What happens if a monk breaks the rules?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
If a monk breaks any of the four pārājikas, also known as the defeats, he is automatically expelled from the sangha for life and falls from monkhood immediately, with no chance of becoming a monk again in his lifetime. The intention to break a rule is a necessary factor in constituting an offence, and the consequences of breaking the rules can be severe, including expulsion and loss of monkhood.
Understanding the Consequences of Breaking the Rules
The rules that govern a monk’s behavior are in place to help them maintain a simple and humble lifestyle, free from material possessions and worldly desires.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What happens if you break Buddhist rules?
Living a life in violation of the precepts is believed to lead to rebirth in a hell, emphasizing the importance of following the Buddhist rules.
2. What happens if a monk breaks a vow?
If a monk breaks a vow, such as the vow to eat food methodically, it may only require acknowledging it as a misdeed, with no need for a public confession.
3. Do monks get punished?
Monks who conspire and lead other monks to become unruly, or who slander or shame temple officials or elders, shall receive 100 days of punishment.
4. What is forbidden for a monk?
Monks are prohibited from possessing money and from storing food, making them completely dependent on the laity for many simple things.
5. Can a monk get kicked out?
The four pārājikas are rules that entail expulsion from the sangha for life, and if a monk breaks any one of these rules, he is automatically expelled.
6. Can monks have kids?
Monks, for example, are not allowed to get married nor have children, as they leave their family forever and get a new family in the monastery.
7. Do monks get laid?
Sexual activity is permitted for laypeople, but a monk or nun who has sexual intercourse violates a fundamental vow, and is no longer a monastic.
8. Are you allowed to touch a monk?
Under no circumstances should you ever touch a monk, and if you decide to approach a seated monk, make sure to sit down yourself before speaking.
9. Do monks live without money?
According to the Buddhist monastic code, monks and nuns are not allowed to accept money or even to engage in barter or trade with laypeople, living entirely in an economy of gifts.
10. Why can’t monks talk?
Monastic silence functions to avoid sin, and although speech is morally neutral per se, silence is seen as the only effective means of neutralizing a tendency towards sins of the tongue.
11. Can you become a monk if you are divorced?
You may be single or divorced, but your decision to become a monk is in harmony with your ex-partner, so that they will not prevent you from entering training as a monastic.
12. Can a monk get angry?
Monks must embody the qualities of compassion and loving-kindness, and the ability to overcome anger in everyday life is one of the hallmarks of a Buddhist monk.
13. What are the unforgivable sins in Buddhism?
The Dhammasangāni regard five acts – matricide, parricide, slaying an Arhat, slaying a Buddha, and causing division among priesthood – as unpardonable sins.
14. What do Buddhists do when angry?
In the Theravada Buddhism tradition, the antidote to anger is loving-kindness and compassion, and if you’re angry with someone, you hold them in your heart with loving-kindness and compassion.
15. Is it rude to take a picture of a monk?
It is rude to take a picture of a monk without their permission, and you should watch them carefully to see if they are appreciating having you take their photo.