multiclassing. This is part of how multiclassed spellcasters get access to a variety of minor spells.
Do you pick a subclass for each class when multiclassing?
Yes, when you take your first level of a new class, you choose that class’s subclass as soon as you reach the relevant level for subclass selection. This allows you to fully customize the abilities of each class you take, leading to more intricate builds.
What hit dice do I use when multiclassing?
When multiclassing you add together the Hit Dice granted by all your classes to form your pool of Hit Dice. If the Hit Dice are the same die type, you can simply pool them together. For example, a fighter 3/barbarian 3 character has 6d12 Hit Dice.
Is multiclassing more powerful than sticking to a single class?
Not always. While some multiclass combinations can be potent, many are not. A single-class character often has a more cohesive power progression and access to higher-level abilities which makes them a powerful and well-rounded choice for any party composition.
Can I be level 20 in more than one class?
No, the game is designed to have a maximum character level of 20. You can only reach level 20 once, and you must choose one class combination to reach that maximum total level. The player cannot level up to level 20 in one class, and then proceed to level up to level 20 in another class.
Do you have to meet prerequisites when multiclassing?
Yes, you must meet certain ability score prerequisites in your existing class to multiclass into a new class. These prerequisites ensure a basic level of proficiency in the new class. For example, you would need a score of 13 in Strength to multiclass into Barbarian or Paladin.
What is the most difficult class to play in D&D?
While difficulty is subjective, classes like Sorcerer, Wizard, and Artificer are often cited as more complex due to their reliance on spell management and strategic planning. Each class offers its own challenges, but those classes which are heavily spell-focused generally require more strategic choices.
Is multiclassing as a bard a good idea?
Multiclassing as a Bard can offer certain benefits such as access to better armor or extra attacks, but be sure to consider what you gain by multiclassing vs what you lose out on from continuing your path as a bard. For example, if the purpose of multiclassing is access to spells, a bard can get any spell they want through Magical Secrets.
Conclusion: The Trade-Off of Multiclassing
Multiclassing in D&D can be a fun way to explore new build possibilities and customize your character to achieve unique goals. However, it’s essential to acknowledge the downsides. The most critical consideration is that multiclassing always comes at the cost of delayed core class progression, which could negatively impact your overall effectiveness in combat or while playing more nuanced role-playing scenarios. Knowing the trade-offs and planning ahead is vital to ensuring that your multiclass choice contributes to a satisfying and effective character. If you do your research, you can create a unique and powerful character that is both rewarding to play, and effective in any party composition.