What is the Best Off-Hand Straight Sword in Elden Ring?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The best off-hand straight sword in Elden Ring often boils down to the Carian Knight’s Sword. Its inherent Magic damage and Intelligence scaling, coupled with the powerful Carian Grandeur weapon skill, make it an exceptional choice for builds focused on Intelligence or hybrid melee/caster playstyles. However, “best” is subjective and depends heavily on your build, playstyle, and the specific challenges you’re facing. Other excellent alternatives exist, each with its own strengths.
Understanding the Off-Hand Role
Before diving deeper, let’s clarify the purpose of an off-hand straight sword. Generally, it serves several key functions:
- Parrying: Straight swords are among the best weapon classes for parrying due to their decent speed and parry window.
- Quick Attacks/Roll Catches: Used to punish opponents trying to heal or creating space.
- Status Buildup: Inflicting status effects like bleed or frostbite is often easier with quick, off-hand attacks.
- Buff Application: Swords can be buffed with spells or greases to add elemental damage or status effects.
- Weapon Skill Variety: Access to unique and potentially powerful weapon skills without needing to two-hand the weapon.
Why the Carian Knight’s Sword Excels
The Carian Knight’s Sword shines in the off-hand for several reasons:
- Magic Damage Scaling: It deals primarily Magic damage, scaling with Intelligence. This is ideal for sorcerers who want a melee option without compromising their stats.
- Carian Grandeur Weapon Skill: This weapon skill summons a magical greatsword for a powerful, sweeping attack. The charge version is particularly devastating and can stagger most enemies. It is extremely effective at all stages of the game.
- Early Acquisition: Found in Liurnia of the Lakes, it is accessible relatively early in the game, allowing you to incorporate it into your build from the mid-game onward.
- Fashionable: Let’s be honest; it looks great.
Considerations for the Carian Knight’s Sword
Despite its strengths, the Carian Knight’s Sword is not without its drawbacks:
- Intelligence Requirement: It demands a significant Intelligence investment (10 Strength, 18 Dexterity, 24 Intelligence), making it unsuitable for non-Intelligence builds.
- Limited Scaling Beyond Soft Caps: Like many weapons, its scaling tapers off significantly beyond 60 Intelligence.
- Magic Resistance: Some enemies and bosses are highly resistant to Magic damage, making the Carian Knight’s Sword less effective against them.
Other Contenders for Best Off-Hand Straight Sword
While the Carian Knight’s Sword is a top contender, other straight swords can excel in specific situations:
- Lordsworn’s Straight Sword: A solid, versatile choice available early. It can be infused with Ashes of War, allowing you to customize its damage type (e.g., Fire, Lightning, Bleed) and weapon skill to suit your build. This makes it fantastic in the off-hand as a quick application of a specific status effect.
- Longsword: Another reliable early-game option, similar to the Lordsworn’s Straight Sword. Its versatility and availability make it a popular choice. Like the Lordsworn’s Straight Sword, the Longsword can be infused with Ashes of War.
- Broadsword: Known for its high physical damage output for a straight sword. While it lacks the range of other options, its damage can be significant, especially when infused and buffed.
- Sacred Relic Sword: Requires defeating the final boss (Elden Beast). Its weapon skill, Wave of Gold, deals massive Holy damage over a wide area. This is incredibly effective for farming runes and clearing large groups of enemies. While typically used as a main weapon, its wave skill can be used in the off-hand in certain situations.
- Miquellan Knight’s Sword: Deals Holy damage and scales with Faith and Dexterity. Its weapon skill, Sacred Blade, infuses the sword with Holy damage and launches a projectile. This weapon is especially effective against enemies weak to Holy damage, such as those found in the late-game areas.
- Rotten Crystal Sword: Deals primarily physical damage, but inflicts Scarlet Rot. While it is difficult to acquire and has a low drop rate from the Crystalians in Elphael, Brace of the Haligtree, the Scarlet Rot buildup can be a powerful tool against many bosses and enemies.
- Regalia of Eochaid: Deals physical and magic damage, scaling with Strength, Dexterity, and Arcane. Its unique weapon skill, Eochaid’s Dancing Blade, launches a spinning blade projectile that returns to the user. This weapon is especially effective for Arcane builds.
The Importance of Ashes of War
The Ash of War system significantly impacts the effectiveness of straight swords in the off-hand. Ashes of War allow you to change a weapon’s scaling, damage type, and weapon skill. This flexibility enables you to tailor your off-hand sword to your specific needs. For example:
- Bloodflame Blade: Adds fire damage and bleed buildup to your weapon.
- Chilling Mist: Adds frostbite buildup to your weapon.
- Golden Vow: Increases attack power and defense for a short time.
- Parry: Allows you to parry enemy attacks.
Final Verdict: It Depends on Your Build
Ultimately, the “best” off-hand straight sword is subjective and depends on your build and playstyle.
- For Intelligence builds, the Carian Knight’s Sword is an excellent choice.
- For Faith builds, the Miquellan Knight’s Sword is a strong contender.
- For Arcane builds, the Regalia of Eochaid is a unique option.
- For general versatility and customization, the Lordsworn’s Straight Sword or Longsword with a suitable Ash of War is hard to beat.
Experiment with different options to find what works best for you. Remember to consider your stat investment, desired status effects, and the enemies you’ll be facing.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Can you power stance straight swords in Elden Ring?
No, you cannot power stance straight swords. Power stancing requires two weapons of the same weapon class, and straight swords do not meet this requirement.
2. How do I infuse a straight sword with an Ash of War?
You need to visit a blacksmith, such as Hewg at the Roundtable Hold, or obtain the Whetstone Knife from Gatefront Ruins in Limgrave. With the Whetstone Knife, you can infuse weapons with Ashes of War at Sites of Grace.
3. Where can I find the Carian Knight’s Sword?
The Carian Knight’s Sword is found in a chest at the Carian Study Hall in Liurnia of the Lakes.
4. What stats does the Carian Knight’s Sword scale with?
The Carian Knight’s Sword primarily scales with Intelligence, but also has some scaling with Strength and Dexterity.
5. Is the Carian Knight’s Sword viable in the late game?
Yes, with sufficient Intelligence investment and upgrades, the Carian Knight’s Sword remains viable throughout the game.
6. What is the best Ash of War for a bleed build using a straight sword?
Bloodflame Blade is an excellent choice, as it adds fire damage and bleed buildup to your weapon.
7. Which straight sword has the highest physical damage?
The Broadsword generally has the highest raw physical damage among straight swords.
8. What is the best way to upgrade a straight sword?
Use Smithing Stones to upgrade standard straight swords and Somber Smithing Stones to upgrade unique straight swords like the Carian Knight’s Sword.
9. Can I use grease on the Carian Knight’s Sword?
No, the Carian Knight’s Sword cannot be buffed with greases or spells.
10. What are some good early-game straight swords?
The Longsword and Lordsworn’s Straight Sword are both excellent choices that are easily accessible early in the game.
11. How important is weapon scaling for an off-hand weapon?
Weapon scaling is less critical for an off-hand weapon primarily used for quick attacks or status buildup. However, if you plan to use weapon skills frequently, scaling becomes more important.
12. Is it worth dual-wielding straight swords?
While you cannot power stance straight swords, you can equip one in each hand and alternate attacks. This can be effective for applying status effects or dealing consistent damage, but it generally requires more stat investment.
13. What is the difference between physical and elemental damage on a straight sword?
Physical damage is resisted by an enemy’s physical defense, while elemental damage (e.g., Magic, Fire, Lightning, Holy) is resisted by their corresponding elemental defense. Knowing an enemy’s weaknesses is crucial for maximizing damage output.
14. How do I effectively use the Carian Grandeur weapon skill?
Charge the skill to its maximum level for the most damage and stagger potential. Time your attacks to coincide with enemy openings.
15. What is the best way to farm runes to upgrade my straight sword?
Early to mid-game, farming at the Palace Approach Ledge-Road in Mohgwyn Palace is an excellent option. Later in the game, the Sacred Relic Sword’s Wave of Gold skill is incredibly efficient for rune farming in the same area.