Decoding Need vs. Greed in World of Warcraft: A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
In the vast and immersive world of World of Warcraft (WoW), navigating the complexities of loot distribution can be as challenging as facing a raid boss. One of the most fundamental concepts players encounter is the difference between “Need” and “Greed” when it comes to rolling for items. Understanding this distinction is crucial for maintaining good etiquette, fostering positive group dynamics, and ultimately, acquiring the gear you need to progress. So, what is the core difference? In simple terms, “Need” is reserved for items that are an actual upgrade for your character’s primary specialization, while “Greed” is for items that you want for other reasons, such as off-spec use, selling, or disenchanting. This difference is at the heart of how loot distribution functions in WoW and impacts player interaction significantly.
Understanding the Basics of Need and Greed
The loot system in WoW operates on a roll system where players choose between “Need”, “Greed”, “Disenchant” or “Pass” options when an item drops. When a player clicks “Need”, they are essentially stating that the item is a significant upgrade to their current gear in their current specialization. When clicking “Greed”, players are indicating that they still want the item, but it isn’t a direct upgrade for their current gear. This distinction prioritizes players who benefit most from an item. When an item drops, players choose one of the four options or can choose to not roll at all by just closing the item roll window. If multiple players click Need, a random roll is done to choose the winner. If no one clicks Need but multiple players click Greed, a random roll is done to choose the winner. If no players click either Need or Greed, the item remains unclaimed on the corpse for anyone to loot.
Need: Prioritizing Gear Upgrades
The “Need” option is meant for situations where a particular item is a legitimate upgrade for your character’s primary specialization. This doesn’t necessarily mean it has to be a huge upgrade; even a small improvement, such as a weapon with slightly better stats or a piece of armor that fills a currently vacant slot, qualifies as “need”.
- Primary Specialization: This is the spec you are currently playing and gearing for. If you are playing a Restoration Druid, the plate gear for a Protection Paladin is not meant for you and should not be “needed” unless no one else in the group needs it.
- Direct Upgrade: This means the item offers better stats, item levels, or unique effects that will improve your character’s performance in your chosen role (e.g., damage, healing, tanking).
- Fair Play: Using “Need” correctly is about playing fairly and acknowledging that some players have a greater claim to an item.
Greed: Secondary Options and Other Uses
The “Greed” option comes into play when an item is not a direct upgrade for your character’s main specialization. There are several common scenarios where using “Greed” is appropriate:
- Off-Spec Gear: If you have an alternate role you enjoy playing (e.g. a DPS warrior who wants some tanking gear), you can roll “Greed” for gear useful in that spec if no one else “Needs” it.
- Transmog: Players wanting to collect items for their appearances can roll “Greed.”
- Selling/Disenchanting: Items can be sold on the auction house or disenchanted into crafting materials; “Greed” rolls are appropriate in these cases.
- Collection: Some players enjoy collecting different armor pieces and weapons; “Greed” rolls are useful for this purpose.
The Importance of Loot Etiquette
Choosing “Need” or “Greed” correctly is not just about getting the best loot; it’s also about following loot etiquette. Respectful behavior contributes to positive group experiences. Choosing “Need” for every item regardless if it is an upgrade, is often called ninja looting and can have you ostracized from a group and cause conflict.
FAQs About Need and Greed in WoW
To provide further clarity and address common queries, here are some frequently asked questions:
1. What happens when multiple people click “Need” on the same item?
When multiple players click “Need”, the game performs a random roll, and the player with the highest roll wins the item. This prevents disputes and allows for fair distribution when multiple people genuinely need the gear.
2. Can I click “Need” if I plan to sell the item later?
No, clicking “Need” to sell an item later would be considered improper etiquette. “Need” is reserved for situations where the item is a gear upgrade for your current spec. If you want to sell it, click “Greed”.
3. Is it okay to click “Need” on an item that’s a very slight upgrade?
Yes, even if the upgrade is minor, if it is still an upgrade to your character in your currently active specialization, using “Need” is acceptable. If a similar upgrade exists, such as an item with the same stats but different colors, clicking “Greed” would be the more respectful option.
4. What does it mean when I see “Need before Greed” in a group description?
“Need before Greed” is a commonly used loot system and guideline where players with a genuine need for the item (as a primary spec upgrade) are prioritized. This is similar to the default roll system and essentially means, unless stated otherwise, that players should choose the roll options based on whether the item is an upgrade for their current role. It helps promote fair distribution of loot.
5. What if I click “Need” by accident?
It’s always best to be mindful of your clicks. The game provides a confirmation step before finalizing your roll so players can verify their choice. If you accidentally click “Need” when you should’ve clicked “Greed”, you should explain it to the group and try to make amends, especially if another player needed it.
6. What happens if nobody clicks “Need” or “Greed” on an item?
If no one rolls “Need” or “Greed”, the item remains on the corpse, free for anyone to loot. Be aware that any looting done after this step is not protected by the need/greed rule and may be seen as unethical if someone was waiting for the item to be unrolled to pick it up.
7. Is it okay to click “Greed” on an item that someone else clearly needs?
Clicking “Greed” when another player in the group clearly needs the item is generally acceptable but not always advisable. While you are not necessarily doing anything wrong, this may be considered rude in some groups. It is always best to communicate with the group what your goals are.
8. When is it okay to click “Need” for an off-spec?
Clicking “Need” for off-spec gear is usually only acceptable if no one else in the group needs the item as an upgrade for their current spec. This helps to avoid conflicts and ensures everyone benefits from the loot.
9. How do you know if an item is an upgrade?
Utilize the game’s item comparison system, where you can compare the stats of an item with what you’re currently wearing. There are also several tools and add-ons available that can help. A good rule of thumb is: if the item level is higher and the primary stats are better for your current role, it is likely an upgrade.
10. What is a “Ninja Looter”?
A “Ninja Looter” is a player who uses the “Need” option dishonestly, such as “needing” an item for an off-spec or just to sell it, even though another player clearly needed it as a gear upgrade. This behavior is considered unethical and can harm a player’s reputation.
11. Does “Need before Greed” apply to all types of content?
Generally, “Need before Greed” etiquette applies to most group content, including dungeons, raids, and world bosses. However, it’s always best to confirm loot rules with the group before starting an activity, especially if you are not familiar with them.
12. What is “Master Looter”?
Master Looter is a deprecated loot system where a single member of a group is responsible for choosing who receives loot. While no longer a loot option available to players by default, it is still a part of some organized, high-end raids and guild systems.
13. Can the loot rules change in the future?
Blizzard, the company behind WoW, often makes changes to the game, including the loot systems. It’s important to stay updated on game changes through the official patch notes and community discussions.
14. What is Personal Loot?
Personal loot is a loot system where players receive loot tailored to their characters individually. In this system, items are automatically awarded based on the player’s current loot specialization and are not rolled on in a group setting.
15. Why did they get rid of master loot?
Master Loot was removed as a loot option for most of the game because the system was often misused for personal gain by some players, leaving many feeling cheated. Blizzard has moved towards loot systems that prioritize fairness and inclusivity.
Conclusion: Playing Fair and Enjoying the Game
Understanding the nuances of “Need” and “Greed” in WoW is essential for having a positive gaming experience. By using the loot options as intended and respecting other players, you contribute to a more enjoyable environment for everyone. When in doubt, always communicate with your group and adhere to the principles of fair play and courtesy. This way, you can continue to explore and conquer Azeroth, equipped with both skill and the loot you need.