Hero vs. Vagabond in Elden Ring: A Tarnished’s Tale of Two Beginnings
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The Lands Between calls to all manner of Tarnished, each with their own past and destiny. When starting your Elden Ring adventure, choosing your class is the first step on this arduous journey. Two popular choices for melee-focused players are the Hero and the Vagabond, each offering a distinct starting point with profound implications for your early game experience and build possibilities. The primary difference lies in their stat distribution and starting equipment: the Hero boasts higher Strength, Vigor, and some Arcane, geared towards wielding heavy weapons and brute force, while the Vagabond offers a more balanced approach with decent Strength, Dexterity, and Vigor, making them versatile for a wide range of builds. The Vagabond is usually considered as the “safe” pick for new players, allowing them to make mistakes and adapt more easily.
Decoding the Core Differences
Stats: Strength vs. Versatility
The Hero shines with its impressive Strength stat. This allows you to immediately wield heavier weapons that pack a serious punch, granting you an early advantage in combat. The high Vigor also provides a substantial health pool, enhancing survivability. The inclusion of Arcane suggests a potential for future experimentation with certain incantations or item discovery.
On the other hand, the Vagabond presents a more balanced stat spread. While their Strength isn’t as initially impressive as the Hero’s, it’s still sufficient for wielding many decent weapons. The presence of a good Dexterity stat also opens up possibilities for quicker weapons and combat styles. The Vigor ensures decent health, and the remaining stats are distributed in a way that allows for future specialization. This is the safest choice for newcomers.
Equipment: Axe and Shield vs. Sword and Armor
The Hero starts with a Battle Axe and a Leather Shield. The Battle Axe is a powerful weapon capable of dealing significant damage, especially early on. Paired with high Strength and Vigor it allows the player to go head to head with nearly all beginning enemies and even early bosses. The Leather Shield provides some protection, though it’s not ideal for parrying.
The Vagabond begins their journey with a Longsword, a Heater Shield, and a full set of armor. The Longsword is a versatile weapon that can be used for thrusting and slashing, while the Heater Shield offers excellent physical defense. The starting armor provides additional protection, further enhancing survivability.
Early Game Experience: Power vs. Flexibility
Choosing the Hero means embracing a power-focused approach from the start. You’ll be able to tackle early enemies head-on, relying on brute force and high health to overcome challenges. However, you might find yourself limited in terms of weapon choices if you prefer faster, more agile combat.
Selecting the Vagabond offers a more flexible start. You can experiment with different weapon types and combat styles, adapting your build to your preferences. The starting armor and shield will provide a solid foundation for survival, allowing you to learn the game’s mechanics without being overwhelmed.
Which Class is Right for You?
Ultimately, the best class depends on your preferred playstyle and build intentions.
-
Choose Hero if:
- You want to focus on Strength-based builds using heavy weapons.
- You prefer a direct, aggressive combat style.
- You value high health and survivability.
-
Choose Vagabond if:
- You’re new to Elden Ring or Souls-like games.
- You want a versatile class that can adapt to different builds.
- You prefer a balanced approach to combat.
- You want good starting armor.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: Is the Hero class bad for magic builds?
While the Hero‘s low Intelligence and Faith make it less ideal for traditional magic builds, the Arcane stat opens up some options. Certain incantations and weapon skills scale with Arcane, allowing for a unique hybrid build. However, if you primarily want to focus on sorceries or faith-based incantations, other classes like the Astrologer or Prophet would be more suitable.
Q2: Can the Vagabond use heavy weapons effectively?
Yes, the Vagabond‘s decent Strength stat allows them to wield many heavy weapons, especially after leveling up. While they might not be able to use the absolute heaviest weapons right away, they can certainly create effective Strength-based builds.
Q3: Does the Vagabond’s starting armor make a big difference?
Yes, the Vagabond‘s starting armor provides a noticeable increase in physical defense, which can be crucial for survival in the early game. It allows you to take more hits and learn enemy attack patterns without being instantly killed.
Q4: Is the Hero class good for parrying?
The Hero‘s starting Leather Shield isn’t the best for parrying, but it can still be done. However, it may be worthwhile for the hero to invest in a shield with better parrying capabilities.
Q5: Which class is better for a “quality” build (Strength and Dexterity)?
The Vagabond is generally considered the better choice for a quality build. Their balanced stat distribution makes it easier to invest in both Strength and Dexterity without feeling like you’re wasting points.
Q6: Can I respec my stats later in the game?
Yes, you can respec your stats in Elden Ring after defeating Rennala, Queen of the Full Moon. This allows you to experiment with different builds without having to start a new game.
Q7: Does starting class matter in the long run?
While starting class affects your initial experience, it becomes less significant as you progress. By the mid-to-late game, your stats and equipment will largely determine your build, regardless of your starting class.
Q8: Which class is best for a beginner who wants to try everything?
The Vagabond is the most forgiving for beginners who are unsure of which build they wish to pursue as their well-rounded stats can be used to create many builds. This is a great option for players who are new to souls like games and want to experiment.
Q9: Is there an “easy mode” in Elden Ring?
While there is no official easy mode, the Vagabond’s decent stats and starting armor can make the early game slightly easier. The ability to summon spirit ashes and co-op multiplayer can also help ease the difficulty.
Q10: Where can I learn more about Elden Ring builds and strategies?
There are many online resources available, including wikis, forums, and YouTube channels. You can also check out websites like GamesLearningSociety.org to learn about the educational aspects of gaming and how games like Elden Ring can enhance problem-solving skills.
Q11: What are some good early game weapons for the Hero?
Besides the starting Battle Axe, you can find other powerful early game weapons like the Greatsword or the Claymore, which scale well with Strength.
Q12: What are some good early game weapons for the Vagabond?
The Longsword is a solid starting weapon, but you can also find the Twinblade, Uchigatana or the Lordsworn’s Straight Sword early on.
Q13: How does Arcane affect the Hero’s gameplay?
Arcane primarily affects item discovery, increasing your chances of finding rare loot. It can also be used to cast certain incantations that scale with Arcane.
Q14: Can the Vagabond become a powerful magic user?
While the Vagabond‘s starting Intelligence and Faith are low, they can still become effective magic users by investing in those stats. However, it might require more stat allocation compared to classes that start with higher magic stats.
Q15: Should I choose a class based on its lore?
While the lore of each class can be interesting, it should not be the primary factor in your decision. Focus on the stats and starting equipment that best align with your desired playstyle and build.
In conclusion, the choice between Hero and Vagabond depends on your desired playstyle and build preferences. The Hero offers a powerful start with high Strength and Vigor, while the Vagabond provides a more versatile and balanced approach. No matter which class you choose, remember that your journey in the Lands Between is yours to forge. Good luck, Tarnished!