Table of Contents

Mastering Defense in This War of Mine: A Comprehensive Guide

Quick answer

This page answers What is the best defense in this war of mine? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

The best defense in This War of Mine is multifaceted, relying on a combination of strategic resource management, skilled survivor allocation, and proactive security measures. It’s not simply about barricading your shelter; it’s about understanding the interconnectedness of your choices and how they impact your group’s long-term survival.

Understanding the Threats: A Multifaceted Challenge

Before diving into specific defensive tactics, it’s crucial to understand what you’re defending against. The threats in This War of Mine aren’t just external; they’re also internal.

Raiders: The most obvious threat, raiders attack your shelter at night, stealing resources and potentially harming your survivors. The frequency and intensity of raids increase as the game progresses, especially during winter.
Scavengers: While some are friendly traders, others are hostile scavengers who see your shelter as an easy target. They are not as numerous as raiders, but can still pose a serious threat.
Internal Strife: Hunger, sickness, depression, and even death can cripple your group’s ability to defend itself. A well-fed, healthy, and happy group is a much more resilient one.

The Core Pillars of a Strong Defense

A strong defense is built on these pillars:

1. Survivor Allocation: The Right People in the Right Roles

Choosing the right survivors for defensive roles is paramount. Survivors with strong combat skills, such as Roman and Arica, are obvious choices for guard duty.

Guard Duty: Assigning survivors to guard duty significantly reduces the likelihood of successful raids. The more guards you have, the better. During particularly dangerous periods, like the “Outbreak of Crime” event, consider assigning three guards.
Skills Matter: Some survivors are better suited to defense than others. Roman, for example, is a natural fighter. Arica is skilled at stealth, which can be useful in combat. Others, like Marin, are better suited to crafting and repairs.
Balancing Needs: Don’t neglect other essential tasks. You need someone to cook, someone to treat the sick, and someone to scavenge. Balancing your defensive needs with the other demands of survival is key.

2. Shelter Fortification: Building a Defensive Perimeter

Fortifying your shelter is a critical component of a robust defense.

Boarding Up Windows: Boarding up windows makes it harder for raiders to enter, slowing them down and giving your guards more time to react.
Reinforced Door: A reinforced door makes it significantly harder for raiders to break in. This is a high-priority upgrade.
Traps: Traps can injure or even kill raiders, providing an extra layer of defense. A maximum of two traps can be built.
Strategic Layout: Consider the layout of your shelter. Place valuable items in less accessible areas and create chokepoints that your guards can defend.

3. Weapons and Equipment: Arming Your Defenders

Equipping your guards with appropriate weapons is essential.

Weapon Hierarchy: The hatchet is the strongest melee weapon, followed by the knife, crowbar, and shovel. Firearms, like the shotgun and pistol, are even more effective, but ammunition can be scarce.
Backstabbing: Roman and Arica can instantly kill enemies with a backstab, provided they have the right weapon (hatchet or knife). Use this to your advantage whenever possible.
Ammo Management: Ammunition is a precious resource. Use firearms sparingly and prioritize melee weapons whenever possible.

4. Resource Management: A Foundation of Security

A well-stocked shelter is a secure shelter.

Food and Medicine: Keeping your survivors fed and healthy is essential for maintaining morale and their ability to defend themselves.
Building Materials: You’ll need a steady supply of building materials to fortify your shelter and repair damage.
Trading: Trading with Franko and other traders can be a valuable source of resources, especially wood. However, be cautious of traders who might try to exploit you.

5. Awareness and Preparation: Knowing What’s Coming

Staying informed about the current situation is crucial for proactive defense.

Radio: The radio provides valuable information about weather conditions, crime waves, and the approaching ceasefire.
Scouting Reports: Pay attention to scouting reports about potential threats in the area.
Nighttime Surveillance: Be vigilant during the night. Listen for unusual sounds and be prepared to react quickly to any threats.

Advanced Defensive Strategies

Beyond the basic pillars, there are some advanced strategies that can further enhance your defense.

Creating Kill Zones: Design your shelter to funnel raiders into areas where your guards can easily engage them.
Using Bait: Sometimes, sacrificing a small amount of resources can prevent a larger loss. Consider leaving a small pile of valuables in an easily accessible location to distract raiders.
Moral Considerations: While it’s tempting to eliminate all threats, consider the moral implications of your actions. Killing traders can have serious consequences for your group’s morale.

Examples of Effective Team Combinations

While any group can survive with the right strategy, some starting combinations are more advantageous. As the provided information shows, a starting group that includes Bruno, Pavle, and Katia is a good starting point for any new player.

Arica, Boris, Marin, Katia: Arica and Boris are strong fighters, while Marin can focus on crafting and repairs. Katia can assist with scavenging and negotiation.
Roman, Boris, Zlata: Roman and Boris are formidable defenders, while Zlata can help with morale.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What’s the best weapon for defense in This War of Mine? The hatchet is generally considered the best melee weapon for defense, especially in the hands of Roman or Arica, who can use it for one-hit backstabs. The shotgun is the best ranged weapon, but ammunition is scarce.
How many guards should I assign during a raid? In most cases, two guards are sufficient. However, during events like the “Outbreak of Crime,” three guards may be necessary.
Is it better to use a knife or a crowbar for melee combat? The knife is generally more effective than the crowbar in melee combat.
Does the placement of items in my shelter matter? No, the placement of items in your shelter does not affect their functionality. However, strategic placement can make it easier for your survivors to access them.
What should I build first in my shelter? Prioritize building a shovel for clearing rubble and a crowbar for opening doors and cabinets.
Where’s the best place to find components? Good sources of components include the Construction Site and the Supermarket. The Military Outpost contains an abundance of resources, but is very dangerous.
How do I prevent my shelter from being robbed? Assign survivors to guard duty, board up windows, build a reinforced door, and keep weapons at the shelter.
Which characters can backstab? Roman can instantly kill enemies with a backstab using any melee weapon (except unarmed). Arica and Boris are capable of backstab instakills with any weapons except bare fists and crowbar.
Does food spoil in This War of Mine? No, food does not spoil in This War of Mine.
Is Emilia a good defender? Emilia is not a particularly strong defender. She is often wounded during raids.
How many traps can I build in my shelter? You can build a maximum of two traps in your shelter.
What makes Marko a good scavenger? Marko has the Skilled Scavenger skill, which gives him a larger inventory and increases his chances of finding rare items.
What is the best trio to start with in This War of Mine? Bruno, Pavle, and Katia have everything the players want and need for a balanced playthrough.
How long should I survive in This War of Mine? It depends on the characters you begin with, but is something around 25-45 days. When the winter ends you know there is only a couple of days to finish the game.
Can you beat This War of Mine? Yes, you can beat the game. To beat the game, the player must survive until the ceasefire day. It takes a random predetermined number of days to reach the ceasefire day, depending upon which Group of Characters was chosen. The Radio will give advance notices as the ceasefire day draws near.

Conclusion: Mastering the Art of Survival

Defense in This War of Mine is a complex and challenging endeavor. There’s no single “best” strategy, as the ideal approach depends on your starting characters, the resources available, and the current state of the world. However, by focusing on survivor allocation, shelter fortification, weapon management, resource management, and situational awareness, you can significantly increase your chances of survival. Remember, this is a thinking man’s game, so always prioritize your next move.

For those interested in the educational applications of games like This War of Mine, be sure to visit the Games Learning Society at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/ to explore the potential of games as learning tools. You can also visit GamesLearningSociety.org.