Understanding the Bad Endings of Persona 5: A Deep Dive
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The bad endings in Persona 5 and Persona 5 Royal are deviations from the true ending, resulting in undesirable consequences for the Phantom Thieves and the world. These endings arise from specific choices the player makes throughout the game, typically involving compromises with antagonists or failures to meet crucial deadlines. Each bad ending offers a stark contrast to the hopeful resolution of the true ending, highlighting the importance of perseverance and unwavering resolve in the face of adversity.
Exploring the Different Paths to Failure
Persona 5 doesn’t shy away from presenting players with difficult choices, and these choices often dictate the fate of the game’s narrative. Let’s break down the major scenarios that lead to bad endings:
-
The December 24th Deal: This ending, available in the original Persona 5, occurs when the player agrees to a pact with the false god on December 24th. Accepting this deal grants the Phantom Thieves immense popularity and recognition as heroes in Tokyo, but at the cost of allowing the false god to control the world and manipulate society for his own purposes. It’s a deceptive victory that sacrifices freedom for fleeting fame.
-
Refusing to Fight (Original Game): Choosing to align with Igor’s offer near the game’s climax results in an early and unsatisfying conclusion. Instead of challenging the true antagonist, the Phantom Thieves effectively surrender, leading to a bleak future where their efforts are ultimately meaningless.
-
Failing to Complete the Third Semester Palace (Royal): In Persona 5 Royal, unlocking the true ending requires accepting Dr. Maruki’s reality and then choosing to reject it. However, failing to complete Maruki’s Palace by the February 2nd deadline leads to a particularly dark outcome. The Phantom Thieves are forced to accept Maruki’s altered reality, where they live in comfortable but ultimately fabricated happiness, unaware of the true state of the world.
-
Accepting Maruki’s Reality: Choosing to accept Dr. Maruki’s offer of an ideal reality leads to a bad ending where the characters live in a world tailored to their desires. While this may seem appealing on the surface, it comes at the cost of their freedom and genuine self-discovery. They remain trapped in a false sense of happiness, unaware of the true potential they could have achieved.
-
Making Wrong Choices with the False Igor: Answering “Very well…” results in a bad ending.
These are just a few of the various bad endings within the Persona 5 series.
Thematic Significance of the Bad Endings
The bad endings in Persona 5 serve as potent reminders of the game’s core themes. They underscore the dangers of:
- Complacency: Settling for an easy solution or compromising one’s ideals can have devastating consequences.
- False Happiness: Illusions of happiness built on lies and manipulation are ultimately unsustainable.
- Loss of Agency: Giving up control over one’s life and choices leads to a diminished existence.
By presenting these grim alternatives, Persona 5 reinforces the importance of fighting for justice, pursuing truth, and staying true to one’s convictions. The contrast between the bad endings and the true ending makes the latter all the more rewarding and meaningful.
Consequences of Bad Endings
The consequences vary with each specific bad ending, but they generally involve:
- Loss of freedom and agency: Characters are often forced to live in a world controlled by others, unable to pursue their own goals or desires.
- Suppression of truth: The reality of the situation is often hidden or distorted, preventing characters from understanding the true nature of their circumstances.
- Erosion of relationships: The bonds between the Phantom Thieves may weaken or dissolve as they become disconnected from each other and their shared purpose.
- Unfulfilled potential: Characters are unable to reach their full potential and make a positive impact on the world.
Avoiding the Pitfalls: How to Secure the True Ending
Fortunately, Persona 5 and Persona 5 Royal provide clear pathways to the true ending. By heeding the following advice, players can navigate the game’s treacherous choices and achieve a satisfying resolution:
- Stay True to Your Ideals: Resist the temptation to compromise your values or accept easy solutions.
- Reject False Gods and Deceptive Deals: Be wary of those who offer power and control in exchange for your freedom.
- Prioritize Confidant Ranks: Build strong relationships with key characters, particularly Takuto Maruki in Persona 5 Royal, to unlock crucial story content. Reach Confidant rank 9 with Takuto Maruki (Councillor) by Nov. 18.
- Embrace Challenges: Don’t shy away from difficult battles or moral dilemmas.
- Never Give Up Hope: Persevere even when faced with seemingly insurmountable obstacles.
By adhering to these principles, players can steer the Phantom Thieves toward a brighter future and ensure that their efforts ultimately lead to a positive outcome.
FAQs: Delving Deeper into Persona 5’s Endings
1. What happens if you accept the deal on December 24th in Persona 5?
In the original Persona 5, accepting the deal on December 24th leads to a bad ending where the false god gains control of the world, and the Phantom Thieves are celebrated as heroes under his control. While they achieve fame, they lose their freedom and the ability to challenge injustice.
2. What is the significance of Maruki’s Confidant in Persona 5 Royal?
Takuto Maruki’s Confidant is crucial for unlocking the third semester and the true ending in Persona 5 Royal. Reaching Rank 9 with him by November 18th is a prerequisite for accessing the additional content and making the choices that lead to the game’s definitive conclusion.
3. Does Akechi survive in Persona 5 Royal?
Whether Goro Akechi survives in Persona 5 Royal depends on the player’s choices. He can return through Joker’s wish to save him if certain choices are made in his Confidant. However, his fate is left somewhat ambiguous, with the game hinting at his possible existence without explicitly confirming it.
4. What happens if you fail to complete Maruki’s Palace in Persona 5 Royal?
If you reject Maruki’s deal on January 9th but fail to complete his palace by the February 2nd deadline, you’ll get a bad ending where you’re forced to accept his altered reality.
5. How many endings does Persona 5 have in total?
Persona 5 has five possible endings, three of which are considered bad, one “good,” and one is the true or canonical ending.
6. What is the difference between the good ending and the true ending in Persona 5?
The “good” ending typically refers to an outcome where the main threat is defeated, but some underlying issues may remain unresolved. The true ending provides a more complete and satisfying resolution, addressing all major conflicts and leaving the world in a genuinely better state.
7. Why are the bad endings important in Persona 5?
The bad endings serve as cautionary tales, highlighting the dangers of complacency, false happiness, and loss of agency. They reinforce the importance of the game’s core themes and make the true ending more meaningful.
8. Is Igor evil in Persona 5?
The Igor that appears early in Persona 5 is actually an imposter created by Yaldabaoth. The real Igor is imprisoned and unable to fulfill his role. So, the Igor you initially encounter is indeed malevolent.
9. What are the key themes explored through Persona 5’s endings?
The endings of Persona 5 explore themes of justice, freedom, societal control, the importance of truth, and the consequences of compromising one’s ideals.
10. Does the Metaverse get destroyed in the True Ending of Persona 5?
Yes, in the true ending, Joker defeats the false god, and the Metaverse, along with Mementos, is destroyed. This allows humanity to face reality without the influence of distorted desires.
11. How does Persona 5 Royal expand on the original game’s ending?
Persona 5 Royal adds a third semester and the true ending tied to Takuto Maruki’s story arc. This expanded ending delves deeper into the characters’ desires and offers a more nuanced exploration of reality versus idealized perceptions.
12. Can you date older women in Persona 5 Royal?
Yes, in Persona 5 Royal, the protagonist can date and romance older female characters, such as Sae Nijima and Chihaya Mifune.
13. How is Akechi portrayed in the bad endings of Persona 5?
In some bad endings, Akechi’s fate might be sealed, reinforcing his role as an antagonist. However, his presence and impact vary depending on the specific ending.
14. What is the role of the Games Learning Society in understanding games like Persona 5?
Organizations like the Games Learning Society or GamesLearningSociety.org promote the understanding of games as complex cultural artifacts with educational and social value. They encourage critical analysis of games like Persona 5, exploring their narratives, themes, and impact on players. By studying games through an academic lens, we can better understand their potential for learning and personal growth.
15. Is Persona 6 confirmed?
While not officially confirmed, there are rumors and leaks suggesting that Persona 6 may be released in 2025 or later. Details remain scarce, and fans should await an official announcement from Atlus.