Hexproof vs. Shroud: Untangling Magic’s Protection Keywords
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The core difference between shroud and hexproof in Magic: The Gathering boils down to who can target the permanent in question. Hexproof prevents your opponents from targeting the permanent, while shroud prevents everyone, including you, from targeting it. This subtle but significant difference impacts card design and strategic gameplay immensely.
Shroud: The Original “Hands Off” Ability
What Shroud Does
Shroud is the older of the two mechanics and, in essence, creates a zone of untouchability around a permanent (usually a creature). If something has shroud, no player can target it with spells or abilities. This means you can’t boost your own shroud creature with an aura or target it with a beneficial instant in response to removal. It’s protection, but at a cost.
The intent behind Shroud was to protect a permanent but due to some unintentional consequences of the mechanic, it has since been replaced by Hexproof.
Why Shroud Can Be a Double-Edged Sword
While protecting a creature from your opponent’s removal is excellent, shroud can limit your ability to enhance or save your own creatures. This restriction often makes shroud a less desirable ability than hexproof in many situations.
Shroud and Board Wipes
Like hexproof, shroud offers no protection against board wipes. This is because board wipes don’t target individual permanents; they affect the entire battlefield. Spells like “Wrath of God” or “Damnation” will destroy creatures with shroud just as readily as any other creature.
Hexproof: The “Fixed” Shroud
How Hexproof Improves on Shroud
Hexproof is effectively the revised and more intuitive version of shroud. It protects a permanent from being targeted by spells or abilities your opponents control. This crucial distinction allows you to target your own hexproof creatures with buffs, equipment, and rescue spells, while still denying your opponent the ability to remove them with targeted removal.
The Strategic Advantage of Hexproof
The primary benefit of hexproof is that it provides a degree of protection without completely locking you out of interacting with your own permanent. You can equip it with powerful artifacts, enchant it with Auras, and cast instants and sorceries to enhance its abilities or save it from harm. This flexibility makes hexproof a highly valued ability in many competitive decks.
Board Wipes and Hexproof
Just like shroud, hexproof doesn’t protect against non-targeting effects, such as board wipes. Spells that destroy all creatures or inflict damage on all creatures will still affect creatures with hexproof.
Strategic Implications
The choice between using a creature with shroud versus one with hexproof often comes down to the strategy of your deck. If your deck relies heavily on auras and equipment, hexproof is the clear winner. However, in a deck that focuses on raw power and resilience, the downside of shroud might be less significant.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Does Hexproof stop Deathtouch?
Hexproof only prevents targeting. Deathtouch is a static ability that affects combat damage, not targeting. A creature with deathtouch will still destroy a creature with hexproof if it deals damage to it in combat.
2. Does Hexproof stop sacrifice effects?
No. Hexproof protects against spells or abilities that target the creature. Sacrifice effects, such as those from cards like “Diabolic Edict,” often target the player, forcing them to sacrifice a creature. In this case, hexproof provides no protection.
3. Can you enchant a creature with Hexproof?
You cannot cast an Aura spell targeting a permanent with hexproof controlled by an opponent. However, if you can put an Aura onto the battlefield without casting it (e.g., with a card ability), you can attach it to a permanent with hexproof.
4. Does Hexproof stop “Return to Hand” effects?
Hexproof prevents the creature from being the target of spells or abilities your opponent controls. If the “Return to Hand” effect targets the creature, then hexproof will protect it. If the effect doesn’t target, such as a global bounce spell, hexproof offers no protection.
5. Does Hexproof stop Wrath of God?
No. “Wrath of God” destroys all creatures. Since it doesn’t target, hexproof is ineffective.
6. How do you get rid of creatures with Hexproof?
Use non-targeting removal like board wipes, sacrifice effects, or effects that reduce toughness to zero.
7. Is Hexproof better than indestructible?
It depends on the situation. Indestructible protects against destruction effects, while hexproof protects against targeted removal. Both are strong, but have different weaknesses. Indestructible can be bypassed by exile effects, and hexproof by board wipes.
8. Can you counter a creature with Hexproof?
Yes, you can counter the spell that is a creature with hexproof while it is on the stack (being cast). Hexproof only applies once the creature is on the battlefield.
9. Does Hexproof stop abilities triggered by a creature entering the battlefield?
Hexproof only prevents spells or abilities from targeting the permanent. Abilities that trigger upon a creature entering the battlefield do not target, so hexproof does not stop them.
10. Does Hexproof cause Auras to fall off?
No. Hexproof prevents the permanent from being targeted by spells or abilities. Auras already attached to the permanent remain in place.
11. Can you target your own creature with Shroud?
No. Shroud prevents any player from targeting the permanent, including its controller.
12. Does Shroud protect against effects that give -X/-X to all creatures?
No. Shroud protects against targeted spells and abilities. Effects that give all creatures -X/-X do not target, therefore shroud does not protect against them.
13. How do you get rid of creatures with Indestructible?
Exile them, reduce their toughness to 0, force your opponent to sacrifice them, or counter them when cast.
14. Does Double Strike beat Deathtouch?
Yes, a creature with first strike or double strike can defeat a creature with deathtouch in combat without being destroyed. The first strike damage step will kill the deathtouch creature before it can deal damage in the normal combat damage step.
15. Are there situations where Shroud is preferable to Hexproof?
Rarely. The main advantage of shroud is that it also protects from your own accidental targeting, but this is generally not worth the significant downside of not being able to buff or protect your own creature. In some very niche cases, a card with shroud might have a lower mana cost or other beneficial stats compared to a similar card with hexproof, making it a better option in specific deck archetypes. Understanding the nuances between hexproof and shroud is critical for strategic gameplay in Magic: The Gathering. While shroud provides blanket protection, hexproof offers a more balanced approach, allowing you to target your own creatures while shielding them from your opponents’ control. Choose wisely, and may your protected creatures reign supreme! You can learn more about this and other great articles on Games Learning Society or GamesLearningSociety.org.