Arthur vs. John: Unveiling the Abilities Arthur Morgan Possesses That Elude John Marston
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Arthur Morgan and John Marston are two iconic protagonists in the Red Dead Redemption series, forever etched in the annals of gaming history. While both are hardened gunslingers operating in the harsh landscapes of the Wild West, certain key differences in their skill sets and character arcs make them distinct and compelling. The most glaring difference is Arthur’s ability to swim, whereas John almost instantly drowns. Beyond this, Arthur’s advantages stem from his longer tenure with the gang, which gave him more opportunities to hone skills that John either lacked or never fully developed. He has acquired unique experiences and abilities along the way. Let’s dive into a more in-depth analysis and look at the finer details of Arthur’s capabilities that set him apart.
Arthur’s Superior Skill Set
Arthur boasts a more rounded set of skills, which stems from his longer dedication to Dutch’s gang. He is seen as a more seasoned outlaw. Arthur can swim, indicating a baseline level of competence in the water. In contrast, John’s inability to swim is a recurring gag and a significant gameplay limitation. This highlights Arthur’s greater self-sufficiency in diverse environments.
Furthermore, Arthur’s physical prowess and brawling skills are often considered superior. He seems to have a natural inclination for close-quarters combat. He displays a more ruthless efficiency and brutal fighting style. While both men are capable shots, Arthur’s overall combat versatility edges out John.
More importantly, Arthur demonstrates a greater range of emotional depth and character complexity, which translates into decision-making. His journey is one of self-discovery and moral reckoning. John’s arc, while powerful, is more straightforward in its pursuit of redemption. Arthur also exhibits a more active role within the Van der Linde gang, handling a wider variety of tasks and responsibilities.
FAQs: Delving Deeper into the Differences
Here are some frequently asked questions regarding the capabilities, personalities, and in-game features associated with Arthur Morgan and John Marston:
1. Why can’t John Marston swim in Red Dead Redemption 2?
Rockstar Games deliberately retained John’s inability to swim as a humorous callback to the original Red Dead Redemption. It’s now considered canon. The in-game explanation is simple: John simply never learned how to swim.
2. Is Arthur more skilled in combat than John?
While both are formidable fighters, many players find that Arthur’s brawling skills are notably superior to John’s. Arthur’s larger size and more aggressive fighting style gives him an edge in hand-to-hand combat.
3. Does Arthur make fun of John for his swimming inability?
Yes, there are instances where Arthur teases John about his inability to swim. In one memorable card game scene, Arthur quips, “Why don’t we up the ante here? Loser has to strip and jump in the water. Oh wait, Marston can’t swim.”
4. Can Arthur become skinny in RDR2?
Yes, Arthur’s weight is dynamic and changes based on his eating habits. By eating less, players can make Arthur lose weight. It’s important to balance weight management with maintaining his core stats.
5. Did Arthur have any mental illness in RDR2?
Arthur does not exhibit symptoms of a formal mental illness. However, his mental and emotional state is deeply affected by contracting Tuberculosis (TB). The illness causes significant physical and psychological distress.
6. Why doesn’t John mention Arthur in Red Dead Redemption 1?
Several theories explain John’s omission of Arthur in RDR1. Some common explanations include:
- Painful memories: Thinking about Arthur causes him intense emotional pain.
- Gratitude and shame: John is ashamed that Arthur sacrificed himself to save his family.
- Arthur’s last wish: Arthur told John to “not look back” and focus on his family’s future.
7. Is it possible to save Arthur from TB in RDR2?
Unfortunately, there is no definitive cure for Arthur’s TB within the game’s storyline. The only way to avoid Arthur contracting TB is to completely avoid progressing in the game. By not continuing the game, players can stop the illness from happening.
8. Does John inherit Arthur’s horses?
Sadly, John does not inherit Arthur’s stabled horses after the story transitions. Players begin the epilogue with a single horse and must acquire new ones.
9. Could a healthy Arthur beat Micah?
The consensus among many players is that a healthy Arthur would easily defeat Micah in a fight. Arthur’s superior fighting skills and moral grounding are perceived to give him a significant advantage.
10. How much older is Arthur than John?
Arthur is 35 years old, while John is 26 years old during the events of Red Dead Redemption 2.
11. Can players continue playing as Arthur after his death?
No, once Arthur dies, the game transitions to John Marston as the playable character. There are no in-game methods or cheats to allow continued gameplay as Arthur.
12. Who is the smartest character in RDR2?
While intelligence is subjective, Marko Dragic is often considered the smartest character in Red Dead Redemption 2, owing to his advanced scientific knowledge and inventions.
13. How does Arthur contract TB?
Arthur contracts TB during a mission involving Leopold Strauss’s debt collection. He is infected by Thomas Downes while attempting to collect a debt from him. Downes is ill with TB.
14. What is the secret ending of RDR2?
The “secret ending” of Red Dead Redemption 2 is a short bonus scene unlocked by achieving 100% completion of the game. In this ending, John visits Arthur’s grave, providing an emotional closure to the epic narrative.
15. Why did Arthur give John his hat?
Arthur gave John his hat as a symbolic gesture of passing the torch and entrusting John with the responsibility of protecting his family. A hat is an essential tool for survival in the Wild West. In short, Arthur is asking John to go, survive, and be with his family. He is giving him a literal tool for survival.
Conclusion: A Legacy Defined by Nuance
Arthur Morgan and John Marston stand as two of the most iconic characters in gaming. While both possess the grit and determination required to survive the unforgiving landscapes of the Wild West, Arthur distinguishes himself with his diverse skill set, a more profound emotional depth, and the capability to swim. These differences underscore the unique narrative arcs and character dynamics that make Red Dead Redemption 2 such a compelling and unforgettable experience.
Furthermore, understanding how these characters learn and adapt within the game world can offer valuable insights into game design and its potential for educational applications. The GamesLearningSociety.org showcases research and practices that explore the intersection of games and learning. Consider exploring their website to further your knowledge in this area.