What is the Advantage Roll in D&D?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
In Dungeons & Dragons (D&D), an advantage roll is a mechanic that allows a player to roll a d20 twice and take the higher of the two results. It’s essentially a boon, granting a greater chance of success on a d20 test, such as an attack roll, saving throw, or ability check. When you have advantage, the odds are stacked in your favor!
Diving Deeper: Understanding Advantage
Advantage represents a circumstance that gives you a beneficial edge in a particular situation. This might be due to tactical positioning, a helpful spell effect, a creature being distracted, or simply a stroke of luck. Unlike a simple bonus to your roll, advantage significantly alters the probability distribution, making higher results far more likely. It is designed to be a powerful, yet simplified, mechanic that helps the game flow more smoothly.
When Do You Get Advantage?
The Dungeon Master (DM) decides when and how players gain advantage, based on the narrative and the rules. Here are some common sources:
- Flanking: In some campaigns, strategically positioning allies can grant advantage on attack rolls.
- Spells and Abilities: Certain spells and class abilities, like the Help action or the Bless spell, directly grant advantage.
- Conditions: Being hidden, invisible, or having an enemy be blinded, paralyzed, or incapacitated can provide advantage.
- DM Discretion: The DM can award advantage for creative solutions, clever roleplaying, or when the situation logically favors the player.
Advantage vs. Bonuses
It is crucial to understand the difference between advantage and a simple bonus. A bonus is a numerical addition to your d20 roll. Advantage, however, involves rolling twice and picking the higher result. While both increase your chances of success, advantage has a more pronounced effect, especially on rolls that require high numbers. Unlike bonuses, you do not stack multiple advantages together.
Disadvantage: The Flip Side
Disadvantage is the opposite of advantage. When you have disadvantage, you roll a d20 twice and take the lower of the two results. It represents circumstances that hinder your efforts, making success more difficult. The sources of disadvantage are similar to those of advantage:
- Conditions: Being poisoned, frightened, or restrained can impose disadvantage.
- Spells and Abilities: Certain spells and abilities inflict disadvantage on targets.
- DM Discretion: The DM can impose disadvantage when circumstances make a task particularly challenging.
Advantage and Disadvantage: Interaction
The rules for advantage and disadvantage are straightforward:
- If you have both advantage and disadvantage on the same roll, they cancel each other out. You roll only one d20.
- Multiple instances of advantage don’t stack. You only roll two dice, even if you have multiple sources of advantage. The same rule applies to disadvantage.
This “supervening” rule is important to prevent advantage or disadvantage from becoming overwhelming. It promotes a simple, easily manageable system.
Advantage: A Simple, Yet Powerful Mechanic
Advantage is a cornerstone of D&D 5th edition’s design philosophy. It’s designed to be simple to understand and implement, yet it has a significant impact on gameplay. By rolling twice and taking the best (or worst) result, advantage and disadvantage create dynamic shifts in probability, reflecting the ebb and flow of combat and exploration.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Advantage in D&D
1. Can I stack multiple sources of advantage?
No. Even if you have multiple factors granting you advantage, you still only roll two dice and take the higher result. The same applies to disadvantage; multiple sources don’t stack.
2. What happens if I have both advantage and disadvantage?
They cancel each other out. You roll a single d20 as normal. It doesn’t matter how many sources of each you have; one of each will negate the other.
3. Does advantage apply to damage rolls?
No, advantage only applies to the d20 roll for attack rolls, saving throws, and ability checks. It does not affect damage rolls. Some abilities might grant increased damage, but this is separate from advantage.
4. If I have advantage on an attack roll, do I get advantage on the damage roll too?
No, advantage only applies to the attack roll itself. The damage roll is a separate event and is not affected by advantage (unless a specific feature explicitly states otherwise).
5. How does advantage interact with critical hits?
When you have advantage and score a critical hit, you still roll double the dice for damage. The advantage only helped you land the critical hit in the first place.
6. Can the DM give advantage to monsters?
Yes, the DM can give advantage to monsters under the same circumstances as they would for player characters.
7. What is the Help action and how does it grant advantage?
The Help action is a standard action a character can take in combat. It allows one character to assist another character with a task, granting them advantage on their next ability check or attack roll against a specific target, provided the assisting character is within 5 feet of the target or the task at hand.
8. Is it worth strategically trying to get advantage in combat?
Absolutely! Advantage significantly increases your chances of hitting an enemy. Positioning, using helpful spells or abilities, and exploiting enemy weaknesses are all valuable tactics.
9. Can I use a Bard’s Bardic Inspiration die and also have advantage?
Yes! Bardic Inspiration is a bonus added to your roll after you roll the die. Having advantage and using Bardic Inspiration are completely separate mechanics and can be used together.
10. What’s the mathematical probability of hitting with advantage compared to without?
The exact probability depends on the Armor Class (AC) you are trying to hit. However, advantage significantly increases your chances. For example, if you normally have a 50% chance to hit, advantage can increase that to around 75%. The higher the AC, the greater the benefit of advantage.
11. Does advantage stack with bonuses to the roll, like from weapons or abilities?
Yes, advantage is separate from bonuses. You roll two dice, take the higher result, and then add any relevant bonuses (e.g., Strength modifier, proficiency bonus, weapon bonus) to the final result.
12. Can disadvantage ever be worse than just a straight roll (without advantage or disadvantage)?
Yes, disadvantage inherently makes it more likely to roll lower numbers. If you need a very high number to succeed, the chance of rolling that high number even once is less probable when you have disadvantage.
13. How does advantage work with abilities that let you reroll dice?
Typically, the reroll happens after you’ve already determined which of the two d20s you’re using (the higher one if you had advantage). You reroll the chosen die. Some abilities, however, might specify different timing.
14. Can a player always declare they want to try to gain advantage?
Not necessarily. The opportunity to gain advantage depends on the circumstances of the situation and the DM’s judgment. Players can suggest creative solutions, but the DM ultimately decides whether those solutions warrant advantage.
15. What are some creative ways players can try to gain advantage?
Players can try many things! Describing clever maneuvers in combat, using their environment to their benefit (e.g., pushing a creature prone), exploiting a monster’s weaknesses, using the Help action, or even just vividly describing their actions in a way that impresses the DM can potentially earn them advantage. Ultimately, creativity and good roleplaying are key.