Mastering Extra Attack in Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The Extra Attack feature in Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition is a cornerstone of martial combat, significantly boosting a character’s offensive capabilities. Beginning at 5th level for most classes, it allows you to attack twice, instead of once, whenever you take the Attack action on your turn. This number can further increase to three attacks at 11th level and four attacks at 20th level, but typically only for the Fighter class. The core principle is simple: when you choose to attack on your turn, you get more opportunities to hit your enemies. This doesn’t grant an extra action or bonus action; it simply expands the possibilities within the Attack action. Understanding the nuances of Extra Attack is crucial for optimizing combat effectiveness, especially when combined with other class features, spells, and equipment.
Understanding the Mechanics of Extra Attack
The beauty of Extra Attack lies in its simplicity and the options it unlocks. It doesn’t cost you extra resources or require specific conditions (besides being the correct level in a class that grants it). It is passive feature that is always active. Here are some of the mechanics that you need to know:
-
The Attack Action is Key: You only gain the benefits of Extra Attack when you specifically take the Attack action. Other actions, like casting a spell or using a class feature, do not trigger Extra Attack unless explicitly stated.
-
Multiple Attacks, One Action: Extra Attack grants you multiple attacks within a single action. Think of it as streamlining your offensive output.
-
Misses Don’t Matter: You are not penalized for missing with your first attack. The number of attacks you have is the same. You can still make all of your attacks, even if the initial attacks don’t hit the target.
-
Weapon Flexibility: You can use different weapons for each attack, allowing you to adapt to different situations and exploit vulnerabilities.
-
Grappling and Shoving: Extra Attack isn’t limited to weapon attacks. You can replace one or more of your attacks with special melee attacks such as grappling or shoving a creature. This offers tactical options for controlling the battlefield.
Classes and Extra Attack
The Extra Attack feature is primarily associated with martial classes, but some subclasses offer it as well. Here’s a general overview:
- Barbarian, Fighter, Monk, Paladin, Ranger: These classes receive Extra Attack at 5th level.
- Fighter: Fighters are unique in receiving additional attacks at higher levels (11th and 20th).
- Bladesinger (Wizard), College of Swords Bard, College of Valor Bard: These subclasses gain Extra Attack at 6th level. Their implementation also allows for unique options, such as the Bladesinger’s ability to substitute one attack with a cantrip.
Interactions with Other Features and Spells
Extra Attack’s interaction with other abilities and spells can be tricky, but understanding these interactions is key to maximizing your character’s potential.
Spells
Generally, you cannot cast spells as part of the Extra Attack action unless a specific class feature allows it (like the Bladesinger’s ability to cast a cantrip). Spells require the Cast a Spell action, which is separate from the Attack action. Therefore, you can’t use Extra Attack to cast multiple spells in a single turn.
Two-Weapon Fighting
Two-Weapon Fighting is a separate rule that allows you to make an additional attack with a light weapon using your bonus action, provided you’ve attacked with a different light weapon during your Attack action. Extra Attack doesn’t automatically grant you this bonus action attack, but it enhances your overall offensive output by giving you more attacks during your Attack action.
Action Surge
The Fighter’s Action Surge feature grants you an additional action on your turn. This action can be used to take the Attack action again, allowing you to make even more attacks if you have Extra Attack.
Haste
The Haste spell grants you an additional action that can be used for one attack. However, the extra attack granted by Haste cannot be used for grappling, shoving, or casting spells unless you have a feature that otherwise allows you to do so.
Optimization and Tactical Considerations
Maximizing the effectiveness of Extra Attack involves strategic decision-making and leveraging other abilities. Here are some points to consider:
-
Weapon Choice: Selecting weapons that synergize with your class features and combat style is crucial. For example, a Paladin might benefit from a Greatsword for Divine Smite, while a Ranger might prefer dual wielding for more opportunities to apply Hunter’s Mark.
-
Feats: Feats like Great Weapon Master or Sharpshooter can significantly boost your damage output, especially when combined with Extra Attack. However, these feats often come with a trade-off, such as a penalty to attack rolls.
-
Positioning: Strategic positioning on the battlefield is essential for maximizing your attacks. Flanking enemies or gaining high ground can provide advantages.
-
Crowd Control: Using Extra Attack to grapple or shove enemies can disrupt their plans and control the battlefield, giving your allies an edge.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Can I use two cantrips in a turn with Extra Attack?
No. The Bladesinger’s Extra Attack feature allows you to cast a cantrip instead of one of your attacks, not in addition to all of your attacks. It simply replaces one attack with a cantrip.
2. Can I use two spells with Extra Attack?
No. Extra Attack specifically relies on the Attack action, not the Cast a Spell action. You can only cast spells that have a casting time of one action, unless you have the Action Surge or Haste to give you another action.
3. How many times can I use Extra Attack 5E?
The number of attacks you get from Extra Attack depends on your class and level. It starts with two attacks at 5th level for most martial classes, increasing to three at 11th level and four at 20th level for Fighters.
4. Can you hold an Extra Attack in 5E?
No. The Extra Attack feature only applies when you take the Attack action on your turn. You cannot “hold” an attack for later.
5. Can I Extra Attack with a spell attack?
No. Making a spell attack is not taking the Attack action, which is required for Extra Attack. You need to take the attack action to trigger extra attack.
6. What is the Extra Attack item in 5E?
The Scimitar of Speed lets you make an extra attack with it as a bonus action. The Potion of Speed grants you the effects of a Haste spell, including the ability to take an extra Attack action each turn.
7. Do Bards get Extra Attack?
Bards do not receive Extra Attack unless they select the College of Valor or the College of Swords subclasses. The other bard subclasses don’t give this feature.
8. Do Clerics get Extra Attack?
Clerics typically do not get Extra Attack. However, a War Domain Cleric can use their bonus action to make a weapon attack when they take the Attack action (this is not Extra Attack, but a separate feature).
9. Does Extra Attack give you an extra action?
No, Extra Attack is part of the Attack action, not a separate action. Your bonus action is reserved for bonus action abilities, like attacking with an off-hand weapon.
10. How do you get an extra action in 5E?
The only way to get an extra action or bonus action is the Fighter’s Action Surge ability or to have the Haste spell cast on you.
11. Can you grapple as part of Extra Attack 5E?
Yes! You can replace one or more of your attacks granted by Extra Attack with a grapple or shove attempt. They’re “special melee attacks” that substitute an attack.
12. How does Extra Attack work with Haste 5E?
Using the Attack action from Haste allows you to make one additional attack that you could otherwise make while taking the Attack action. It doesn’t give anything more than what the Attack action can be used for, and limits it to one additional attack.
13. What is the difference between Extra Attack and extra action?
Extra Attack applies when you take the Attack action on your turn. Action Surge (from the fighter class) lets you take an extra action (but not extra movement, nor a bonus action or reaction).
14. Can you switch weapons with Extra Attack?
Yes, you can use different weapons for each attack granted by Extra Attack. Nothing in the feature restricts you to using the same weapon for all attacks.
15. Can you attack with two different weapons with Extra Attack 5E?
Yes, you can hold two weapons and attack once with each when you have Extra Attack (two total attacks). However, you won’t qualify for the bonus action attack from two-weapon fighting unless they’re light weapons.
Conclusion
The Extra Attack feature is a fundamental aspect of combat in D&D 5E. Understanding its mechanics, interactions, and tactical applications is essential for players who want to maximize their combat effectiveness. By leveraging Extra Attack in conjunction with other class features, spells, and equipment, you can create a formidable character capable of dominating the battlefield. If you are interested in learning more about using games for education, be sure to visit the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.