The Best Mounted Weapon in D&D: A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of the best mounted weapon in D&D is complex and depends heavily on your playstyle and the specific situation. However, when considering sheer potential for damage and tactical advantages, the answer leans heavily towards the Lance, used correctly, is the best mounted weapon. While it comes with a significant drawback, its strengths when utilized with skill and strategy often outweigh its weaknesses, making it a formidable choice for any mounted warrior.
Understanding the Lance’s Strengths and Weaknesses
The lance boasts the highest damage die of any one-handed weapon in D&D, typically a 1d12. This is a significant step up from the more common 1d8 or 1d6 that other one-handed weapons offer. The reach of the lance also provides a tactical advantage, allowing a mounted character to engage enemies from a safe distance.
However, the lance isn’t without its drawbacks. The most prominent of these is that it imposes Disadvantage on attack rolls against any target within 5 feet of you. This can be a significant handicap, limiting its use in close quarters and making it a gamble in crowded battles. Also, you must be mounted to wield a lance with one hand, otherwise, it must be wielded in two hands which has its own set of consequences.
Why the Lance is Still the Best
Despite the disadvantage, the lance retains its top position due to several factors:
- Devastating Charge: When used in a charge, the lance’s raw damage is simply unmatched among one-handed options. A well-executed mounted charge with a lance can often eliminate weaker foes outright and severely wound tougher opponents.
- Mobility and Reach: A mounted character using a lance can maintain distance and position much better than those on foot. The combination of mobility and reach allows the lancer to dictate the terms of engagement, picking off enemies from a safe distance and avoiding close-quarters skirmishes when possible.
- Strategic Positioning: A skilled lancer will always be aware of positioning, using the mount to its fullest capability to avoid being surrounded. This minimizes the instances where Disadvantage comes into play.
- Support from Allies: A team that works well together can further mitigate the disadvantages of the lance. Allies can engage targets who get too close, allowing the lancer to focus on targets at the edge of their reach.
Considering Other Options
While the lance comes out on top in most cases, other weapons have merit for a mounted combatant. The Cavalry Saber, also mentioned in the sources, is an excellent choice for a mobile warrior. Its curved design makes it ideal for slashing attacks from horseback, and while it lacks the raw damage potential of the lance, it doesn’t impose disadvantage in close combat. However, it doesn’t come close to the damage output of a lance.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 15 FAQs that explore mounted combat and weapon choices in more detail:
1. What makes a weapon good for mounted combat?
A weapon suited for mounted combat typically benefits from reach, is easily wielded while in the saddle, and does not cause excessive penalties due to the mount’s movement. The ability to strike from a distance while maintaining mobility is crucial.
2. What are the best alternatives to the lance for mounted combat?
Besides the lance, a saber, scimitar and a longbow can be effective choices. The saber and scimitar are designed for use on horseback, and the longbow allows for ranged attacks while maintaining mobility. Javelins can also be surprisingly effective, providing a ranged option with relatively high damage for each shot.
3. When should you not use a lance in mounted combat?
Avoid using the lance when expecting close-quarters fighting with multiple enemies and in confined spaces where you will often find yourself within 5 feet of your target. Disadvantage will severely hamper your efficacy. Situations where you can’t maneuver your mount freely will also make the lance difficult to use.
4. How do you minimize disadvantage with a lance?
Utilize your mount’s mobility to stay at the edge of your reach, keep your distance from your target, and coordinate with your team to engage enemies that close the gap.
5. Is the Yklwa a viable mounted weapon?
While the Yklwa has a decent damage die (1d8) and a thrown property, it is usually not the best choice on horseback when compared to a lance. The Lance’s higher damage output and reach makes it superior for mounted combat.
6. Why would anyone choose a dagger or club over a more damaging weapon?
Daggers and clubs can have advantages, such as being easily concealed, offering a lightweight option, and sometimes having special properties. Furthermore, some builds are designed around finesse weapons, making daggers a necessary part of their combat strategy.
7. Are legendary weapons the best option for mounted combat?
Legendary weapons, like the Hazirawn or Vorpal Sword, can provide significant advantages in mounted combat because of the additional damage and abilities they often grant. However, they are rare and not usually part of a player’s starting gear. A well-enchanted lance is often more accessible and can be nearly as powerful when used in a mount.
8. How does 2d6 compare to 1d12 in terms of damage?
2d6 provides more consistent damage, as the average roll is 7. 1d12, on the other hand, offers a higher maximum damage but also a chance for significantly lower rolls. 1d12 is slightly more volatile, where as 2d6 is more consistent with the average being its highest probability.
9. What class is best suited for mounted combat?
Paladins are exceptionally well-suited for mounted combat due to their high strength, martial prowess, and access to spells that can enhance their combat abilities. Other martial classes like Fighters and Rangers can also be effective riders. The Cavalier subclass is built entirely for mounted combat.
10. Is plate armor the best armor for mounted combat?
Plate armor offers the highest AC, making it ideal for protecting a mounted character. However, it is heavy and can be expensive. Consider lower-weight armor options if mobility is crucial.
11. Are there ways to counter mounted combatants?
Caltrops can hinder mounted units, forcing them to slow down. Also, archers or spellcasters can target the mount, making it difficult for the rider to maintain their positioning. Entangling spells and area of effect attacks can also be used to disrupt mounted characters.
12. How does horse armor work in D&D?
Horse armor, which can vary from leather to barding (metal armor), increases the mount’s AC. Leather is craftable, while other armor is generally obtained as loot.
13. What is a Horse Pistol?
A Horse Pistol is a period weapon that is designed for use on horseback. It is designed to be stowed on the saddle. The pistols are designed to be fired one handed.
14. What is the most damaging weapon in 5e?
The Flametongue Rapier, a magic weapon, can potentially deal significant damage with its combination of piercing and fire damage. However, this magic weapon is not available to all players and classes. A lance, however, can achieve comparable numbers with the right buffs and tactics.
15. What are the weaknesses of mounted combat?
Mounted combat is very strong, however, there are several weaknesses such as it being less effective in confined spaces, vulnerable to crowd control effects, and reliant on the mount’s survivability. If your mount is killed, you are no longer mounted.
Conclusion
While many weapons can be effective in mounted combat, the lance stands out as the best option when used strategically. Its combination of high damage, reach, and mobility, when used correctly, makes it the most powerful weapon for a mounted warrior in D&D. Understanding its limitations and using your mount effectively will ensure victory on the battlefield.