Decoding the Commander’s Codex: What’s the Average Makeup of a Magic: The Gathering Deck?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
So, you’re diving into the world of Commander (also known as EDH, short for Elder Dragon Highlander), and you’re wondering what goes into the average deck? Great question! Commander is a unique and popular Magic: The Gathering format known for its social gameplay, powerful plays, and deck-building freedom. On average, a Commander deck consists of 33-42 lands, roughly 10-15 mana ramp spells/artifacts, around 5-7 removal spells (including board wipes and targeted removal), approximately 6-10 cards for card draw, and the rest of the deck is filled out with creatures, synergistic pieces, and strategies tailored to your chosen Commander. This is just a starting point, though, as Commander deck construction is far from a rigid science and offers near limitless deck-building options!
Deconstructing the Commander Deck: Essential Components
While the beauty of Commander lies in its flexibility, there are some general guidelines and common elements that contribute to a successful and fun deck. Let’s break down the key components:
- Land Base (33-42): The bedrock of any Commander deck is its land base. The exact number depends on your deck’s mana curve (the distribution of card costs) and the amount of mana ramp you include. If your deck is packed with low-cost spells and mana-producing artifacts or creatures, you can lean towards the lower end of the spectrum. Decks heavily reliant on land-based strategies or higher mana costs may benefit from a larger land base. Prioritize lands that produce multiple colors of mana or have useful abilities.
- Mana Ramp (10-15): Mana ramp refers to cards that allow you to accelerate your mana production, casting more powerful spells earlier in the game. This includes mana rocks (artifacts like Sol Ring, Arcane Signet, or Commander’s Sphere), mana dorks (creatures like Llanowar Elves or Birds of Paradise), and land-fetching spells (like Cultivate or Rampant Growth). Adjust the amount of ramp based on your Commander’s cost and the overall mana curve of your deck.
- Removal (5-7): In a multiplayer format like Commander, dealing with your opponents’ threats is crucial. Removal spells come in two main varieties: targeted removal (cards that destroy or exile specific creatures or artifacts) and board wipes (cards that destroy all creatures or artifacts on the battlefield). A healthy balance of both is essential to handle a variety of situations. Common examples include Swords to Plowshares, Beast Within, and Wrath of God.
- Card Draw (6-10): Running out of cards in hand is a death sentence in Commander. Consistent card draw ensures you always have options and can keep pace with your opponents. Include a mix of repeatable card draw engines (like Rhystic Study or Mystic Remora) and burst card draw spells (like Blue Sun’s Zenith or Harmonize).
- Synergy and Theme: This is where your deck’s personality shines. The remaining slots should be filled with cards that synergize with your Commander’s abilities or support your overall strategy. If you’re building a tribal deck, include creatures of that type and cards that benefit them. If your Commander focuses on a specific mechanic, like graveyard recursion or token generation, include cards that enhance those abilities.
Beyond the Numbers: The Art of Commander Deckbuilding
While these numbers provide a solid framework, remember that Commander deck building is more art than science. Consider the following factors:
- Your Playstyle: Are you an aggressive player who likes to pressure opponents early? Or do you prefer a more controlling strategy, slowly building your advantage over time? Your playstyle will influence your card choices.
- Your Commander: Your Commander is the heart and soul of your deck. Choose a Commander that resonates with you and build your deck around their strengths.
- Your Budget: Commander can be an expensive format, but it doesn’t have to be. There are plenty of powerful and effective cards available at budget-friendly prices.
- Your Playgroup: The power level of your deck should be appropriate for your playgroup. Talk to your friends about their expectations and adjust your deck accordingly.
Ultimately, the best way to learn is by doing. Experiment with different card combinations, test your deck against different opponents, and refine your list based on your experiences.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Commander Deckbuilding
What is the ideal number of lands in a Commander deck?
There isn’t a single “ideal” number, but 33-42 lands is a good starting point. Adjust based on your mana curve and the amount of mana ramp in your deck. Decks with low mana curves and plenty of ramp can often get away with fewer lands, while decks with high mana curves and less ramp will need more.
How much mana ramp should I include in my Commander deck?
Aim for 10-15 pieces of mana ramp. This includes mana rocks, mana dorks, and land-fetching spells. The more expensive your Commander and your deck’s key spells are, the more ramp you’ll need.
How many creatures should be in a Commander deck?
This depends heavily on your strategy. Some decks, like tribal decks, might run upwards of 40 creatures. Other decks, like control decks, might run fewer than 20. Consider how important creatures are to your overall game plan.
What are the most important types of removal to include in a Commander deck?
You’ll want a mix of targeted removal (for dealing with specific threats) and board wipes (for resetting the board when things get out of control). Targeted removal should be versatile enough to handle a variety of threats, while board wipes should be able to clear the board without hindering your own strategy too much.
How much card draw is necessary in a Commander deck?
Aim for 6-10 sources of card draw. Include a mix of repeatable card draw engines and burst card draw spells. Card draw is crucial for maintaining card advantage and ensuring you always have options.
Is it okay to play a Commander deck with only one color?
Yes! Mono-colored Commander decks can be very powerful and focused. They often have access to unique synergies and strong utility lands.
What’s the difference between mana rocks and mana dorks?
Mana rocks are artifacts that produce mana, while mana dorks are creatures that produce mana. Mana rocks are generally more resilient to creature removal, while mana dorks can be more synergistic with creature-based strategies.
How do I choose a Commander that’s right for me?
Consider your playstyle, your favorite colors, and the types of strategies you enjoy. Read about different Commanders and see if any of them spark your interest. You can also visit GamesLearningSociety.org to learn more about effective collaboration and learning strategies that can help you master deck-building.
What’s a “mana curve” and why is it important?
The mana curve is the distribution of card costs in your deck. A well-balanced mana curve ensures that you have spells to cast at every stage of the game. Avoid having too many expensive spells and not enough cheap spells, or vice versa.
What are some good budget-friendly Commander staples?
Some excellent and affordable Commander staples include Sol Ring, Arcane Signet, Cultivate, Rampant Growth, Swords to Plowshares, and Beast Within. Many common dual lands are also affordable and can improve your mana base.
How important is it to have a strong mana base in Commander?
A strong mana base is crucial for consistency. Invest in lands that produce multiple colors of mana, especially if you’re playing a multi-colored deck. Fetch lands, shock lands, and check lands are all excellent choices, but even basic dual lands can make a big difference.
Should I include tutors in my Commander deck?
Tutors (cards that allow you to search your library for a specific card) can be very powerful in Commander, but they can also make your deck more predictable. Consider whether you want your deck to be more consistent or more unpredictable.
What’s the difference between a “good” Commander deck and a “powerful” Commander deck?
A “good” Commander deck is well-built, consistent, and fun to play. A “powerful” Commander deck is designed to win quickly and efficiently, often at the expense of fun and interaction. The best type of deck depends on your playgroup and your personal preferences.
How do I balance the power level of my Commander deck?
Talk to your playgroup about their expectations and adjust your deck accordingly. Avoid including cards that are excessively powerful or unfun to play against. Focus on creating a balanced and interactive play experience.
Where can I find more resources for Commander deck building?
There are many websites and online communities dedicated to Commander deck building. Some popular resources include EDHREC, MTGGoldfish, and TappedOut. You can also find helpful articles and videos on YouTube and other online platforms.