Mastering the Art of Disarming in D&D 5e: A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
What are the rules for disarm in D&D? The core rules of Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition (5e) do not include a dedicated “Disarm” action as a standard combat maneuver. However, the Dungeon Master’s Guide (DMG) offers an optional rule on page 271 for disarming an opponent. This rule allows a character to use a weapon attack to attempt to knock a weapon or other item from a target’s grasp. Here’s a breakdown:
- Action: Disarming is performed as part of a standard attack action. You are essentially replacing a regular attack with an attempt to disarm.
- Attack Roll: To disarm, you must make a weapon attack roll. This means you roll a d20, add your relevant attack modifier (Strength for melee weapons, Dexterity for ranged or finesse weapons), and compare the total to the target’s Armor Class (AC).
- Disadvantage: If the target is holding the item with two or more hands, the attacker makes the attack roll with disadvantage. This reflects the difficulty of dislodging an item held firmly.
- Success: If the attack roll equals or exceeds the target’s AC, the item is dislodged and falls to the ground within the target’s space or, in some cases, a location determined by the DM (if kicked).
- Item Type: This rule applies to weapons and other items held in a target’s hand. It could be a spellcasting focus, a magical item, a shield, or any object capable of being dropped.
- Unarmed Disarm: If you wish to attempt to snatch the item into your hand, the disarm must be made as an unarmed attack. This means you’d be using your fist, foot, or other part of your body, and not a weapon. You would make a normal attack roll with your unarmed strike.
- Bonus for Easy Disarms: The optional rule also states that if the item is poorly secured or otherwise easy to snatch or cut away (as determined by the DM), the attacker gets a +4 bonus to their attack roll.
- GM Discretion: Like many optional rules, the DM has the final say on how disarming works in their game. They can modify this rule based on their preferred play style.
Essentially, disarming in D&D 5e is a special kind of attack roll intended to knock an item out of an opponent’s hands. It’s not a guaranteed action, and it comes with its own set of considerations.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Disarming
1. Can you disarm a creature of a held shield?
Yes, the disarm action can target a held shield, as it’s an item held in a character’s hand. If a successful disarm attack is made, the shield would be dropped. Note that a shield that is dropped does not add to your AC.
2. Can you snatch an item instead of just dropping it when disarming?
Yes, the optional rule permits it. However, if you aim to snatch the item, you must use an unarmed attack to make the disarm attempt. You would make a normal unarmed attack roll, with the additional consequence of disarming on a successful hit.
3. How do you pick up a dropped weapon?
If a weapon is dropped within a character’s reach, it typically requires a free object interaction to pick it up. However, if the weapon is out of sight or in a hazardous location, the DM might require a Perception check, costing a full action. This reflects the time and effort needed to find and recover the item.
4. Does a Disarming Attack maneuver from the Battle Master Fighter work like the DMG’s disarm rule?
Yes, the Battle Master Fighter’s Disarming Attack maneuver follows the same general principle, but it adds a superiority die to the attack roll and, on a hit, can cause the target to drop the held item and become unable to pick it up until the start of your next turn. It is a more potent version of a disarm action.
5. How does the DM decide if an item is easy to disarm?
The DM has the final say based on the situation. For instance, a loosely held dagger might be easily disarmed, granting the +4 bonus. Conversely, a mace held in a gauntleted grip would be harder to disarm. DM judgment is key. The DM can allow a player to make a check to see the security of the weapon.
6. Does disarming cause a creature to be prone?
No, disarming does not cause a creature to fall prone. It simply forces the target to drop the held item. The target remains standing and can take other actions as normal.
7. Can you disarm a creature’s natural weapons, like claws or teeth?
No, the disarm action specifically targets held objects. Natural weapons like claws, teeth, and tentacles cannot be disarmed because they are part of a creature’s body.
8. Can you use a ranged weapon to disarm?
Yes, you can attempt to use a ranged weapon to disarm. However, a successful disarm attempt with ranged weapon would still need to be a standard weapon attack. The same rules apply: the target drops the held item if the attack roll equals or exceeds the target’s AC.
9. What happens if you critically hit on a disarm attack?
A critical hit on a disarm attack has no specific effect beyond the fact that the attack automatically hits. The item drops. Whether a critical hit has additional consequences is up to the DM’s discretion and specific home rules.
10. Is yelling an action?
Whether yelling is an action depends on the DM. RAW indicates it’s not an action. Generally, yelling would count as speaking as part of your movement. However, a yell intended to intimidate might require a Charisma skill check. A yell might also, at a DM’s discretion, alert nearby enemies.
11. What is Rule Zero of D&D?
Rule Zero, often referred to as GM fiat, is the understanding that the Dungeon Master has the ultimate authority to make rulings, modify rules, or even create new rules as they see fit to enhance the game experience. The DM is, ultimately, the “god of the game”.
12. What is the difference between RAW and RAI?
RAW (Rules as Written) means following the rules of the game exactly as they appear in the official books, with no added interpretation. RAI (Rules as Intended), on the other hand, refers to how the rules are meant to be interpreted, even if they aren’t explicitly stated in the text.
13. Can you delay your turn in combat?
The official rules of D&D 5e do not allow you to delay your turn in combat. Turns are determined by the initiative order, and characters must take their action on their designated turn. There is not a “hold action” until a future turn rule in the game. However, a player might use ready an action to trigger it once a condition has been met.
14. What does squeezing mean in D&D?
Squeezing is when a creature moves into a space that is smaller than its normal size. A creature can squeeze through a space large enough for a creature one size smaller than it. While squeezing, you move at half speed and have disadvantage on attack rolls and Dexterity saving throws.
15. What is the most important rule in D&D?
The most important rule in D&D is that everyone at the table is having fun. While following the rules is essential for a structured and balanced game, the primary goal is to provide an enjoyable experience for all participants. DMs and players should work together to create engaging narratives and memorable moments.
Disarming is an optional but potentially very useful tactic that allows players to disrupt their opponents in combat, offering a strategic element to battles. Always remember to discuss with your DM how these rules will be applied at your table, to ensure a smooth and enjoyable gameplay experience.