Group Loot vs. Need Before Greed: Understanding the Nuances of Loot Systems
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The world of online multiplayer games, particularly MMORPGs like World of Warcraft, is often governed by complex loot systems. Two prominent methods, group loot and need before greed, have significantly shaped player experiences and interactions. While both aim to distribute items among a group, their mechanisms and implications differ considerably. Simply put, group loot is a more open system where anyone who is eligible to use an item can roll for it, while need before greed prioritizes those who truly need the item for their class or build over those who simply want it for off-spec or for personal gain. This subtle difference leads to drastically different social dynamics and strategic considerations.
Group Loot: Random Rolls for Everyone
How Group Loot Functions
In a group loot system, when an eligible item drops, it triggers a roll among all players in the group who are capable of using that item. For instance, if a plate helmet drops, all plate-wearing classes (e.g., Paladins, Warriors, Death Knights) in the group are eligible to roll. The system then assigns a random number to each eligible player, and whoever has the highest roll wins the item. This method is largely based on random chance.
Advantages of Group Loot
- Simplicity: Its straightforward nature makes it easy to understand, even for newer players.
- Equality: Everyone who can utilize an item has an equal chance to win it, promoting a sense of fairness.
- Flexibility: Players aren’t restricted to “needing” an item, allowing off-spec or cosmetic gear acquisition more accessible.
Disadvantages of Group Loot
- Potential for Greed: It can encourage players to roll on items they don’t necessarily need, potentially depriving those who would benefit more.
- Competition: The randomness can lead to intense competition for coveted items, occasionally breeding animosity within groups.
- Lack of Prioritization: Doesn’t discriminate between players who need the item for main spec and those who just want it for other purposes.
Need Before Greed: Prioritizing Essential Upgrades
How Need Before Greed Functions
The need before greed system adds a layer of prioritization. Players are given two options when an eligible item drops: “Need” or “Greed.” Players can only select “Need” on items that are specifically designated for their current class and role. For example, a warrior can “need” a tanking shield but can only “greed” a caster’s staff. If multiple players select “Need,” the system will roll among them. If no one selects “Need,” players who selected “Greed” will roll for the item. In most systems, players who don’t have the right armor class or who already possess the same or similar item may be automatically passed over.
Advantages of Need Before Greed
- Fairness in Upgrades: Ensures that players who need an item to progress their primary role have a better chance of obtaining it.
- Reduced Greed: Discourages players from rolling on items they don’t immediately need, fostering a more collaborative atmosphere.
- Clear Purpose: Establishes a clear hierarchy of priority, making it easier to manage loot distribution in a group.
Disadvantages of Need Before Greed
- Restriction: Can limit the ability to collect gear for off-specs or purely cosmetic purposes.
- Potential for Abuse: While rare, some players might attempt to exploit the system by changing specs temporarily just to “need” an item.
- Complexity: Slightly more complex than group loot, which can be confusing for beginners.
Key Differences Summarized
The core distinction lies in the intent behind the system. Group loot is inclusive, allowing anyone who can equip an item to roll, while need before greed prioritizes the progression and efficiency of the group. Think of it as a difference between a free-for-all raffle (group loot) and a carefully prioritized lottery where those in the most critical need have an advantage (need before greed).
Need before greed aims to reduce the occurrences of players rolling “greed” on items when someone else in the party/raid actually needs it to progress. While group loot doesn’t differentiate between who needs an item the most, need before greed’s prioritization can lead to a more efficient and cooperative gaming experience, particularly in progression content.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What happens if no one needs an item in a need before greed system?
If no player selects “Need” on an item, the system will proceed to a “Greed” roll among players who selected that option. The highest roll wins.
2. Can you “Need” an item for an off-spec in Need before Greed?
Usually, no. The “Need” option is generally reserved for your currently active specialization, ensuring you have a primary use for the item. Items needed for an off-spec are rolled for with “Greed.”
3. Is “Need before Greed” the same as “Master Looter”?
No. “Master Looter” is a completely different loot system where a designated player decides how loot is distributed. Need before Greed is an automated system with a defined set of rules.
4. When was group loot removed from World of Warcraft?
The subject of the original group loot system was removed in patch 8.0.1 of World of Warcraft.
5. How does Dragonflight handle loot in World of Warcraft?
Dragonflight uses a modified version of group loot, where loot that drops is not specific to the classes in the group. This means there is the potential for any armor type, including items not used by classes in the group, to drop.
6. What is the difference between group loot and personal loot?
With group loot, any eligible player rolls on items. With personal loot, the system decides who gets loot and then determines the item based on the player’s class and loot preferences.
7. How does the round-robin loot system work?
Round-robin looting cycles items evenly through all group members, essentially making it a fair, but unselective system.
8. What are the disadvantages of the round robin loot system?
While it is fair, round robin is not very efficient, as it may lead to players receiving items that are of little to no use to them.
9. Why is round robin used in other contexts outside of gaming?
Outside of gaming, round-robin scheduling is valued for its fairness in allocating resources, ensuring no one process or entity monopolizes a resource. This applies to things like computer process scheduling and in tournaments.
10. What are the main issues with a group loot system?
The primary problems with group loot are the potential for greed, where players roll on items they don’t really need, and the heightened competition for valuable loot.
11. How does need before greed etiquette work?
Need before greed etiquette encourages players to only roll need if they require an item for their main spec, leaving items for off-spec or cosmetic purposes for after the main users have had a chance.
12. What is shared loot?
Shared loot means players who have assisted in killing a mob all have a chance at receiving items, as opposed to one player receiving all of the loot.
13. What are loot tables?
Loot tables are data files that define what items can drop from particular enemies, chests, or other sources.
14. Why did Blizzard remove Personal Loot in WoW?
Blizzard removed personal loot to create a unified system, preventing players from circumventing random drops by strategically stacking certain classes or roles.
15. What does “burst time” mean in computing?
Burst time refers to the amount of CPU processing time a task requires to complete its execution.