Battlefield 4: Unraveling the Choices and Consequences of Its Three Endings
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Battlefield 4, a flagship title in the renowned first-person shooter franchise, took players on a thrilling ride through intense combat scenarios and a compelling narrative. A crucial element that elevated the game beyond mere action was its branching storyline, culminating in three distinct endings determined by the player’s final choice. Understanding these choices and their implications is key to appreciating the depth of Battlefield 4’s campaign.
The three endings are determined by which character the player, as Recker, chooses to sacrifice in the final moments of the game:
-
Sacrificing Irish: If Recker gives the detonator to Irish, he uses it to destroy the Valkyrie, sacrificing himself in the process. This ending is considered by many to be the “canon” ending.
-
Sacrificing Hannah: Alternatively, Recker can give the detonator to Hannah. She then sacrifices herself to destroy the Valkyrie.
-
Doing Nothing: Perhaps the most controversial and unexpected ending, Recker can choose to do absolutely nothing. In this scenario, Admiral Chang is shot and killed by the timely arrival of the Valkyrie.
Each ending carries its own weight, influencing the player’s perception of the characters and the overall message of the story. Let’s delve into each ending in more detail and explore some frequently asked questions surrounding this pivotal decision.
Diving Deeper into Each Ending
Understanding the nuances of each ending allows us to appreciate the game’s narrative ambition. Battlefield 4 attempted to imbue its action with moral choices, forcing players to consider the consequences of their actions.
The Sacrifice of Irish
Giving the detonator to Irish results in his heroic self-sacrifice. He redeems himself for his past actions, specifically his previous desertion and apparent death in an earlier mission. This ending highlights themes of redemption and selflessness. It reinforces the idea that even those with a checkered past can make the ultimate sacrifice for the greater good. Many fans view this ending as the most fitting and poignant conclusion to Irish’s character arc.
Hannah’s Ultimate Choice
Choosing to give the detonator to Hannah presents a morally ambiguous scenario. Is it fair to ask someone who is seemingly unstable and perhaps unwilling to die to make such a sacrifice? This ending explores themes of duty, sacrifice, and the burden of choice. Some players argue that this ending is the “wrong” one, as Hannah seems the least willing and mentally prepared for such a task. However, it also demonstrates the immense pressure placed on individuals during wartime.
The “No Choice” Option: A Twist
Refusing to make a choice leads to a rather anticlimactic ending. Admiral Chang is killed by the timely arrival of the Valkyrie, seemingly resolving the immediate threat. However, it leaves a lingering sense of dissatisfaction. This ending suggests that inaction can sometimes lead to unexpected positive outcomes, but also highlights the importance of making difficult decisions when necessary. It raises questions about fate, chance, and the role of individual agency in shaping events. Furthermore, this ending seems to downplay the player’s role in the final events.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Battlefield 4’s Endings
The multiple endings of Battlefield 4 have sparked countless discussions among fans. Here are some of the most frequently asked questions:
1. Which ending is considered the “canon” ending?
While there is no officially designated “canon” ending by DICE or EA, the Irish sacrifice ending is generally accepted by the community as the most likely to be considered canon. This is based on character development and narrative closure.
2. Does the ending I choose affect future Battlefield games?
No, the endings of Battlefield 4 have not had a direct impact on subsequent Battlefield titles. The franchise typically features standalone stories with minimal connectivity between games.
3. How do I unlock all three endings?
To experience all three endings, you simply need to replay the final mission (“Singapore”) and make a different choice at the end each time.
4. Are there any achievements or trophies associated with the different endings?
No, there are no specific achievements or trophies tied to selecting each of the different endings. The achievement is simply for completing the campaign.
5. Which ending is the “best” ending?
The “best” ending is subjective and depends on individual player preference. Some prefer the Irish sacrifice for its emotional impact and sense of closure. Others might find the Hannah sacrifice more thought-provoking due to its moral ambiguity. And some prefer the no choice ending for its unexpected outcome.
6. Does my choice of ending affect the credits or any post-credits scenes?
No, the credits and any post-credits scenes (if any) are the same regardless of the ending you choose.
7. Did DICE originally plan for different endings?
It’s unclear whether DICE had different plans for the endings during development. The existing three choices appear to be the result of their design choices.
8. Why did DICE choose to include multiple endings in Battlefield 4?
The inclusion of multiple endings was likely an attempt to add depth and player agency to the campaign. It aimed to create a more engaging and memorable experience by allowing players to shape the story’s conclusion. Perhaps the team was exploring the educational possibilities offered by games. At the Games Learning Society, educational games are an important topic of research and development. Find out more at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.
9. Is there any hidden meaning or symbolism in the different endings?
The endings can be interpreted in various ways, with themes of redemption, sacrifice, duty, and the consequences of inaction all being present. The specific meaning is left open to player interpretation.
10. What is the general fan reaction to the different endings?
Fan reaction to the endings has been mixed. Some appreciate the choice and the opportunity to shape the story, while others find the endings underwhelming or morally ambiguous. The no choice ending, in particular, has received criticism for feeling anticlimactic.
11. Could the “no choice” ending be considered the “bad” ending?
While not explicitly stated as a “bad” ending, the “no choice” option often feels less satisfying than the other two. It can be seen as a missed opportunity for player agency and a less impactful conclusion to the story.
12. How does the community rank the three endings?
Based on various online forums and discussions, the general consensus seems to be:
- 1st: Irish Sacrifice
- 2nd: Hannah Sacrifice
- 3rd: No Choice
This ranking is largely based on emotional impact, character development, and overall narrative satisfaction.
13. Are there any mods that alter or expand on the Battlefield 4 endings?
While modding is not as prevalent in Battlefield 4 compared to some other games, it is possible that some mods exist that alter or expand upon the endings. However, these would typically be limited to the PC version of the game.
14. Did the multiple endings impact the critical reception of Battlefield 4’s campaign?
The multiple endings were a talking point in reviews, with some critics praising the player agency and narrative depth, while others found them underwhelming or lacking in impact. Overall, the campaign received mixed reviews, and the endings were just one factor contributing to this reception.
15. Is there any connection between the Battlefield 4 endings and real-world military ethics?
The choices presented in Battlefield 4 can be related to real-world military ethics, particularly in terms of sacrifice, duty, and the moral dilemmas faced by soldiers in combat. The game encourages players to consider the consequences of their actions and the weight of responsibility.
In conclusion, the three endings of Battlefield 4 offer a unique and engaging element to the game’s campaign. While the impact on the overarching Battlefield universe is minimal, they provide a moment of player agency and encourage reflection on the themes of sacrifice, duty, and the burden of choice. Ultimately, the “best” ending is a matter of personal preference, shaped by individual interpretation and emotional connection to the characters and the narrative.