The Lure of the Unbreakable: What Happens When You Refuse to Return the Skeleton Key in Skyrim?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
So, you’ve got your hands on the Skeleton Key in Skyrim. It’s shimmering, whispering promises of effortless lockpicking. But a nagging thought creeps in: Do I really have to give this back? The short answer is no. The longer, much more interesting answer involves weighing convenience against completion, power against principle, and a healthy dose of player agency that Bethesda is famous for providing. Refusing to return the Skeleton Key effectively turns it into a permanent unbreakable lockpick. But this decision comes with consequences.
The Unbreakable Promise and the Guild’s Dilemma
Keeping the Skeleton Key means you’ll never fumble with broken lockpicks again. Any lock, regardless of difficulty, yields to your touch. This is especially attractive to characters who haven’t invested heavily in the Lockpicking skill tree. Imagine waltzing through dungeons, effortlessly unlocking chests and doors that would otherwise require a pile of snapped lockpicks and a whole lot of frustration.
However, there’s a catch: The Thieves Guild questline cannot be completed if the Skeleton Key is not returned. Specifically, you won’t be able to proceed past the quest “Blindsighted” and get to the quest “Darkness Returns”, locking you out of becoming the Guildmaster. If you’re a completionist who wants to experience the full arc of the Thieves Guild, the key must go back to its rightful owner, the Daedric Prince Nocturnal.
The Trade-Off: Convenience vs. Completion
The decision boils down to your play style and priorities.
For the Casual Thief:
If you prioritize convenience and exploration over completing every questline, keeping the Skeleton Key is a fantastic choice. It streamlines gameplay, eliminates lockpicking frustration, and lets you focus on other aspects of Skyrim’s vast world.
For the Completionist:
If you crave that Guildmaster title and want to see every corner of the Thieves Guild story, you’ll need to relinquish the key. The reward for returning it is Nocturnal’s Agent ability. This ability is a daily power that grants one of three effects: Shadowcloak of Nocturnal (invisibility), Nocturnal’s Embrace (absorb health), or Nocturnal’s Strangulation (absorb stamina). The effect that you get each day at random. These abilities are situational, but some players find value in them.
The Power Gamer’s Perspective:
For those obsessed with optimizing their character, reaching a Lockpicking skill of 100 and investing in the “Unbreakable” perk essentially replicates the Skeleton Key‘s effect. This allows you to complete the Thieves Guild questline and have an unbreakable lockpick. The key becomes redundant, allowing you to return it without sacrificing the benefit it provides.
Considering the Alternatives
Before making your decision, consider these factors:
- Your Skill Level: If you’re early in the game and struggling with lockpicking, the Skeleton Key is a godsend. But as your skill increases, its value diminishes.
- Your Playstyle: Are you a meticulous thief who meticulously plans heists, or a more impulsive adventurer who wants to open every lock they encounter?
- Your Goals: Do you want to become Guildmaster and fully experience the Thieves Guild story, or are you more interested in exploring Skyrim’s dungeons and hidden secrets?
The Aesthetic Argument
Some players keep the Skeleton Key simply for aesthetic reasons. It’s a unique and powerful artifact, and having it in your inventory is a tangible reminder of your adventures with the Thieves Guild. However, consider that it is also a Daedric artifact, and might not fit the persona of every roleplay character.
FAQs: Unlocking the Secrets of the Skeleton Key
1. Can I get the Skeleton Key back after returning it?
No. Once you return the Skeleton Key to the Ebonmere (Nocturnal’s shrine), it’s gone for good. There’s no way to retrieve it in subsequent playthroughs.
2. Do I have to return the Skeleton Key to become Guildmaster?
Yes. Completing the Thieves Guild questline, including returning the Skeleton Key, is a prerequisite for becoming the Guildmaster.
3. What happens if I lose the Skeleton Key?
In Skyrim, the Skeleton Key is unlosable. It’s a quest item, so you can’t drop it or accidentally sell it.
4. Is the Skeleton Key worth it?
That depends on your priorities. If you struggle with lockpicking and value convenience, the Skeleton Key is invaluable. If you’re a completionist or a power gamer, its value diminishes as you level up your Lockpicking skill.
5. Does the Skeleton Key level up my Lockpicking skill faster?
No. The Skeleton Key simply allows you to open locks without breaking lockpicks. It doesn’t affect the rate at which your Lockpicking skill increases.
6. What level should my Lockpicking skill be before returning the Skeleton Key?
Around level 90 or higher. At this point, you’ll have unlocked most of the perks in the Lockpicking skill tree, and Master locks will no longer pose a significant challenge.
7. What are the benefits of becoming Guildmaster?
Becoming Guildmaster grants you access to a special room in the Thieves Guild headquarters, improved fences for selling stolen goods, and radiant quests that allow you to continue supporting the Thieves Guild.
8. Are there any mods that allow me to keep the Skeleton Key and complete the Thieves Guild questline?
Yes, there are mods available that allow you to complete the Thieves Guild questline without returning the Skeleton Key. Search for mods on Nexus Mods to get it.
9. Can I duplicate the Skeleton Key?
Without using console commands or exploits, no. There is no legitimate way to duplicate the Skeleton Key within the game.
10. What if I accidentally return the Skeleton Key too early?
Unfortunately, there’s no way to undo your decision. You’ll have to live with the consequences or reload a previous save.
11. Is there any other unbreakable lockpicks besides the Skeleton Key?
Besides getting the Lockpicking perk, no. The Skeleton Key is unique, and if lost, there are no other ways to obtain one besides a brand new playthrough.
12. What is Nocturnal’s Agent power?
Nocturnal’s Agent is the power you gain from completing the Thieve’s Guild questline that allows you to choose between Shadowcloak of Nocturnal (invisibility), Nocturnal’s Embrace (absorb health), or Nocturnal’s Strangulation (absorb stamina).
13. Can I become the leader of the Thieves Guild?
Yes, you can, by doing five jobs in each of the capitals of the major holds. After you completed five of those jobs in a specific hold capital, you will be assigned a special quest.
14. How many jobs does it take to restore the Thieves Guild?
You can take various jobs from Delvin and Vex in the major hold capitals. When you have completed five of those jobs in a specific hold capital, you will be assigned a special quest in that location.
15. Is Brynjolf marriable?
Yes, with mods! In the base game, he is not.
Making the Choice: A Matter of Perspective
Ultimately, the decision to return or retain the Skeleton Key is a personal one. There’s no right or wrong answer. Consider your play style, your goals, and your tolerance for frustration, and choose the path that will bring you the most enjoyment in your Skyrim adventure. And remember, there is no way to “have your cake and eat it too” unless you download mods, or console commands.
Further enriching the gaming experience through research and understanding, groups like the Games Learning Society (GamesLearningSociety.org) explore the educational potential within games, offering insights into how these choices and challenges shape player engagement and learning.