What Game is Most Like Elden Ring?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The answer, unequivocally, is Dark Souls 3. While many games share aspects of FromSoftware’s iconic formula, Dark Souls 3 provides the closest experience to Elden Ring in terms of core gameplay mechanics, combat feel, and general atmosphere, though it forgoes the open world. If you’ve been captivated by the vastness and challenges of Elden Ring and are looking for something similar but less sprawling, Dark Souls 3 is the logical and most rewarding next step. It captures the essence of what makes Elden Ring great while maintaining a more linear, yet equally compelling, structure. This similarity extends to combat pacing, enemy designs, boss encounters, and the overall sense of rewarding progression.
Dark Souls 3: The Direct Predecessor
Dark Souls 3 was released just before Elden Ring, which naturally makes it the most refined expression of the design philosophy that led to Elden Ring’s creation. In this, you’ll find a seamless transition, not a radical departure.
Combat and Mechanics
The combat in Dark Souls 3 will feel immediately familiar to Elden Ring players. The emphasis on deliberate attacks, dodging, and stamina management is virtually identical. Weapon variety, from colossal greatswords to swift katanas, is abundant and each weapon type has a comparable counterpart in Elden Ring. You will find yourself feeling instantly at home with the roll timings and strategic battles that define both titles.
Level Design
While Elden Ring is known for its vast, open world, Dark Souls 3 opts for a more interconnected, labyrinthine level design. This doesn’t necessarily mean it’s inferior; on the contrary, it allows for tightly constructed areas filled with secrets and shortcuts. The exploration is still rewarding, just on a more contained scale. This refined, focused level design can be just as engaging and rewarding as the openness of Elden Ring.
Boss Encounters
Boss battles in Dark Souls 3 are another standout feature, often considered some of the best in the entire “Soulsborne” catalogue. They are challenging, requiring mastery of the combat system, and rewarding players who are persistent. Many of these boss encounters are very similar in philosophy to Elden Ring, demanding careful attention to attack patterns and punishing mistakes severely.
Atmosphere and Lore
The dark, melancholic atmosphere and intricate lore of Dark Souls 3 are reminiscent of Elden Ring. The world is filled with decaying grandeur and a sense of impending doom. The story is told through item descriptions, environmental storytelling, and cryptic dialogue, compelling the player to unravel the mysteries of the setting. If you enjoyed the tone and storytelling style of Elden Ring, you will find Dark Souls 3 incredibly appealing.
Why Not Other Souls-Like Games?
While games like Demon’s Souls, Dark Souls 1 & 2, and Bloodborne are excellent, they differ more substantially from Elden Ring.
- Demon’s Souls is the foundational game but feels clunkier by today’s standards.
- Dark Souls 1 has a more interconnected world, but combat is slower and more methodical.
- Dark Souls 2 has several mechanical differences that can feel quite jarring coming from Elden Ring.
- Bloodborne, with its faster, more aggressive combat and gothic setting, stands on its own and offers a very different experience, not as aligned with Elden Ring’s more classic medieval fantasy.
Even though they are part of the same family of games, Dark Souls 3 most successfully modernized the formula leading directly into the design of Elden Ring, which makes it feel like the direct stepping stone to it.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions about Elden Ring and its relationship to other games to help provide a deeper understanding.
1. Is Elden Ring the Most Difficult FromSoftware Game?
While FromSoftware games are known for their difficulty, Elden Ring is generally considered on the easier side compared to its peers. Its open-world design allows players to explore and gain levels elsewhere if they hit a challenging roadblock, making progression less frustrating.
2. What Is the Lore Connection Between Dark Souls and Elden Ring?
There is no direct story or lore connection between the Dark Souls series and Elden Ring. They are set in separate universes, although they share similar themes and a dark fantasy aesthetic.
3. Is There an Official Sequel to Elden Ring?
While nothing is explicitly confirmed by the developer, hints suggest that a sequel is currently in development. Elden Ring is the studio’s most successful title, so a sequel is quite possible and highly anticipated.
4. Should I Play Elden Ring if I’ve Never Played a Souls Game?
Yes, absolutely! Elden Ring is a fantastic entry point into the genre. The open-world and diverse gameplay mechanics make it more approachable than some of the older titles.
5. Is Elden Ring Too Hard for Casual Gamers?
Elden Ring is challenging, but the open world allows casual players to approach it at their own pace. Exploration can be used to increase power and make difficult challenges more manageable.
6. Is Bloodborne Harder than Elden Ring?
Generally, Bloodborne is considered harder than Elden Ring. Bloodborne’s faster combat and lack of the open world make it more demanding. Elden Ring provides several tools to mitigate difficulty, such as summoning help and the ability to leave and explore elsewhere if you are struggling.
7. How Big is the Elden Ring Map Compared to Skyrim?
The map in Elden Ring is considerably larger than Skyrim’s. Elden Ring’s sprawling landscape dwarfs Skyrim.
8. How Long Does it Take to Beat Elden Ring?
On average, it takes about 58 hours to complete the main story of Elden Ring. However, if you aim for 100% completion, expect to invest around 133 hours.
9. Is Elden Ring’s Magic System Better Than Skyrim’s?
While Skyrim has a fun magic system, Elden Ring’s magic is more comprehensive and effective. Elden Ring has taken the Soulsborne magic system to another level.
10. Is there DLC for Elden Ring?
Yes, FromSoftware is developing DLC for Elden Ring. They have only teased a single trailer so far.
11. What Makes Elden Ring So Popular?
The popularity of Elden Ring is due to its challenging but rewarding gameplay, massive open world, and unique sense of exploration. This is combined with detailed lore, intriguing boss fights, and the freedom of being able to tackle the world in the order the player chooses.
12. What is the Hardest Game of All Time?
There is no single answer, but many consider FromSoftware games like Bloodborne and Dark Souls to be among the hardest. Other contenders include games like Contra, Cuphead, and Dwarf Fortress.
13. What is Elden Ring’s “Souls” Equivalent?
Elden Ring’s equivalent to “souls” from the Dark Souls games are Runes. They serve the same purpose of being the in-game currency and experience points.
14. Should I Play the Souls Games in Order?
The recommended order for playing Souls games leading up to Elden Ring is: Demon’s Souls, Dark Souls, Dark Souls 2, Bloodborne, Dark Souls 3, and then Sekiro.
15. Is Elden Ring a Creepy Game?
Elden Ring is a dark and often disturbing environment with some extremely creepy locations and enemies. It is definitely not a game for those who prefer bright and cheerful aesthetics.
Conclusion
While many games can provide a challenge and some dark fantasy aspects, Dark Souls 3 offers the most authentic Elden Ring experience. The similar combat mechanics, boss encounters, and overall design ethos make it the most natural next game for those who enjoyed Elden Ring. If you’re looking for more of what you loved about Elden Ring, look no further than Dark Souls 3. It’s a polished, thrilling, and challenging experience that will certainly scratch that particular itch.