The Brotherhood of Steel and Far Harbor: A Path of Destruction and Missed Opportunities
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Telling the Brotherhood of Steel about Acadia in the Far Harbor DLC for Fallout 4 leads to a swift and devastating outcome. Upon informing the Brotherhood of the existence of a haven for synths on the island, Knight-Captain Larsen will dispatch a Vertibird filled with heavily armed soldiers to eliminate every last synth residing there. This triggers an attack on Acadia, resulting in the deaths of DiMA and the other synths, effectively wiping out the settlement. Importantly, revealing Acadia to the Brotherhood locks you out of the main questline of Far Harbor, preventing you from experiencing the complex moral choices and potential for a peaceful resolution that the DLC offers. It is a path of violence with significant narrative drawbacks.
The Consequences of Brotherhood Involvement
The Brotherhood of Steel operates on a core philosophy of eliminating synth threats to humanity. Acadia, a hidden refuge for synths seeking autonomy and escape from the Institute, directly contradicts their beliefs. By revealing Acadia’s existence, you are essentially signing their death warrant and foregoing any opportunity to explore the nuanced story and alternative solutions Far Harbor presents.
Choosing this path immediately removes several crucial questlines, including the potential for replacing the High Confessor Tektus and fostering peace between Far Harbor and the Children of Atom. The most rewarding and arguably most satisfying endings are completely inaccessible if you involve the Brotherhood in Acadia’s fate. Instead, you are left with a purely destructive outcome that offers little in terms of rewards or positive impact on the island’s communities.
Moreover, siding with the Brotherhood in this scenario can negatively impact your relationship with other factions like the Railroad, who are dedicated to protecting synths. While the Brotherhood might appreciate your loyalty and award you with ranks and equipment, it comes at the cost of numerous missed opportunities and a potentially less fulfilling overall experience in Far Harbor.
Why It’s Generally Not Recommended
From a gameplay perspective, alerting the Brotherhood to Acadia is generally considered one of the least desirable options. It cuts short the Far Harbor narrative, preventing players from experiencing the full depth and complexity of the DLC. It also means missing out on unique rewards, such as the Acadia’s Shield synth armor, and the chance to shape the future of Far Harbor in a more meaningful and peaceful way.
Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to involve the Brotherhood in Far Harbor is a matter of personal preference and roleplaying style. However, it is crucial to understand the significant consequences of this action and the opportunities it eliminates before committing to this path.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions to provide additional clarity on the complexities of the Far Harbor DLC and the potential consequences of your actions:
1. What happens if you tell Far Harbor about DiMA?
You can convince the people of Far Harbor to only kill DiMA and leave Acadia alone, but only if you first confront DiMA about the murder and then convince him to turn himself in. DiMA will then be executed in Far Harbor for his crime, but you can then convince the Harbormen to leave Acadia alone. This path requires a high degree of persuasion and careful planning.
2. What is the best ending for Far Harbor?
The “best” ending is subjective, but the happiest ending with the most rewards is generally considered the path where you maintain peace between Far Harbor, Acadia, and the Children of Atom. This involves resolving the conflicts between the factions without resorting to violence and requires careful negotiation and manipulation.
3. Will the Brotherhood destroy Acadia regardless of what I do?
No, the Brotherhood will only attack Acadia if you specifically inform them of its existence. You can complete the Far Harbor DLC without ever involving them.
4. What happens if I tell the Brotherhood about Mass Fusion?
Informing the Brotherhood about Mass Fusion starts the quest “Spoils of War,” which ultimately leads to hostility with the Institute. This locks you into the Brotherhood’s ending for the main Fallout 4 storyline.
5. Can you get Final Judgement if you side with the Brotherhood?
Yes, you can get Final Judgement if you side with the Brotherhood of Steel by having a weapon with high disarm chance and hitting him during the Nuclear Option quest.
6. How do you get the peaceful ending in Far Harbor?
The peaceful ending in Far Harbor is achieved by keeping DiMA’s secret and working to replace High Confessor Tektus with a synth, leading the Children of Atom towards a path of peace with Far Harbor. This path requires high charisma or luck.
7. Should I tell the Institute about Acadia?
No, telling the Institute about Acadia will have the same outcome as telling the Brotherhood – Acadia will be destroyed, and you’ll miss the main Far Harbor questline. Both factions view synths outside their control as a threat.
8. Should I tell Avery she’s a synth?
Telling Captain Avery she’s a synth will reveal the truth that her own mind has been altered. She will remain determined to keep the peace on the island and ask you to not tell Allen.
9. Is the Sole Survivor a synth?
No, the Sole Survivor is not a synth. This is confirmed throughout the main storyline and the DLCs.
10. Can Far Harbor forgive DiMA?
Yes, Far Harbor can forgive DiMA, but it requires convincing him to turn himself in and pleading for Acadia’s survival after his execution. This is a difficult path that requires helping the people of Far Harbor.
11. What is the most peaceful ending in Fallout 4 main game?
The most peaceful ending in Fallout 4’s main game is generally considered the Minutemen ending, where the other factions are left intact, except for the Institute.
12. What happens if I side with the Brotherhood in Fallout 4?
Siding with the Brotherhood of Steel will result in the destruction of the Institute and, depending on your choices, may lead to conflict with the Railroad. You will be promoted to the rank of Sentinel and gain access to a jetpack for your power armor.
13. Is the Brotherhood of Steel bad in Fallout 4?
The Brotherhood of Steel cannot be classified completely as good or bad, as they lie somewhere in between. They have both redeeming qualities and flaws, making them a morally complex faction. Their motivations are often driven by their pursuit of technology and power, and they are not always concerned with the well-being of the general population.
14. Who is the synth in Far Harbor?
Far Harbor starts with the search for Kasumi Nakano, but the major synth presence is in Acadia, led by DiMA, a synth who resembles Nick Valentine.
15. Do I need Valentine for Far Harbor?
While not strictly required, bringing Nick Valentine to Far Harbor greatly enhances the experience, as some of the biggest payoffs and quests in the story revolve around him. Nick Valentine is unique character to take with you in Far Harbor because, he himself is a synth.
Understanding the consequences of your choices is critical when navigating the complex world of Fallout 4, especially in the Far Harbor DLC. Consider exploring different avenues and completing different quests until you find a resolution that best aligns with your moral compass. Remember that playing and studying games helps you think critically, analyze complex systems, and solve problems creatively, which are valuable skills in the real world too. Check out the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org to find out more about how games and learning intersect.