What happens if you give Nepheli the potion?

If you give Nepheli the potion, she will turn into a doll and leave Roundtable Hold soon after, becoming an eternal slave to Seluvis, thereby prematurely ending her questline. This decision will also allow you to purchase her Spirit Ashes from Seluvis later on, but it’s not a recommended choice, as her Spirit Ashes aren’t worth upgrading in Elden Ring.

Understanding the Consequences

To further understand the implications of giving Nepheli the potion, let’s explore some frequently asked questions related to this topic.

FAQs

1. What happens if you don’t give Nepheli the potion? If you choose not to give Nepheli the potion, you can progress her questline by giving her the Stormhawk King, which will remind her of her past and allow her to regain her strength as a warrior.
2. What is the point of the Stormhawk King? The Stormhawk King is a crucial item required to progress Nepheli Loux and Kenneth Haight’s questlines, making it a significant element in the story.
3. Where did Gideon’s daughter go? Nepheli Loux, who is Gideon Ofnir’s adoptive daughter, can be found in the room outside the library at Roundtable Hold after defeating Godrick the Grafted and exhausting Gideon’s initial dialog.
4. What happens if you use Miquella’s Needle before Melina burns herself? Using Miquella’s Needle before Melina burns herself is a critical choice that affects the story, but the specifics of this action are not directly related to giving Nepheli the potion.
5. Who killed Seluvis? Seluvis was killed by Ranni offscreen, as a consequence of his own actions and Ranni’s quest for power.
6. Is Seluvis a bad guy? Yes, Seluvis is portrayed as a villainous character, known for his manipulative and abusive behavior, including being a serial rapist.
7. What to do after not giving Nepheli the potion? After deciding not to give Nepheli the potion, you should give her the Stormhawk King to progress her questline and help her regain her former glory.
8. Should I give the potion to Nepheli or Gideon? It’s not recommended to give the potion to either Nepheli or Gideon, as both choices lead to negative outcomes, but giving it to Nepheli directly ends her questline.
9. Can you talk to Nepheli after beating Godrick? Yes, Nepheli can be found and spoken to after defeating Godrick, allowing you to progress her story or give her the potion if you choose to do so.
10. Is Nepheli Loux puppet good? While Nepheli’s puppet form can be a powerful Spirit to summon, turning her into a puppet by giving her the potion is not recommended due to the story consequences.
11. Who is the evilest character in Elden Ring? The Frenzied Flame is considered the most evil force in Elden Ring, aiming to spread chaos and destruction, though characters like Mohg and the Dung Eater also exhibit extremely villainous behaviors.
12. Is the Dung Eater evil? Yes, the Dung Eater is one of the most evil characters, known for his horrific actions, including cultivating Seedbed Curses on corpses to prevent souls from reaching the Erdtree.
13. How do you get the Dung Eater after Seluvis dies? The Dung Eater puppet can be obtained from Seluvis’s corpse after he dies, typically after Ranni kills him upon receiving the Fingerslayer Blade.
14. Why did Seluvis want Nepheli? Seluvis targeted Nepheli because of her potential and the possibility of controlling her as a powerful puppet, which could aid him in his own ambitions.
15. What did the Dung Eater do to his victims? The Dung Eater would cultivate Seedbed Curses on the corpses of his victims, ensuring their souls could not ascend to the Erdtree, leaving them cursed forever.