The Perils and Pleasures of Polygamy: Dating Multiple Partners in Stardew Valley
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
What happens when you juggle multiple romances in the charming world of Stardew Valley? The short answer is: drama, and lots of it! While the game allows you to charm your way into the hearts of all the eligible bachelors and bachelorettes, there are consequences to consider before embarking on a whirlwind polyamorous adventure.
The primary consequence of dating multiple characters is a significant loss of friendship hearts. If you manage to reach the maximum heart level (10 hearts) with every single dating option without taking certain precautions, you’ll trigger a special confrontation cutscene. This scene, known as the “Group Betrayal Cutscene,” occurs when you enter the Stardrop Saloon. In this scene, all your love interests will gather and express their dismay, anger, and hurt upon learning about your dating escapades with each other. This encounter will cause your relationship level with each of those characters to plummet, resulting in a significant drop in hearts. You will have to work hard to regain lost hearts and rebuild their trust.
However, all is not lost! There’s a way to avoid this awkward and heart-wrenching confrontation: the Rabbit’s Foot. By carrying a Rabbit’s Foot in your inventory, you can prevent the Group Betrayal Cutscene from triggering. This allows you to continue dating everyone without the penalty of the heart-dropping event. However, this only postpones the reckoning, it doesn’t eliminate the potential issues.
It’s important to note that while you can have multiple “boyfriends” or “girlfriends,” you can only marry one NPC in Stardew Valley at a time. Once married, your spouse will move into your farmhouse, and they will be your main romantic relationship. You can’t marry multiple NPCs simultaneously. You can, however, divorce your spouse and marry someone else, though this action does come with its own set of consequences, and costs.
Dating, Marriage, and Beyond: Navigating the Complexities
While the freedom to date everyone in Stardew Valley offers a unique gameplay experience, there are nuances to understand:
Dating vs. Marriage
- Dating involves raising the friendship level of eligible NPCs and giving them a Bouquet to signify your romantic interest. This can be done with multiple NPCs at once (although this risks the aforementioned Group Betrayal Scene).
- Marriage is the final commitment you make to a single NPC. Once married, your spouse moves into your farmhouse and offers perks and benefits. You will also no longer be able to date other NPCs while married.
Consequences of Dating While Married
While married, you can still gift bouquets to other eligible characters. If you do, your spouse will become jealous if you give a gift to a character who is the same gender as your spouse and is also considered your romantic partner (i.e., you have given them a bouquet). This jealousy will be temporary, but it will impact your current spouse’s mood. Your spouse might give you the cold shoulder or refuse to speak to you, for example.
The other character that you gave the bouquet to, will still be listed as single even if you have given them the bouquet and are technically “dating”. This is because you are already married and are occupied.
The Witch’s Hut and Ex-Spouses
If you regret your marriage choice, the Witch’s Hut allows you to erase the memories of your ex-spouse for a cost of 30,000g. This option can then allow you to re-date your ex, or someone else entirely, and eventually remarry. However, if you have children with your ex-spouse, they will remain at the farm even after a divorce. If you are expecting a child at the time you get divorced, the child will not be born.
Multiplayer Relationships
In multiplayer mode, players can marry each other by gifting a Wedding Ring, a craftable item. Player-to-player marriage does not affect your romantic relationship with NPCs, allowing you to marry both a player and an NPC (though you can’t marry two players). The process of having children is also similar to marrying an NPC. The main player will be asked if they want to have a child, and the farmhand spouse will also need to agree to have the child.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some common questions regarding relationships and dating in Stardew Valley:
-
Can I have multiple boyfriends or girlfriends in Stardew Valley at once?
Yes, you can date all the eligible bachelors or bachelorettes simultaneously by giving them a Bouquet. However, there are consequences to dating everyone at once. -
How do I avoid the “Group Betrayal Cutscene” when dating everyone?
Carry a Rabbit’s Foot in your inventory. This will prevent the cutscene from triggering, allowing you to avoid the negative relationship hit. -
Can I marry multiple NPCs at the same time?
No, you can only marry one NPC at a time. To marry another NPC, you must first divorce your current spouse. -
What happens if I divorce my spouse?
Your ex-spouse will move out of your farmhouse. You can either let your ex remember your time together, or go to the Witch’s Hut to have your ex’s memory erased for 30,000g. Your children, if any, will stay on the farm, but any unborn child will not be delivered. -
Can I remarry my ex-spouse after a divorce?
Yes, after using the Witch’s Hut to erase their memory, you can once again date them and eventually remarry them. -
Can I marry another player in multiplayer Stardew Valley?
Yes, you can marry another player by gifting them a Wedding Ring. This is separate from marrying an NPC. -
Can you kiss your spouse in multiplayer Stardew Valley?
Yes, you can! This is triggered by simply interacting with your player spouse, and both players will freeze in movement for the duration of the kiss animation. -
What happens if I date someone while married in Stardew Valley?
If you give a gift to a person you are dating who is the same gender as your spouse, your spouse will get upset but not permanently. The person you are dating will still be listed as “single” even with a bouquet as you are already officially married. -
Do spouses help on the farm?
Yes, a happy spouse will help with farm chores like watering crops, feeding animals, or repairing fences. -
Can I have children with my spouse in Stardew Valley?
Yes, you can have a maximum of two children. The gender of the first child is random, and the second child will be the opposite gender of the first. Children will not grow past the toddler stage. -
Is there a “best” spouse in Stardew Valley?
This is subjective, but many players find Maru to be a good spouse due to the valuable gifts she provides. Others may prefer the personality of characters like Emily. -
Who is the hardest to marry in Stardew Valley?
Haley is often considered the most challenging due to her initial snobbish attitude, although many find her story arc to be rewarding. -
Who is the easiest to marry in Stardew Valley?
Leah is known as one of the easiest to romance due to her love of foraged items and even common pieces of trash. -
Does it matter who you marry in Stardew Valley?
No, all spouses give roughly the same type of gifts, and none give you anything game-changing. The choice of who to marry is ultimately based on personal preference. -
Can I date the Wizard in Stardew Valley?
Not in the vanilla game. However, the Stardew Valley Expanded mod allows players to date and even marry the Wizard.
By understanding the rules and consequences, you can confidently navigate the romantic terrain of Stardew Valley, whether you choose to stay loyal to one partner or explore the options with multiple love interests. Remember that the core of the game is to have fun and play in your own way!