What Happens If Ezio Kills Civilians in Assassin’s Creed?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
In the Assassin’s Creed franchise, particularly during Ezio Auditore’s era (Assassin’s Creed II, Brotherhood, and Revelations), there are consequences for harming innocent civilians. The game implements a system where killing civilians leads to desynchronization. The first civilian kill usually triggers a warning message: “Warning: Ezio Auditore did not kill civilians.” This serves as a caution to the player. Committing a second civilian kill will result in immediate desynchronization, effectively ending the current game sequence and forcing the player to reload from the last checkpoint. This mechanic is designed to reinforce the Assassin’s Creed’s core tenet: to protect the innocent and operate from the shadows, avoiding unnecessary harm.
The Philosophy Behind Civilian Protection
Ubisoft’s decision to penalize civilian killings stems from several factors:
-
Maintaining Historical Authenticity: While Assassin’s Creed takes creative liberties, it strives to ground its narrative in historical settings. Massacring civilians wouldn’t align with the idealized portrayal of an assassin operating for the greater good within those historical contexts.
-
Upholding the Assassin’s Creed: The game’s narrative revolves around a strict code of conduct for the Assassins. Indiscriminate killing directly contradicts this code, disrupting the immersion and narrative coherence.
-
Gameplay Balance and Challenge: The game encourages stealth and strategic approaches. Allowing unhindered civilian killing would significantly lower the difficulty, detracting from the intended gameplay experience.
How the Desynchronization Mechanic Works
The desynchronization mechanic acts as an in-game penalty for deviating from the intended gameplay and narrative. When Ezio commits an action considered unacceptable (like killing a second civilian), the Animus, the device used to relive ancestral memories, interprets it as a divergence from the character’s actual historical actions. This “break” in the historical record leads to desynchronization, forcing the player to restart from a point where the actions align more closely with the character’s established history.
Avoiding Desynchronization
To avoid desynchronization, players should:
- Practice stealth: Utilize rooftops, blending, and social stealth to navigate environments without raising alarms.
- Target only designated enemies: Focus attacks on guards, Templars, and other hostile individuals identified by the game.
- Minimize collateral damage: Be mindful of surroundings during combat to avoid accidentally hitting civilians with weapons or abilities.
- Use non-lethal options: Employ tactics like disarming or stunning enemies when possible.
Civilian Casualties in Other Assassin’s Creed Games
The consequences for killing civilians vary across different Assassin’s Creed titles:
- Assassin’s Creed Origins: Similar to Ezio’s trilogy, attacking civilians in AC: Origins results in a warning message, and further civilian casualties lead to desynchronization.
- Later Titles: Some later games in the series have relaxed the strict desynchronization penalties to some extent, potentially implementing bounty systems or notoriety increases instead of immediate game overs. However, the core principle of avoiding civilian casualties generally remains.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Civilian Casualties in Assassin’s Creed
1. Why does the game warn me when I kill a civilian in Assassin’s Creed?
The warning message (“Warning: Ezio Auditore did not kill civilians”) is a reminder that your actions are contradicting the character’s historical behavior, potentially leading to desynchronization.
2. What is desynchronization in Assassin’s Creed?
Desynchronization is a game mechanic that occurs when the player’s actions significantly deviate from the historical events being relived. It results in a game over and requires the player to restart from the last checkpoint.
3. Can I kill soldiers without penalty in Assassin’s Creed?
Yes, attacking and killing guards, Templars, and other hostile NPCs is part of the intended gameplay and does not typically result in desynchronization.
4. Is there a way to disable the desynchronization mechanic?
No, the desynchronization mechanic is a core element of the Assassin’s Creed games and cannot be disabled.
5. Does the number of consecutive civilian kills affect the penalty?
Typically, the first civilian kill triggers a warning, and the second results in desynchronization. Consecutive kills within a short timeframe don’t escalate the penalty beyond immediate desynchronization.
6. What happens if I accidentally kill a civilian during a fight?
Accidental kills still trigger the warning and subsequent desynchronization if a second civilian is killed. It’s crucial to be mindful of surroundings during combat.
7. Does killing a civilian in self-defense result in desynchronization?
Even if a civilian inadvertently gets caught in the crossfire during self-defense, the desynchronization penalty still applies.
8. Are there any exceptions to the civilian killing rule?
Generally, there are no exceptions. Killing civilians always carries the risk of desynchronization.
9. Do all Assassin’s Creed games have the same civilian killing penalty?
The severity of the penalty can vary across different Assassin’s Creed titles. Some games may introduce alternative consequences like increased notoriety or bounty systems.
10. How does the Animus explain the desynchronization mechanic?
The Animus, as explained within the game’s narrative, interprets deviations from the subject’s historical actions as a “break” in the genetic memory, causing the desynchronization.
11. What is the main reason for Ezio killing people?
Ezio’s kills primarily target those who threaten his family, freedom, or the principles of the Assassin Brotherhood. He operates with a sense of justice and righteousness, even within a world of violence.
12. How many people did Ezio Auditore assassinate?
Estimates vary, but it’s generally accepted that Ezio assassinated several hundred individuals throughout his lifetime across the Assassin’s Creed games.
13. Is it possible to complete Assassin’s Creed without killing anyone?
It is possible to significantly minimize kills and focus on stealth and non-lethal options, but completing the game without any kills is generally not feasible due to certain mandatory combat sequences.
14. What alternatives does Ezio have when fighting?
Ezio can utilize stealth takedowns, disarming opponents, throwing sand to temporarily blind enemies, and utilizing smoke bombs to create distractions and escape. He can also often avoid combat altogether through skillful navigation and blending.
15. Where can I find information about educational games and the impact of games on learning?
You can find valuable information about the educational aspects of games and their impact on learning at the Games Learning Society website: https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/ or GamesLearningSociety.org.
The Assassin’s Creed series, through its mechanics and narrative, underscores the importance of moral choices and the consequences of violence, even within a virtual world.