Choosing to Forego a Keepsake in Elden Ring: A Deep Dive
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
So, you’re starting your journey as a Tarnished in the Lands Between, and the moment has arrived: selecting your Keepsake. But what if you decide to be a minimalist, a purist, or just plain stubborn and choose… nothing? What happens if you don’t choose a Keepsake in Elden Ring? Simply put, you start the game with no additional item beyond your chosen class’s starting equipment. There’s no penalty, no special disadvantage (or advantage), you just begin your adventure with less. Whether that’s a wise choice is another matter entirely, but the game allows it!
Is the Path of the Ungifted Right for You?
The allure of starting with nothing might appeal to seasoned Soulsborne veterans seeking an extra challenge. It’s a way to test your skills, knowledge of the game, and resourcefulness from the absolute outset. However, for newcomers or those simply looking for a smoother start, forgoing a Keepsake might make the initial hours of the game considerably more difficult.
The decision hinges on your comfort level with the notoriously challenging nature of Elden Ring. Are you confident in your ability to manage resources, understand enemy attack patterns, and navigate the world effectively without any initial advantage? If so, then the path of the ungifted might be a rewarding (albeit punishing) experience.
Weighing the Pros and Cons
Potential Benefits of No Keepsake
- Increased Difficulty: For experienced players, it adds an additional layer of challenge and can make the initial hours of the game more engaging.
- No “Wasted” Item: Some players might feel that none of the Keepsakes perfectly align with their build or playstyle, preferring to find items naturally.
- Sense of Accomplishment: Overcoming early obstacles without a starting boost can provide a greater sense of satisfaction.
Drawbacks of Starting Empty-Handed
- Harder Early Game: The initial hours of Elden Ring are already challenging. Starting with nothing makes it even tougher.
- Missed Opportunity: Keepsakes can provide valuable early-game advantages, making certain areas or encounters significantly easier.
- Slower Progression: Without the benefit of a starting item, you might progress slower in the early game as you struggle to acquire necessary resources.
The Value of a Helping Hand
While the temptation to go “naked” into Elden Ring might be strong for some, consider the advantages a Keepsake can offer. Items like the Golden Seed (allowing you to immediately upgrade your flasks) or the Crimson Amber Medallion (boosting your HP) can significantly improve your survivability and resource management in the crucial early hours.
Ultimately, choosing a Keepsake is about tailoring the game’s beginning to your preferences. If you’re new to Soulsborne games or simply want a less punishing start, selecting a helpful item is highly recommended. If you crave a greater challenge and are confident in your abilities, then starting with nothing might be the perfect way to begin your legend.
FAQ: Keepsakes in Elden Ring
1. What exactly is a Keepsake in Elden Ring?
A Keepsake is a starting item you choose during character creation in Elden Ring. It provides an initial advantage or resource that can aid you in the early hours of the game.
2. Are Keepsakes essential for completing Elden Ring?
No, Keepsakes are entirely optional. You can complete the game perfectly fine without choosing one. They simply offer a slight head-start.
3. Which Keepsake is generally considered the “best”?
The Golden Seed is often considered the most versatile and useful Keepsake for most players. It allows you to immediately increase the number of flask charges you have at a Site of Grace.
4. Is the Crimson Amber Medallion a good Keepsake choice?
Yes, the Crimson Amber Medallion, which increases your maximum HP, is another excellent choice, especially for players new to Soulsborne games. It provides a valuable boost to your survivability.
5. What does the Fanged Imp Ashes Keepsake do?
The Fanged Imp Ashes summons two Fanged Imp spirits to aid you in combat. This can be helpful in the early game, but their usefulness diminishes as you progress.
6. What is the Cracked Pot Keepsake used for?
Cracked Pots are used to craft throwable items like firebombs or poison pots. While useful, they are readily available in the game, making this a less valuable Keepsake.
7. Should I choose the Stonesword Key as my Keepsake?
The Stonesword Key allows you to unlock Imp Statues that guard valuable items or areas. While useful, you can find Stonesword Keys throughout the game, so it’s not necessarily the best choice for a Keepsake.
8. What about the Bewitching Branch Keepsake?
Bewitching Branches can temporarily charm enemies to fight for you. They can be helpful in specific situations but are not generally as versatile as other Keepsake options.
9. Is the Lands Between Rune a worthwhile Keepsake?
The Lands Between Rune grants you a small amount of runes. This can provide a slight early-game boost, but the amount is relatively insignificant in the long run.
10. What is the purpose of the Shabriri’s Woe Keepsake?
Shabriri’s Woe greatly increases enemy aggro towards you. This is primarily useful for co-op play, allowing you to draw enemy attention away from your allies.
11. Can I acquire Keepsakes later in the game if I don’t choose one at the start?
No, you cannot acquire the starting Keepsakes later in the game. Once you’ve made your choice (or chosen to forgo one), that’s it.
12. Does choosing a specific Keepsake lock me into a particular build?
No, your Keepsake choice does not restrict your build in any way. You are free to develop your character as you see fit, regardless of your starting item.
13. Does the Astrologer class benefit more from a specific Keepsake?
While the Astrologer can benefit from any of the useful Keepsakes like the Golden Seed or Crimson Amber Medallion, they can also make good use of the Cracked Pot, as the class uses spells instead of melee weapons.
14. If I die and lose my runes, does my Keepsake disappear too?
No, your Keepsake is a permanent starting item. It will not be lost if you die or lose your runes. Only the Sacrificial Twig talisman has this behavior.
15. Where can I learn more about Elden Ring strategies and gameplay mechanics?
You can find a wealth of information about Elden Ring strategies, build guides, and gameplay mechanics on various online forums, wikis, and YouTube channels. You might also find interesting insights into game design and learning at the Games Learning Society website (GamesLearningSociety.org).
In conclusion, the decision of whether or not to choose a Keepsake in Elden Ring is a personal one. Weigh the pros and cons carefully, consider your playstyle and experience level, and choose what you believe will best enhance your experience in the Lands Between. Good luck, Tarnished!