The Consequences of Giving Seluvis’s Potion to the Dung Eater in Elden Ring
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Giving Seluvis’s potion to the Dung Eater in Elden Ring has significant and irreversible consequences, effectively ending his questline and altering the obtainable rewards. Specifically, by administering the potion to the Dung Eater, you permanently lock yourself out of obtaining his unique armor set and the possibility of achieving his ending. Instead, you are given the Dung Eater Puppet Spirit Ashes by Seluvis after you have handed the potion over. This action transforms the Dung Eater into a puppet, under Seluvis’s control, removing him from the rest of his intended story arc within the game. Essentially, you are trading a potential ending and unique gear for a powerful summon. This choice has serious ramifications for those looking to experience the full breadth of Elden Ring‘s narrative and item collecting opportunities.
The Dung Eater’s Quest and Its Alternatives
Before delving further into the specifics, it’s crucial to understand the Dung Eater’s questline and the different pathways one can take. Normally, the Dung Eater’s quest involves several key steps:
- Meeting the Dung Eater at the Roundtable Hold.
- Finding a Seedbed Curse and speaking to him to obtain the Sewer-Gaol Key.
- Locating and freeing his physical body in the Subterranean Shunning Grounds beneath Leyndell, Royal Capital.
- Following his storyline, culminating in the ability to achieve his unique ending with the Mending Rune of the Fell Curse.
However, the potion acts as a major detour, immediately bypassing the later parts of the quest and transforming the Dung Eater into a puppet for Seluvis.
The Potion’s Impact
When you give the potion to the Dung Eater, he is essentially “captured” by Seluvis and turned into a puppet, thus nullifying any further progress on his questline. The Dung Eater no longer gives you the opportunity to obtain his armor. The narrative shifts, instead providing you with the Dung Eater Puppet spirit ash. This potent summon mirrors the Dung Eater’s tanky nature, absorbing damage and pulling aggro from your opponents effectively, but at the cost of his armor set and quest ending.
The Consequences in Detail
- Loss of Armor Set: The Dung Eater’s Omen Armor Set is a uniquely designed set of gear that is only obtainable by progressing through the later stages of his quest. This set is completely inaccessible if the potion is given, thus eliminating the chance to add it to your collection.
- Locked Out of the Ending: The Mending Rune of the Fell Curse leads to a bleak and disturbing ending. This ending, however negative it may seem, is a part of the games story, and you are locked out of this opportunity by giving him the potion.
- No more Seedbed Curse Interaction: One of the key mechanics of the Dung Eater’s quest involves collecting Seedbed Curses. Giving the potion renders these items pointless in terms of the Dung Eater’s plot.
- Spirit Ash Replacement: The immediate reward for this action is the Dung Eater Puppet Spirit Ash. The power of the summon serves as a very powerful tank, but at the cost of other in-game rewards.
Why Players Might Choose This Path
Despite the negative consequences, there are reasons why players may opt to give the potion to the Dung Eater:
- Spirit Ash Utility: The Dung Eater Puppet is a powerful summon that excels at drawing enemy aggro and mitigating boss damage, which can be a massive asset in tough encounters. For some players, this immediately usable summon can be considered more valuable than a potential armor set.
- Questline Dislike: Some players might find the Dung Eater’s character and actions abhorrent, and may not want to progress through his quest, opting instead to remove him from the equation.
- Alternative Progression: Players may be following Seluvis’s quest and find this an important part of the questline in order to achieve specific goals.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some common questions players have about giving the potion to the Dung Eater:
1. What exactly is Seluvis’s potion?
Seluvis’s potion, originally intended for Nepheli Loux, is a concoction that turns the recipient into a puppet under his control. It’s a tool he uses to enslave and manipulate others to his will.
2. Can I reverse the decision to give Dung Eater the potion?
Unfortunately, no. Once you administer the potion to the Dung Eater, the change is permanent and irreversible, locking you out of his associated quest ending and armor set for that playthrough.
3. Can I still get the Dung Eater’s armor set after giving him the potion?
No. Giving the Dung Eater the potion and getting the Dung Eater Puppet locks you out of obtaining his armor set in the current playthrough. There is no way to backtrack this decision.
4. Is the Dung Eater ending worth pursuing?
The Dung Eater’s ending is considered a “bad” ending, where the world is cursed. Whether it’s “worth it” depends on individual preferences. Some players might want to experience all endings, even if they are negative.
5. What are Seedbed Curses, and how are they related to the Dung Eater?
Seedbed Curses are key items that progress the Dung Eater’s quest. He requires you to find these and present them in order to achieve the other parts of his questline.
6. Can I summon the Dung Eater before I give him the potion?
Yes. You can summon the Dung Eater as an ally for the Morgott fight provided you have released him from his cell before giving him the potion. However, giving him the potion will prevent you from using his summon in later gameplay.
7. Is the Dung Eater Puppet spirit ash any good?
The Dung Eater Puppet is a strong summon. It has high damage resistance and excels at drawing aggro, making it a useful ally in battles.
8. Should I give the potion to Gideon Ofnir?
Giving the potion to Gideon Ofnir is an alternate option. This is a preferred choice for players who want the rewards from the quests of both Dung Eater and Nepheli as opposed to the Dung Eater puppet.
9. What is the Dung Eater’s weakness?
The Dung Eater is weak to fire damage. Keep this in mind if you choose to fight him.
10. How do I access the Subterranean Shunning Grounds?
The Subterranean Shunning Grounds are located beneath Leyndell, Royal Capital. You’ll need to find the entrance via a ladder near the main road within the capital.
11. Does the Dung Eater have any lore implications?
The Dung Eater’s lore is grim and disturbing, focusing on themes of defilement and torment. He is one of the most morally corrupt characters in Elden Ring.
12. Does killing the Dung Eater after giving him the potion still give his armor set?
No, killing the Dung Eater after giving him the potion does not give his armor. You only obtain the spirit ash after turning him into a puppet for Seluvis.
13. Can you turn other characters into puppets?
Yes, you can attempt to turn other characters into puppets as part of Seluvis’s questline, but this usually leads to negative consequences.
14. What happens if you attempt to give Ranni the amber draught?
Attempting to give Ranni the amber draught results in her killing the player instantly, thus failing this side quest.
15. How does the Dung Eater ending impact the world of Elden Ring?
The Dung Eater’s ending curses the world, resulting in a bleak outcome where all inhabitants suffer. It’s one of the darkest and most controversial endings in the game.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the decision to give Seluvis’s potion to the Dung Eater comes down to individual player choices. While it can be a shortcut to a powerful summon, it is a major trade-off that robs players of the chance to fully experience the Dung Eater’s quest and the rewards associated with it. Consider your gameplay priorities and desired outcomes before making this permanent decision. Weighing the long-term consequences with the immediate gratification is crucial to ensure a rewarding experience in Elden Ring.