The Blackburn Dilemma: What Happens When You Let Him Go in Fallout 76?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Deciding whether to let Dr. Blackburn walk free in Fallout 76 is a pivotal moment in the Steel Reign DLC. The consequences of your choice ripple through the Wasteland, impacting the future of the Brotherhood of Steel and the fate of countless individuals. If you allow Dr. Blackburn to escape, you’re essentially gambling on his word that he can stop the FEV distribution. He claims to possess the only access code to abort the plan, making him the only potential solution, provided his fellow scientists are spared. This decision hinges on your trust in a man who is willing to go to extreme lengths to achieve his vision of a “better” humanity, a vision fueled by his obsession with the Forced Evolutionary Virus (FEV). The ramifications are far-reaching, hinging on whether you believe Blackburn is sincere and capable of controlling the chaos he unleashed.
The Stakes of Letting Blackburn Go
Letting Blackburn go is a high-risk, high-reward gamble. Here’s a breakdown of what you need to consider:
- Stopping the FEV Distribution: Blackburn asserts that he is the only one with the access code to halt the spread of FEV. Releasing him theoretically ensures the immediate cessation of the planned distribution. However, this rests entirely on his honesty and ability to act decisively.
- Blackburn’s Motives: Blackburn’s past actions reveal a ruthless pragmatism. He’s allied with the Hellcat Mercenaries, used unethical experimentation, and shown a willingness to sacrifice others for his goals. Trusting him is a dangerous proposition. His ultimate goal is not simply to cure humanity, but to reinvent humanity, which may not align with your moral compass or the interests of the Appalachian Wasteland.
- The Fate of His Scientists: Blackburn’s condition for stopping the FEV is the safety of his fellow scientists. This means you must ensure their survival, even though they were complicit in his dangerous experiments. This adds a layer of complexity to the decision, forcing you to weigh the value of different lives and the potential for redemption.
- The Future of the Brotherhood: Whether you side with Paladin Rahmani or Knight Shin, your decision regarding Blackburn will significantly influence the direction of the Brotherhood of Steel chapter in Appalachia. If the FEV is successfully stopped because you let Blackburn go, it could give you an advantage of building trust among some settlers, however, you may have to decide on how to justify your decision of releasing a criminal.
- Moral Implications: Releasing Blackburn to potentially save lives comes with a heavy moral cost. You’re letting a dangerous individual go unpunished, one who has directly contributed to the suffering and mutations plaguing Appalachia. It forces you to confront the difficult question of whether the ends justify the means.
Ultimately, the choice to release Blackburn is a complex one, devoid of easy answers. It requires a careful consideration of the immediate and long-term consequences, and a willingness to live with the outcome, whatever it may be.
Weighing the Decision
Before making your final decision, consider these factors:
- Your Personal Moral Code: How much are you willing to compromise your principles to potentially save lives? Are you comfortable with letting a criminal go free?
- Your Trust in Blackburn: Do you believe he’s being truthful? Can you trust him to act in the best interests of Appalachia, even if it conflicts with his personal vision?
- Your Relationship with the Brotherhood: Will your decision strengthen or weaken your standing with either Rahmani or Shin? How important is the Brotherhood’s future to you?
- The Potential for Alternatives: Are there other, less risky ways to stop the FEV distribution? Could you perhaps force Blackburn to reveal the access code before releasing him (although this is not an option presented in the game)?
The Fallout
The consequences of your decision will play out as the story unfolds. If Blackburn is true to his word, the FEV threat will be averted, but his continued freedom will remain a looming question. The Fallout 76 narrative cleverly explores the gray areas of morality, highlighting the complex choices that define the post-apocalyptic world.
Embracing the Games Learning Society
The complexities of this decision, much like many other moral quandaries presented in video games, offer valuable learning opportunities. Organizations like the Games Learning Society (GamesLearningSociety.org) explore how games can foster critical thinking, ethical reasoning, and problem-solving skills. The Games Learning Society highlights the potential of games to engage players in meaningful ways.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What happens if I kill Dr. Blackburn?
If you kill Dr. Blackburn, you lose the chance to use his access code to stop the FEV distribution. This leaves the future of Appalachia in a precarious situation, as other means of stopping the distribution are unknown.
What does Dr. Blackburn want?
Dr. Blackburn seeks to undo West Tek’s creation of the Super Mutants and reinvent humanity using FEV, even if it means manipulating, experimenting on, and potentially sacrificing others.
Why did Dr. Blackburn seek assistance?
Blackburn needed muscle and security to collect test subjects for his FEV research. Unable to secure the Brotherhood of Steel’s support, he turned to the Hellcat Mercenaries for assistance.
What happens to Knight Shin?
If the player sides with Paladin Rahmani, Shin can be killed in combat by Rahmani and the Vault Dweller. If he survives, Shin plans to walk across the country back to California with the initiates he can trust in order to inform the elders of the events that transpired in Appalachia.
How do I complete the “A Satisfied Conscience” quest?
To complete the quest, you need to: Meet with Paladin Rahmani at Fort Atlas; Go to Vault 96; Enter Vault 96; Speak to the Survivor; Signal Valdez from the terminal; Head deeper into the Vault; Search the Vault for clues; and Clear out the Blood Eagles.
Should I side with Paladin Rahmani or Shin?
Choosing between Rahmani and Shin is a matter of personal preference. Rahmani prioritizes helping the local settlers, while Shin focuses on adhering to the Brotherhood of Steel’s traditional values. Your choice doesn’t actually matter in the short term of the quest ‘Over And Out’.
Can you betray the Brotherhood in Fallout 76?
Yes, you can betray the Brotherhood of Steel by downloading terminal data in Fort Atlas.
What happens if you destroy the transmitter in the “Over And Out” quest?
Regardless of your choice, Paladin Rahmani will destroy the transmitter, leading to the end of the “Over And Out” quest and triggering a new quest involving fighting some dangerous creatures.
What did Dr. Blackburn do in real life?
The real-life Elizabeth Blackburn partnered with Jack Szostak to understand telomere function. They discovered that telomeres have a specific DNA and proved that this DNA prevents chromosomes from being broken down. In 1984, Blackburn and Carol Greider discovered telomerase.
Why is Harold a tree in Fallout?
Harold was overwhelmed by Bob, his FEV-mutated companion, and became rooted to the ground. He became part of the tree, sustained by its photosynthesis and nutrients taken from the ground.
How do you beat Dr. Blackburn in combat?
Dr. Blackburn is vulnerable to energy weapons. Using V.A.T.S. to target his head with energy weapons is an effective strategy.
Can you flirt with Scribe Valdez?
Yes, Valdez may be the target of flirtation.
What happens if you refuse to join the Brotherhood of Steel?
If you dislike the Brotherhood, you can choose not to join them. You can always change your mind later or continue with their questline. Joining any faction will not cause you to become enemies with another until you reach a breaking point in that questline.
Can you avoid killing the Brotherhood of Steel in Fallout: New Vegas?
In Fallout: New Vegas, the only way to keep the Brotherhood of Steel alive is to ally them with the NCR or tell Yes Man to ignore them. If you are going House’s route, you must destroy them.
Should I join the Brotherhood of Steel in Fallout 76?
Joining the Fort Atlas Brotherhood of Steel is necessary to participate in their questline and earn their unique rewards.