What Happens If You Give the Red Jeweled Brooch in Bloodborne?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Giving the Red Jeweled Brooch to the Young Girl in Central Yharnam triggers a specific sequence of events with a tragic outcome. If you choose this path, the girl will recognize the brooch as belonging to her mother, Viola. Understanding that this signifies her mother’s demise, she will become deeply distraught and leave her home. Unfortunately, this ultimately leads to her being killed by one of the scavenging pigs found in the sewers below Yharnam. There’s no way to prevent this outcome; it’s a set piece of the game’s narrative, highlighting the grim and unforgiving nature of Bloodborne.
Detailed Consequences of Giving the Brooch
When you hand over the brooch, you’re essentially confirming the girl’s worst fears. This act triggers her departure from her home, and as the article excerpt highlights, she’s “coded” to meet a grim end, regardless of your intentions. This moment serves as a bleak reminder that some outcomes in Bloodborne are inevitable, emphasizing the game’s themes of loss and despair.
It is essential to understand that giving the brooch does not lead to a “good” ending for the girl. The game presents a choice, but neither option spares her from tragedy. This makes the decision a moral one, forcing players to confront the harsh realities of the game’s world. Players must decide whether they want to confirm the girl’s suspicions about her mother and push her to a certain demise, or to preserve some innocence but potentially lead her to the same fate.
Morality and Player Agency
This scenario highlights the limitations of player agency in Bloodborne. While the game often allows for strategic choices and varying approaches to combat, some narrative threads are immutable. This design choice serves to reinforce the game’s thematic concerns. The inability to save every character underlines the hopelessness that permeates Yharnam.
Moreover, it encourages players to grapple with difficult moral decisions that don’t necessarily have a “right” answer. There isn’t a clear-cut, morally superior path; each outcome carries its own weight and implications. In fact, the Games Learning Society promotes the study of how such games impact the players. These challenges create a more immersive and emotionally resonant experience for the player.
Alternatives to Giving the Brooch
If you choose not to give the brooch, the girl will instead ask for guidance. This presents a different set of options, though they ultimately lead to similar tragic endings. You can:
- Direct her to Oedon Chapel: If you’ve spoken to the NPC in Oedon Chapel, you can suggest she seek refuge there. However, this seemingly safe haven is far from a guarantee of safety.
- Direct her to Iosefka’s Clinic: Similarly, if you’ve unlocked Iosefka’s Clinic, you can advise her to go there. However, Iosefka’s Clinic is also not a refuge; the “patients” there suffer a far more terrible fate.
- Withhold Information: You can choose to remain silent, offering no advice.
No matter which path you choose, the girl’s ultimate fate remains sealed. This underscores the inescapable nature of tragedy in Bloodborne.
FAQs about the Red Jeweled Brooch and the Young Girl
What happens if I kill the pig in the sewers?
Killing the pig after the girl has disappeared from her home will not prevent her death. The event is triggered once she leaves, regardless of the pig’s continued existence.
Is there any way to save Gascoigne’s daughters?
No, both daughters are destined to die. You can delay the younger daughter’s death if you do not interact with her until after Rom is defeated.
Is the Red Blood Gem obtained from crushing the brooch any good?
Early game, the Red Blood Gem obtained from crushing the brooch is incredibly valuable. It’s a solid upgrade that will significantly enhance your weapon’s capabilities.
Where do I find the Red Jeweled Brooch?
The Red Jeweled Brooch is found on Viola’s corpse at the Tomb of Oedon, after defeating Father Gascoigne.
Can I change my mind after giving the brooch?
No. Once you’ve given the brooch or directed the girl to a location, you can’t reverse your decision. The consequences are irreversible for that playthrough.
Should I lie to the girl about her mother?
The game doesn’t offer the option to explicitly lie and tell her that her mother is alive. You can withhold information, but you cannot fabricate a story.
What does the girl drop if I send her to Iosefka’s Clinic?
If you send her to Iosefka’s Clinic, she drops the Formless Oedon rune upon her demise.
What do I get if I send her to Oedon Chapel?
If you send her to Oedon Chapel, she will provide two messenger skins: the White Messenger Ribbon and Red Messenger Ribbon.
Is it better to get the Blood Gem or the Messenger Ribbons?
This depends on your priorities. If you value early-game combat power, the Blood Gem is superior. If you prioritize cosmetic items and are willing to sacrifice early-game power, the Messenger Ribbons are more appealing. Most players new to the game recommend using the Blood Gem as it is of more value to newcomers.
What are the best messenger ribbons in the game?
The messenger ribbons are cosmetic items, so “best” is subjective. Some players like the look of the ribbons you get from Gascoigne’s Daughter, and some prefer the ribbons you get from various other sources.
What is the purpose of the Messenger’s?
The messengers are purely cosmetic in Bloodborne. They allow you to customize the appearance of the small creatures that deliver messages from other players in the game.
What are some other tragic character stories in Bloodborne?
Bloodborne is full of tragic storylines, including those involving Eileen the Crow, the inhabitants of the Fishing Hamlet, and the patients of Iosefka’s Clinic.
How can I improve my character’s survivability in Bloodborne?
Leveling up, upgrading weapons, equipping appropriate armor, and mastering combat mechanics are all crucial for improving your character’s survivability.
Is Bloodborne a difficult game?
Yes, Bloodborne is known for its high difficulty. However, with patience, practice, and strategic thinking, it can be a rewarding experience.
Where can I learn more about Bloodborne’s lore and gameplay?
You can find information on the Bloodborne Wiki, community forums, and YouTube channels dedicated to the game. You can also find great scholarly articles about the impact of games like Bloodborne on players at GamesLearningSociety.org.
By exploring these options and considering the consequences of each choice, you can navigate the world of Bloodborne with a greater understanding of its complexities and its often-grim realities.