What is a Good Commander Ratio in Magic: The Gathering?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
A “good” Commander ratio in Magic: The Gathering isn’t a rigid formula but rather a flexible guideline, adapting to your specific deck’s strategy and needs. However, a solid starting point revolves around a balance of mana sources (lands and mana rocks), creatures, and other spells. For most decks, aiming for roughly 33 to 40 lands, 10 to 15 mana rocks, and a mix of creatures and spells to fill out the remaining slots is a great place to start. It’s vital to consider your deck’s mana curve and the specific demands of your chosen commander when making final decisions.
Understanding the Core Components of a Commander Deck
Before diving into specific numbers, let’s break down the key elements that make up a successful Commander deck:
Lands: The Foundation of Your Mana Base
Lands are the bedrock of any Magic deck, providing the necessary resources to cast spells. In Commander, with its larger deck size and slower pace, hitting your land drops consistently is crucial for success. Most guidance suggests a minimum of 33 lands, with many opting for 37-40. The exact number depends on how mana-hungry your strategy is and the type of ramp you employ. For decks with a lower curve, leaning towards 33-36 might suffice. However, decks focused on high-cost spells or those relying on land synergies will need more, potentially 40 or even 42.
Mana Rocks: Accelerating Your Game
Mana rocks, such as Sol Ring, Arcane Signet, and Talismans, provide additional sources of mana and can significantly accelerate your game plan. A good benchmark is between 10 to 15 mana rocks, varying by commander and deck needs. For instance, a commander with a low casting cost might require less ramp compared to a six-mana commander. Lower-cost artifact ramp also helps with color-fixing and can be beneficial in a multicolor strategy.
Creatures: The Power on the Board
Creatures provide board presence, generate card advantage, or deliver crucial utility. The ideal number varies drastically based on your deck’s strategy. Aggressive, creature-heavy decks will naturally run a higher number of creatures, around 30-40, while control-oriented strategies or combo decks may function well with 15-25, or even fewer. Consider the types of creatures you want: some will be more about offense, while others will provide important value or disruption.
Other Spells: The Versatility of Magic
The rest of your deck will comprise instants, sorceries, enchantments, and planeswalkers. These spells provide card draw, removal, board wipes, interaction, and other effects. Finding a good balance for spells is essential. An equal split is not always necessary; it is often better to lean into the effects that match the commander’s gameplan. The aim here is to fill gaps that your creature base cannot easily cover and provide interaction with the table.
Adapting Ratios to Your Strategy
While the above guidelines provide a solid starting point, remember that Commander is a diverse format, and your deck ratio should reflect your chosen strategy. Here are a few examples:
- Aggro Decks: Prioritize creatures and low-cost spells that enable early aggression, while having a respectable 35+ lands. Consider keeping a low to mid range curve, as the speed matters.
- Control Decks: Lean into instants, sorceries, and board wipes to control the flow of the game. They often have fewer creatures but need plenty of interaction. Lands can be between 36-40.
- Combo Decks: Focus on finding and assembling specific card combinations, typically including card draw and tutors, while a land count between 35 and 38 should be adequate.
- Midrange Decks: Aim for a balanced composition, with a mix of creatures, removal, and card draw. 37-40 lands will be ideal, with a curve spread evenly.
- Land-Based Decks: These decks capitalize on landfall triggers and land synergies and may need upwards of 40+ lands to support their strategy.
The Importance of the Mana Curve
Your mana curve is the distribution of your deck based on the converted mana cost of each card. Having a well-balanced curve is vital for hitting your land drops consistently and avoiding being stuck with high-cost spells in your hand with no available mana. A good mana curve should typically feature more lower-cost cards and fewer higher-cost ones, as it allows you to play spells from the beginning. Keep in mind that mana rocks will help in playing more higher-cost spells than you would normally.
The 75% Rule
The 75% rule is an important concept in Commander deck building. It suggests that you build a deck with optimization in mind but intentionally avoid pushing it to its absolute limit. This aims to provide a balanced and fun experience for everyone at the table, where the decks aren’t too powerful and still allow for interesting interaction.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 15 frequently asked questions to further clarify the topic of ratios in Commander:
1. What is the ideal land number in Commander?
The typical land count ranges from 33 to 40, depending on your deck’s mana curve, ramp, and color needs. Landfall decks often go beyond 40, while lower curve decks can run closer to 33.
2. How many mana sources should a Commander deck have?
Aim for 43 to 55 total mana sources, including lands, mana rocks, and creatures that produce mana. This typically translates to 33 to 40 lands, and 10 to 15 mana rocks.
3. How many creatures is ideal in a Commander deck?
Creature counts vary significantly depending on the strategy; 24 creatures are an average, but some decks may run less, and others much more. Control decks could lean towards 15-25, while aggro decks might use 30-40.
4. Is 34 lands enough in a Commander deck?
For most decks, 34 lands are on the lower end, and it may lead to inconsistencies. It might work for a very low-curve deck, but 37 to 40 is a safer starting point.
5. What is the best land ratio in Commander?
A solid ratio usually places lands between 33% to 40% of your deck, so again, 33 to 40 lands in a 100-card deck.
6. How many mana rocks should I run in Commander?
Generally, 10 to 15 mana rocks are a good target. The exact amount depends on your commander’s mana cost and your deck’s need for ramp. Some decks will run less, some will lean much harder into it.
7. What should my mana curve look like?
Your mana curve should ideally have a higher proportion of low-cost cards (1-3 mana) and fewer higher-cost cards (5+ mana) with a smooth transition in between. Ensure there is mana ramp to help with playing higher cost cards.
8. How many lands should be in a 60-card deck?
A standard 60-card deck typically runs 24 lands, but this can adjust based on the deck’s mana curve and specific requirements.
9. What percentage of an MTG deck should be land?
Lands typically make up a touch over 40% of a deck.
10. How many mana cards should you have in a deck?
A little more than 1/3 of your deck should be mana, usually about 24 mana cards in a 60 card deck.
11. How many lands can you play per turn?
A player may only play one land per turn during their main phase.
12. Is 37 lands enough for Commander?
Yes, 37 lands is a good starting point for medium-power midrange Commander decks. However, adjust this number depending on your specific strategy and mana needs.
13. How many creatures should you have in a 60-card deck?
For a balanced deck, 20 to 22 creatures are a good starting point for a 60-card deck.
14. What is Rule 0 in Commander?
Rule 0 is an unofficial rule that encourages players to agree on changes to the rules before a game, ensuring a more enjoyable experience for everyone involved.
15. What is the 75% rule in MTG?
The 75% rule is about building optimized decks that are not quite at their full potential, ensuring games are balanced and fun for everyone.
By understanding these ratios and adapting them to your specific needs and strategy, you can build a powerful and consistent Commander deck that will lead you to victory! Remember that flexibility is key, and experimentation is part of the fun.