Choosing Your First Dance with Death: What’s the Best Dark Souls to Start With?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The Dark Souls series. Just the name conjures images of foreboding castles, relentless enemies, and that oh-so-satisfying feeling of finally overcoming a seemingly impossible challenge. But where do you begin this journey into the abyss? The answer, surprisingly, isn’t always straightforward. While each game shares core mechanics, they also possess distinct qualities that cater to different preferences and skill levels.
The best Dark Souls to start with is arguably Dark Souls III. It offers a smoother, more streamlined experience compared to its predecessors, with refined combat, better tutorials, and a generally more forgiving learning curve. This isn’t to say it’s easy, far from it. But it strikes a better balance between accessibility and the punishing difficulty the series is known for, making it an ideal entry point for newcomers.
Why Dark Souls III Reigns Supreme for Newcomers
Several factors contribute to Dark Souls III’s beginner-friendliness:
-
More Fluid Combat: Dark Souls III inherits the faster, more aggressive combat from Bloodborne. This results in a more responsive and engaging experience, particularly for players accustomed to modern action games. The ability to “weapon art” adds another layer of tactical depth.
-
Improved Tutorials and Onboarding: While still minimalist, Dark Souls III does a better job of subtly guiding players through the initial stages of the game. Important mechanics are introduced more organically, reducing the initial confusion that plagued earlier entries.
-
More Forgiving Level Design: While still challenging, Dark Souls III’s level design is generally more linear and less punishing than that of Dark Souls or Dark Souls II. Fewer instant-death traps and clearer pathways make exploration less frustrating.
-
Visually Stunning World: The graphical fidelity of Dark Souls III is a significant step up from its predecessors. The stunning environments and detailed character models create a more immersive and captivating experience, drawing players deeper into the world.
Weighing the Alternatives: Dark Souls and Dark Souls II
While Dark Souls III is the recommended starting point, the other entries in the series have their own merits:
-
Dark Souls: Prepare to Die Edition (or Remastered): This is where it all began. The original Dark Souls is revered for its intricate world design, interconnected levels, and sense of exploration. However, its clunkier combat, obtuse mechanics, and unforgiving difficulty can be overwhelming for new players. The lack of fast travel early on can be a major deterrent for those unfamiliar with the interconnected world design.
-
Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin: Often considered the black sheep of the series, Dark Souls II features some unique mechanics, such as power stancing, and a more robust build variety. However, it suffers from clunky movement, questionable enemy placement, and a less cohesive world design. The “Adaptability” stat, which governs invincibility frames during rolls, is a major source of frustration for new players who are unaware of its importance. This is generally considered the least beginner friendly of the trilogy.
Beyond the Core Trilogy: Demon’s Souls and Other Soulslikes
Before Dark Souls, there was Demon’s Souls, the progenitor of the Soulsborne genre. While mechanically simpler than the Dark Souls games, Demon’s Souls is still a challenging and rewarding experience. The remake on PlayStation 5 is visually stunning and offers a more accessible entry point than the original.
Outside the core series, many excellent Soulslike games offer different interpretations of the formula. These include:
-
Elden Ring: An open-world masterpiece that provides unprecedented freedom and exploration, while also maintaining the core Soulsborne challenge. This is considered beginner friendly due to the open world nature. Players can always find another area if they run into something too difficult.
-
Bloodborne: A faster-paced, more aggressive take on the Soulsborne formula, with a focus on offensive combat and a gothic horror setting. While its difficulty is comparable to Dark Souls, the faster combat might appeal to some players more.
-
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice: A parry-focused action game with a unique posture-breaking mechanic and a compelling story. This is typically not recommended as a starting point due to its unique combat system and reliance on precise timing.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Which Dark Souls game has the best story?
This is subjective, but many consider the original Dark Souls to have the most compelling and mysterious story, told primarily through environmental storytelling and item descriptions.
2. What is the easiest starting class in Dark Souls?
In Dark Souls III, the Knight is often recommended for beginners due to its strong starting armor, weapon, and well-rounded stats. In Dark Souls 1, the Warrior or Knight are generally considered the best.
3. What is the best build for beginners in Dark Souls?
A strength build focusing on heavy armor and powerful weapons is often recommended for beginners. This allows you to withstand more damage and deal significant damage in return.
4. Do starting classes matter in Dark Souls?
Yes, they provide you with initial weapons, armor, and stats, but in the long run, you can build your character in any direction you choose. The class mostly impacts the early game.
5. Is Dark Souls difficult?
Yes, the Dark Souls games are known for their challenging difficulty, which stems from unforgiving combat, complex level design, and demanding boss battles.
6. What makes Dark Souls so rewarding?
The sense of accomplishment that comes from overcoming seemingly insurmountable challenges, the depth of the world, and the freedom to create your own unique character build.
7. What is the best way to learn the Dark Souls combat system?
Practice, patience, and observation. Pay attention to enemy attack patterns, experiment with different weapons and strategies, and don’t be afraid to die (you will, a lot).
8. Should I use a shield in Dark Souls?
Shields can be very helpful for beginners, allowing you to block attacks and create openings for counterattacks. However, learning to dodge is also crucial for mastering the game.
9. What is the importance of stats in Dark Souls?
Stats determine your character’s attributes, such as health, stamina, strength, and magic. Leveling up the right stats is crucial for creating a viable character build.
10. How do I level up in Dark Souls?
By collecting souls from defeated enemies and spending them at bonfires to increase your stats.
11. What are bonfires?
Checkpoints scattered throughout the world where you can rest, replenish your health and estus flasks, and level up. However, resting at a bonfire will also respawn most enemies.
12. What are estus flasks?
Healing items that replenish your health. You can find and upgrade estus flasks throughout the game.
13. What is humanity (or embers)?
Items that restore your humanity (or ember status), allowing you to summon other players for co-op and kindle bonfires to increase the number of estus flasks you receive.
14. Can I play Dark Souls with friends?
Yes, the Dark Souls games feature a cooperative multiplayer system that allows you to summon other players to help you through difficult areas and boss battles.
15. Where can I learn more about game design?
For those interested in the deeper aspects of game design and the impact of games on society, consider exploring the resources available at the Games Learning Society website, GamesLearningSociety.org.
Embrace the Challenge
The Dark Souls series is not for the faint of heart, but it offers a unique and rewarding gaming experience unlike any other. By starting with Dark Souls III and gradually working your way through the other entries, you can ease yourself into the challenging world and appreciate the subtle nuances of each game. Remember to be patient, persistent, and embrace the inevitable deaths that await you. And most importantly, have fun!