Table of Contents

Navigating the Moral Maze: Choosing the “Best” Option in Witcher 3’s Blood and Wine

Quick answer

This page answers What is the best option in Blood and Wine Witcher 3? quickly.

Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.

Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.

Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.

▶

The Blood and Wine expansion for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is a masterclass in storytelling, offering a vibrant new region, compelling characters, and a morally ambiguous narrative that forces players to confront difficult choices. Defining the “best” option is subjective, as each ending carries its own consequences and emotional weight. However, the ending most players consider the “best,” often referred to as the “happy ending,” involves saving both Duchess Anna Henrietta and her sister, Syanna, at the cost of killing Dettlaff. This outcome is achieved by retrieving the ribbon from the Little Flint Girl in the Land of Fables, ensuring Syanna’s survival, and then convincing her to forgive Anna Henrietta. This path leads to reconciliation, justice (of sorts), and a fitting conclusion to the complex relationship between the sisters. But is this truly the “best” option, or just the most palatable? The answer, like the story itself, is far more nuanced.

Decoding the Moral Compass of Toussaint

The brilliance of Blood and Wine lies in its refusal to offer easy answers. Each path presents its own set of moral compromises, forcing Geralt, and therefore the player, to grapple with issues of justice, revenge, forgiveness, and family. To determine the “best” option for you, you need to consider what values you prioritize. Do you believe in absolute justice, even if it leads to death? Or do you favor forgiveness and reconciliation, even if it means compromising your own moral code?

Understanding the Key Endings

Before delving into the details, let’s outline the primary endings available in Blood and Wine:

The “Happy Ending”: Syanna and Anna Henrietta reconcile. Dettlaff is killed. This is often considered the “best” because it results in the survival of the sisters and a semblance of peace in Toussaint.
The “Bittersweet Ending”: Syanna is killed by Dettlaff. Geralt can choose to fight Dettlaff or let him go. Anna Henrietta is devastated, and Geralt may be imprisoned.
The “Unhappy Ending”: Both Syanna and Anna Henrietta die. Geralt is imprisoned. This outcome is the result of failing to retrieve the ribbon and failing to convince Syanna to forgive her sister.

Achieving the “Happy” Ending: A Step-by-Step Guide

To secure the “happy” ending, you need to follow a specific path of choices:

Choose the “Land of Fables” Quest Line: When Regis asks you about your plan to stop Dettlaff, choose to find Syanna rather than seeking out the Unseen Elder. This triggers the quest “Beyond Hill and Dale.”
Enter the Land of Fables: Navigate through the fairytale realm, completing the various challenges and puzzles.
Find the Little Flint Girl: Locate the Little Flint Girl and either win the ribbon from her by playing Gwent or purchase it for 500 crowns. This ribbon is crucial for Syanna’s survival.
Attend the Tesham Mutna Investigation: After leaving the Land of Fables, investigate the fifth victim in the quest “Pomp and Strange Circumstance.” This provides crucial context for understanding Syanna’s motives and allows Geralt to engage in a meaningful dialogue with her.
The Confrontation in the Children’s Room: During the final confrontation with Syanna, use the knowledge you gained during the investigation to understand her perspective and remain sympathetic to her. This opens the door to convincing her to forgive Anna Henrietta.
The Reconciliation Scene: If you have the ribbon and have successfully convinced Syanna to forgive Anna Henrietta, the sisters will attempt to reconcile during the ceremony. Dettlaff will still appear, and you’ll be forced to fight and kill him to protect the Duchess.

Why the “Happy” Ending Isn’t Always So Happy

While the “happy” ending seems like the obvious choice, it’s important to acknowledge its flaws. Dettlaff, despite his monstrous nature, is ultimately a victim of Syanna’s manipulation. By killing him, Geralt is arguably perpetuating a cycle of violence and failing to address the root cause of the conflict. Furthermore, forcing reconciliation between the sisters might feel artificial and unsatisfying to some players. Is it truly a “happy” ending if it’s built on coercion and the death of another being?

Alternative Perspectives

Some players argue that letting Dettlaff kill Syanna and then choosing not to fight him is the more morally consistent choice. This path acknowledges the complexities of the situation and refuses to engage in further violence. While it results in Anna Henrietta’s grief, it also allows Regis to remain in Toussaint and avoids the bloodshed that defines the other endings. It also is more in line with Geralt’s code of neutrality. This ending highlights the devastating consequences of revenge and offers a grim reminder that some wounds cannot be healed.

The Role of Player Agency

Ultimately, the “best” option in Blood and Wine is the one that resonates most with your own moral compass. There is no right or wrong answer. The expansion’s true strength lies in its ability to provoke thought, challenge assumptions, and force players to confront the uncomfortable realities of a world where choices have real consequences. Consider the values of the GamesLearningSociety.org and how they can influence your decision when engaging with complex narratives like Blood and Wine.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are 15 frequently asked questions about the choices and endings in Blood and Wine:

Can you save both Dettlaff and Syanna? No. Dettlaff can only live if you allow him to kill Syanna and then choose not to fight him.
Should I find Syanna or Orianna first in Witcher 3? Finding Orianna first unlocks additional story content and provides more context for the overall narrative. However, to get the “happy” ending, you must eventually choose to find Syanna.
Does sleeping with Syanna affect anything? Romancing Syanna has no impact on the rest of the game or other romance options.
What happens if you let Dettlaff live? If you let Dettlaff live after he kills Syanna, he will leave Toussaint, and Regis will remain in Toussaint as well. Geralt, however, will be imprisoned for failing to stop Dettlaff.
Should I fight Dettlaff or let him go? This depends on your personal preference. Fighting him leads to the “happy” ending but requires killing Dettlaff. Letting him go is arguably a more neutral choice, but it results in Syanna’s death and Geralt’s imprisonment.
Can you romance Anna Henrietta after Blood and Wine? No, Anna Henrietta is not a romance option for Geralt.
How to save both sisters in Blood and Wine? You need the ribbon from the Little Flint Girl in the Land of Fables. You also need to convince Syanna to forgive Anna Henrietta during the final confrontation.
Who is the main villain in Blood and Wine? While Dettlaff is the immediate threat, Syanna is arguably the true antagonist, driven by revenge and manipulating events to her own ends.
Is it better for Ciri to be a Witcher or Empress? This is subjective. Witcher Ciri is following her passion, while Empress Ciri is arguably safer and more stable. It depends on what you value most for her future.
Can you romance Yennefer in Blood and Wine? If you romanced Yennefer in the main game, she will visit Corvo Bianco after Blood and Wine is completed.
Can you end up with Triss in Blood and Wine? If you romanced Triss in the main game, she will also visit Corvo Bianco.
Can you avoid killing Dettlaff? Yes, by allowing him to kill Syanna and then choosing not to fight him.
What is the best choice for Dettlaff witcher 3? Again, this is subjective. Killing him saves the sisters but perpetuates the cycle of violence. Letting him go results in Syanna’s death but avoids further bloodshed.
Can you become a vampire in The Witcher 3 Blood and Wine? No, Geralt cannot become a vampire in The Witcher 3.
Should I get Syanna the ribbon? Yes, if your goal is to save both sisters and achieve the so-called “happy” ending.

The Blood and Wine expansion presents players with a fascinating ethical puzzle. There’s no single “best” choice, as the optimal resolution hinges on individual moral principles. This exploration of complex ethics aligns well with the values espoused by organizations like the Games Learning Society, which examines how games can be used to educate and promote critical thinking. The compelling characters and ambiguous conclusions of Blood and Wine offer a wealth of opportunity for discussion and reflection.

Ultimately, the “best” option in Blood and Wine is the one that challenges you, makes you think, and leaves you pondering the complexities of morality long after the credits roll.