Unlocking Astarion’s Secrets: The Necromancy of Thay and its Consequences
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Giving the Necromancy of Thay to Astarion in Baldur’s Gate 3 results in a unique but ultimately short-lived interaction. While it significantly increases his Approval and unlocks special dialogue options related to his past and thirst for knowledge, it immediately ends the questline associated with the book. This means you permanently lose the opportunity to read the book yourself and benefit from its potent (though risky) secrets, or to give it to Gale, who also has a vested interest in the tome. Essentially, you’re trading a significant piece of lore and power for a temporary boost in Astarion’s affection and some exclusive conversation. The decision hinges on your priorities: companion bonding or personal power.
Delving Deeper: Astarion and the Necromancy of Thay
The Necromancy of Thay is no ordinary book; it’s a gateway to forbidden knowledge and potentially immense power. Understanding the ramifications of handing it over to Astarion requires considering both his character arc and the book’s inherent dangers. Astarion, a vampire spawn with a troubled past, is naturally drawn to the dark arts, seeing it as a potential avenue for escaping his servitude and reclaiming agency over his life.
Giving him the book plays into his desire for power, offering a glimpse into the arcane secrets that could reshape his existence. The resulting dialogue provides valuable insights into his character, revealing his ambitions and fears in ways that might not otherwise be accessible. This can strengthen your relationship and offer opportunities for deeper roleplaying.
However, this act comes at a cost. The Necromancy of Thay holds numerous traps and challenges for anyone who attempts to read it. These challenges come in the form of increasingly difficult Wisdom checks. Successfully navigating these checks unlocks powerful boons, including the Forbidden Knowledge trait. By giving the book to Astarion, you forfeit the chance to claim these benefits for yourself or another party member.
Furthermore, completing the Necromancy of Thay questline normally leads to further exploration and encounters tied to its secrets. Giving the book to Astarion abruptly cuts this narrative thread, preventing you from experiencing the full scope of this dark and fascinating storyline.
The decision to give the Necromancy of Thay to Astarion truly depends on how you want to shape your game experience. If you prioritize character relationships and uncovering the intricate details of your companions’ histories, then it might be worthwhile. However, if you’re interested in maximizing your character’s power and experiencing all the quests the game has to offer, it’s best to keep the book for yourself. Remember, this is a permanent choice with lasting consequences.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Astarion and Choices
What happens if I let Astarion feed on me?
When you allow Astarion to drink your blood, you receive the Bloodless debuff, which imposes a -1 penalty on all checks until you take a long rest. The only way to avoid this debuff is to allow him to kill you during the feeding process, which can be rectified with a Scroll of Revivify or by paying Withers to revive you.
What happens if I let Astarion ascend?
If you allow Astarion to ascend, he will become significantly more arrogant and power-hungry, openly expressing a desire to dominate the world. This decision drastically alters his personality and may negatively impact your relationship.
Should I give Astarion the parasite?
Consuming regular parasites poses little risk, with the primary consequence being disapproval from most companions, excluding Astarion. There are no significant long-term drawbacks.
Should I open the Necromancy of Thay myself?
Opening and reading the Necromancy of Thay is generally considered beneficial, as successfully passing the Wisdom checks grants the Forbidden Knowledge trait.
Can I romance Astarion without letting him drink my blood?
Yes, romancing Astarion is possible without allowing him to drink your blood. The most important factor is maintaining a high enough Approval rating with him.
Should I let Astarion turn me into a vampire?
While there is a slight risk of death, letting Astarion bite you has more advantages than disadvantages. It doesn’t turn you into a vampire, but it does have minor physical effects.
Do I let Astarion drink my blood regularly?
If you plan to keep Astarion in your party permanently, letting him drink your blood grants him the Happy buff, adding +1 to all his checks, and also grants him the Vampire Bite action in combat.
Does Astarion become evil if he ascends?
Astarion’s ascension leads to a morally questionable ending where he becomes more ruthless and power-hungry, significantly altering his character for the worse.
Can you have a happy ending with Astarion?
Achieving a positive ending with Astarion involves keeping him as a Vampire Spawn and potentially searching for a cure for his vampirism. This offers a more emotionally satisfying resolution compared to his ascension.
Can you convince Astarion not to ascend?
Yes, you can convince Astarion not to ascend through dialogue options, leading him to kill Cazador without performing the ascension ritual. This leads to a more benevolent version of Astarion.
What happens if Astarion drinks Araj’s blood?
If Astarion drinks Araj’s blood, she will reward you with a powerful potion that has a permanent effect.
What is the best ending for Astarion?
The best ending for Astarion involves preventing his ascension, killing Cazador, and helping him come to terms with his vampirism. This results in a more compassionate and stable Astarion.
What was Astarion before he became a vampire?
Before becoming a vampire spawn, Astarion was a magistrate who was targeted by a group of Gur, then enslaved and tortured by Cazador.
How do I stop Astarion from doing the ascension ritual?
To prevent Astarion from performing the ritual, engage with the dialogue options after defeating Cazador and convince him that the ritual will either kill the vampire spawn or consume him entirely.
When can you sleep with Astarion?
You can engage in a romance scene with Astarion after gaining sufficient Approval and completing the Save the Refugees side-quest, which leads to a refugee celebration.
Games can provide unique immersive experiences that allow players to explore different perspectives and complex decisions, enriching the learning experience. You can find further research and insights on this topic at the Games Learning Society website: https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.