Table of Contents

Understanding the Attack Action in D&D 5e: A Comprehensive Guide

The Attack action is a fundamental component of combat in Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition (D&D 5e). It’s the most common action players will take, representing a character’s attempt to strike a foe. But what exactly constitutes an Attack action, and how does it differ from other combat maneuvers? This article provides a comprehensive breakdown of the Attack action, clarifying its mechanics and exploring its nuances.

What is an Attack Action?

At its core, the Attack action in D&D 5e is defined as a single attempt to strike a target using a melee weapon, a ranged weapon, or an unarmed attack. When a character uses their action to take the Attack action, they are essentially committing to a direct physical assault. This action initiates the attack roll, which determines whether the strike hits its intended target. It’s important to note that the Attack action is distinct from other actions, such as casting spells or using special abilities.

The Components of an Attack

An Attack action involves several key components:

Choice of Attack: The player selects what kind of attack they are making: a melee attack, a ranged attack, or an unarmed strike. This choice dictates the weapon used, its range, and potential attack modifiers.
Attack Roll: This is the heart of the Attack action. The player rolls a d20 (20-sided die) and adds their attack bonus. The attack bonus is calculated by adding the character’s proficiency modifier (based on their level) to their relevant ability modifier (Strength for most melee weapons, Dexterity for ranged weapons).
Comparison to Target’s AC: The result of the attack roll is compared to the target’s Armor Class (AC). If the attack roll equals or exceeds the target’s AC, the attack hits. If the result is lower, the attack misses.
Damage Roll: If the attack hits, a damage roll is performed. This typically involves rolling dice based on the weapon used, adding any relevant damage modifiers (e.g., Strength modifier for melee weapons).

Distinguishing Attack Actions from Other Actions

It’s crucial to differentiate the Attack action from other actions in combat:

Cast a Spell Action: Many spells require a character to use their action to cast them. While some spells may involve attack rolls, the act of casting a spell is not considered an Attack action. For example, Eldritch Blast uses the Cast a Spell action, even though it involves making attack rolls.
Other Actions: Actions such as Dash, Disengage, Help, and Hide are all separate from the Attack action. They represent different tactical maneuvers in combat.
Special Abilities: Features like Reckless Attack or specific class features may augment the Attack action but are not themselves considered the Attack action.
Bonus Actions: Spells and actions done as a bonus action are not considered attack actions, including some spells.

Exceptions and Special Cases

While the above covers most cases, some specific situations warrant further clarification:

Extra Attack Feature: The Extra Attack feature, often found in martial classes, allows a character to perform multiple attacks when they take the Attack action. This means the action is still an Attack action, but it produces more attacks. It does not grant the ability to cast a spell and attack, unless other specific class features allow it, such as the Bladesinger’s ability.
Opportunity Attacks: These are special melee attacks triggered when an enemy moves out of an ally’s reach. They are triggered by an enemy’s movement, not a player’s action, therefore not an action in and of themselves. They do, however, still require making an attack roll, making them an attack, within an action.
Unarmed Attacks: Though they are not technically considered “weapon attacks”, unarmed strikes still constitute an attack action, and follow the same rules.
Dragonborn Breath Weapons: These are often mistakenly called attack actions, but are separate actions. While a Dragonborn can use an action to exhale destructive energy, it is not considered to be an attack action.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Is a spell considered an attack in D&D?

Technically, casting a spell is an action, bonus action, or reaction, depending on the spell’s casting time. While some spells may involve an attack roll, the act of casting a spell is not an Attack action.

2. Is a Fireball an attack in D&D?

A Fireball is not an Attack action. It requires a saving throw, not an attack roll, and therefore not part of the Attack action.

3. How do you calculate attack hit in D&D?

Your attack bonus is equal to your proficiency modifier plus your relevant ability modifier (Strength for melee, Dexterity for ranged).

4. Does Eldritch Blast count as an Attack action?

Eldritch Blast is cast using the Cast a Spell action, even though it involves attack rolls. It is not an Attack action.

5. What counts as an attack action in 5e?

An Attack action is a strike dealt with a melee weapon, a ranged weapon, or an unarmed attack.

6. Do weapons count as attack actions?

Weapons are the tools used in the Attack action. They themselves do not constitute an Attack action, rather are used to perform an attack.

7. What determines a critical hit in D&D?

A natural 20 on an attack roll results in a critical hit.

8. How is a D&D ability score calculated?

Ability scores are typically calculated by rolling 4d6, dropping the lowest roll, and repeating six times. The player chooses which rolls go into which ability scores.

9. What is a reckless attack in D&D?

Reckless Attack grants advantage on melee weapon attack rolls, but attack rolls against you gain advantage until your next turn. It enhances an Attack action, not an action in itself.

10. What is considered a weapon attack in D&D?

A “weapon attack” refers to a melee attack or a ranged attack with a weapon. Some attacks count as weapon attacks even if they don’t use a weapon, as specified by the rules.

11. Can you sneak attack objects in D&D?

No, Sneak Attack requires a creature, it does not work on objects.

12. Do spells count as attack rolls?

Some spells require the caster to make an attack roll to determine whether the spell hits. These attacks are governed by spellcasting ability modifier + proficiency bonus.

13. Is dragon’s breath an attack action?

No, the Dragonborn breath weapon is an action, but not the Attack action.

14. Is an opportunity attack considered an attack action?

An Opportunity Attack is not an action itself, it is a reaction, though it involves making a melee attack. It is a reaction to an enemy’s movement out of reach.

15. Is fire breath a bonus action?

A potion of fire breath allows the user to exhale fire as a bonus action, but this is not an attack action.

Conclusion

The Attack action is a cornerstone of combat in D&D 5e, encompassing a wide range of physical strikes using weapons or unarmed combat. Understanding what constitutes an Attack action and how it differs from other actions is crucial for effective gameplay. By carefully considering the distinctions between actions, players can optimize their combat strategies and enjoy the full depth of the D&D experience.

What counts as an attack action in D&D?