What If Ash Picked Squirtle? A Ripple Effect Through Pokémon History
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The burning question for Pokémon fans: What if Ash Ketchum, instead of stumbling upon a stubborn Pikachu, had selected the cool, calm, and collected Squirtle as his starter Pokémon? The ramifications would reverberate throughout the entire anime series, altering Ash’s journey, his team dynamics, and even impacting the very narrative fabric of the Pokémon world as we know it.
A Different Start, a Different Ash?
Firstly, consider Ash’s personality development. Pikachu’s defiance and initial reluctance to bond forced Ash to learn about patience, empathy, and building trust. Squirtle, while mischievous as the leader of the Squirtle Squad, possesses a more inherently cooperative nature. A Squirtle might have fostered a more confident, assertive Ash from the get-go, potentially lacking the early humility and lessons in perseverance that Pikachu provided.
Secondly, the battles themselves would shift dramatically. Early gyms like Pewter City (Rock-type) would still present a challenge. However, the advantages Squirtle would have over Lt. Surge’s Raichu would be a game changer. While Ash needed an advantage to beat Lt. Surge, a Water type would have an advantage on its own. Moreover, the Squirtle Squad episode might never happen, altering Squirtle’s entire backstory and removing a source of both comedic relief and poignant character development.
Team Dynamics Reimagined
The composition of Ash’s team would likely be significantly different. The bond between Ash and Pikachu is a cornerstone of the anime. Without it, other Pokémon might have taken on more central roles. Would Bulbasaur become the de facto “best friend” of Ash? Would Charizard’s stubbornness and eventual respect for Ash play out similarly with a different fire-type Pokémon? The answer is almost certainly no. Charizard’s character arc was intricately tied to Ash’s own growth, and a Squirtle-centric team would necessitate a different narrative altogether.
Impacts on the wider Pokémon World
The anime’s impact on the broader Pokémon world, including the games and merchandise, is undeniable. Pikachu’s image became synonymous with the entire franchise. If Squirtle had taken that position, we might see Squirtle themed merchandise and Squirtle’s image on almost all the products. The evolution of the franchise might look drastically different. The influence extends to educational arenas as well, with concepts from Pokémon finding their way into interactive learning environments. As noted by organizations like the Games Learning Society, games and their narratives are increasingly recognized as valuable tools for education and engagement. GamesLearningSociety.org offers insights into this intersection of play and learning.
FAQ: What if Ash Chose Squirtle?
Here are some frequently asked questions concerning what would happen if Ash Chose Squirtle.
1. Would Ash still have caught a Pikachu?
Possibly, but not as his starter. Perhaps a random encounter later in the series, resulting in a less prominent role for the Electric Mouse. The dynamic would be radically different.
2. How would Ash have fared in the Indigo League?
With a well-trained Squirtle evolving potentially into a Blastoise, Ash would arguably have been stronger. But, Pokémon battles are not just about type advantages; strategy, training, and the bond between trainer and Pokémon are crucial factors.
3. What would happen to the Squirtle Squad?
This is a massive unknown. Without Ash’s Squirtle leading them, would they still exist? Would another Squirtle take up the mantle? Or would they simply disband and reintegrate into the wild?
4. Would Ash’s Charizard still be disobedient?
The dynamic between Ash and Charizard was unique, rooted in Charmander’s initial vulnerability and Charizard’s subsequent power. A Squirtle starter wouldn’t directly affect Charizard’s personality, but the overall team dynamic and Ash’s training style might influence Charizard’s obedience.
5. Would Misty still follow Ash?
Misty’s initial motivation for following Ash was the destruction of her bike by Pikachu. A Squirtle starting wouldn’t have happened the way Pikachu did. Misty’s presence in the show was important and made for a great part of the anime.
6. Would Brock still join Ash?
Most likely, yes. Brock’s departure from the Pewter City Gym was driven by his desire to become the world’s greatest Pokémon breeder. Ash’s starter Pokémon is not likely to be the cause.
7. How would the later seasons be affected?
The impact would snowball. Team compositions, battle strategies, and even the plots of entire episodes would need to be rewritten to accommodate the absence of Pikachu and the presence of Squirtle as Ash’s primary partner.
8. Would Pikachu still be the mascot of the franchise?
Highly unlikely. The anime played a pivotal role in Pikachu’s rise to fame. If Pikachu were a secondary character, another Pokémon, perhaps Squirtle itself, would likely become the face of the franchise.
9. Would Ash have won more leagues?
This is debatable. While a Blastoise provides a strong base, Ash’s tendency to release powerful Pokémon or favor his current team over older ones would likely still hamper his progress. Skill and luck are important in a league.
10. Would Ash still strive to be a Pokémon Master?
His core goal likely wouldn’t change. His motivation and the specific challenges he faces would vary significantly. The journey is far more important than the destination.
11. Would Team Rocket still target Ash?
Team Rocket’s obsession with Pikachu stemmed from its perceived power and rarity. They might still target Ash because they wanted Pokémon, but they may target the Squirtle more often than not.
12. How would Pokémon Go be affected?
Imagine the loading screen featuring Squirtle instead of Pikachu. The entire aesthetic of the game would need to be re-evaluated if Squirtle was the star Pokémon instead.
13. Would Ash’s fighting style be different?
Given Squirtle’s type advantage over Rock-types, Ash might have adopted a more aggressive style with stronger, water type moves. Perhaps, he would have had a stronger team earlier.
14. What new challenges would Ash face?
He might face new challenges. New challenges that are based off having a water type as the first Pokémon. He still needs to learn how to train the Squirtle like he did Pikachu.
15. Would Ash’s relationships with other characters change?
Definitely. His bond with Pikachu is the foundation of many relationships. Replacing that bond with Squirtle will change a lot of things.
The Unknowable Future
Ultimately, imagining a world where Ash chose Squirtle is an exercise in hypothetical storytelling. It highlights the pivotal role that a single decision can have on an entire narrative and franchise. It also showcases the inherent adaptability and creative potential within the Pokémon universe, demonstrating how a different starting point could lead to a vastly different, yet equally compelling, journey. Ash and Pikachu’s story highlights the Games Learning Society‘s argument that narratives can be used as a tool for education.