The Genshin Impact Character Controversy: A Deep Dive
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Genshin Impact, the globally popular gacha game developed by HoYoverse, has faced a multitude of controversies surrounding its characters. These controversies range from accusations of underpowered characters and racial insensitivity in character design, to labor disputes with voice actors, censorship concerns tied to the Chinese government, and gender representation issues in the character roster. These multifaceted issues have sparked heated debates within the Genshin Impact community, leading to boycotts, petitions, and widespread criticism of HoYoverse’s handling of the game.
A Nexus of Discontent: Character-Related Controversies
The heart of the issue lies in the intersection of several sensitive areas. Let’s break down the key areas contributing to character controversy in Genshin Impact:
1. Character Power & Gameplay Balance
One of the most frequent criticisms revolves around the perceived power level and usability of newly released characters. The gacha system, where players spend in-game currency (often acquired with real money) for a chance to obtain specific characters, creates high expectations. When a character is deemed underpowered or doesn’t synergize well with existing team compositions, it leads to player frustration.
Dehya, a Pyro character, serves as a prime example. Her kit was heavily criticized for its poor damage output, awkward gameplay mechanics, and vulnerability to certain enemy attacks, leading many to label her the “worst 5-star character” in the game. This situation was exacerbated by the fact that players had invested resources to acquire and build her, only to find her significantly weaker than anticipated.
2. Representation & Diversity
Genshin Impact’s character roster has also been a focal point for discussions on representation and diversity. Specifically, the game has been criticized for:
- Colorism: The initial designs for characters from the Sumeru region, inspired by South Asian, Middle Eastern, and North African cultures, sparked controversy due to their predominantly light skin tones. This raised concerns about the perpetuation of colorism and the erasure of darker skin tones within these cultures. The leaked splash art for Collei, Dori, and Tighnari fueled this debate, highlighting the perceived lack of diverse representation.
- Limited Darker-Skinned Characters: The game features a limited number of characters with darker skin tones. The portrayal of Kaeya, one of the few darker-skinned characters, has also faced criticism, with some alleging that he has been whitewashed in certain promotional materials.
- Sexualization and Gender Representation: Certain character designs, particularly female characters from Sumeru, were criticized for their emphasis on bare midriffs and belly-dance inspired costumes. This raised concerns about the objectification of female characters and the perpetuation of stereotypical representations. Also, the lack of female designs that would be considered non-sexualized continues to fuel discussion.
- Waifu Obsession: The community’s strong preference towards “waifu” designs (attractive female characters) often leads to backlash against male characters or characters with non-conventional designs. The teaser for Lyney, a male character, faced a wave of dislikes and toxic comments simply because he wasn’t considered a “waifu.”
3. Voice Actor Disputes and Labor Practices
The game’s success is supported by voice actors and production teams, and recent allegations claim that they have not been paid. Financial tensions involving voice actors and HoYoverse have had consequences.
- Unpaid Voice Actors: In July 2023, several Genshin Impact voice actors publicly stated that they had not been paid for their work, with one actor claiming to be at risk of homelessness due to the lack of income. This exposed potential issues with HoYoverse’s payment practices and raised concerns about the treatment of voice actors within the industry.
- Formosa Group Disputes: The disputes extended to the recording studio, Formosa Group, used by HoYoverse, further highlighting the financial complexities and potential exploitation of talent involved in the game’s production.
4. Censorship and Governmental Influence
As a Chinese-developed game, Genshin Impact is subject to Chinese government regulations and censorship policies.
- In-Game Chat Censorship: The in-game chat function is heavily censored to comply with Chinese regulations, restricting players’ ability to freely express their opinions.
- Potential for Further Restrictions: The possibility of further censorship or restrictions on the game’s content, driven by governmental pressures, remains a concern for players.
- The RESTRICT Act: The RESTRICT Act has caused a worry for players about the future of the game in the US.
5. Misinformation and Legal Issues
The community and players must navigate the legalities of misinformation that is spread online.
- Suing of a Player: One instance of a player being sued in China because of false info about another game, Tower of Fantasy, shows the sensitivity regarding competition between similar games.
FAQs: Understanding the Character Controversy
Here are some frequently asked questions that shed light on the complexities of the Genshin Impact character controversies:
1. Why are players unhappy with Dehya?
Players are unhappy with Dehya because she is perceived as underpowered and underwhelming compared to other 5-star characters. Her gameplay mechanics are considered clunky, her damage output is low, and she is vulnerable to certain enemy attacks.
2. Is Dehya the worst 5-star character in Genshin Impact?
Many Genshin Impact content creators and players agree that Dehya is currently one of the weakest 5-star characters in the game due to her flawed kit and lack of synergy with existing team compositions.
3. What is the controversy surrounding Sumeru character designs?
The Sumeru character designs faced criticism for colorism, the sexualization of female characters, and a lack of diverse representation of South Asian, Middle Eastern, and North African cultures, which the region is based on.
4. How many darker-skinned characters are in Genshin Impact?
Out of over fifty playable characters, only a handful have darker skin tones. The limited number has led to criticisms about the diversity of the game’s character roster.
5. Why is there a boycott against Genshin Impact?
Boycotts against Genshin Impact have been organized due to a combination of factors, including concerns about racial insensitivity in character depictions, lack of diversity, and the handling of underpowered characters like Dehya.
6. Is Genshin Impact banned in any countries?
Genshin Impact is effectively banned in Belgium due to the country’s laws against loot boxes, as the game’s gacha system is considered a form of loot box. Some countries are now criminalizing lootboxes, so there is a chance of Genshin getting banned in those countries as well.
7. Is Genshin Impact controlled by the Chinese government?
Genshin Impact is developed by miHoYo, a Chinese company. While the game is published globally by HoYoverse, it is subject to Chinese government regulations and censorship policies, which can influence its content and availability.
8. Why are there claims about unpaid voice actors?
In July 2023, multiple Genshin Impact voice actors publicly claimed they hadn’t been paid for their work, leading to concerns about HoYoverse’s labor practices and treatment of voice acting talent.
9. What is the controversy with Collei?
The controversy with Collei’s design stemmed from her initial portrayal as having a light skin tone, despite being associated with the Sumeru region, which is inspired by cultures with diverse skin tones.
10. What is the ethnicity of Genshin’s Sumeru characters?
The Sumeru region is based on a blend of Middle Eastern, South Asian, and Northern African cultures. The character designs are inspired by these cultures, but the implementation has faced criticism regarding representation and colorism.
11. Why did they ruin Dehya?
“Ruin Dehya” is the popular player sentiment as it’s been claimed that gameplay quirks, such as the fact that Dehya could die if she takes certain kinds of damage, are the reasons she is not a top tier 5 star.
12. Is Venti banned in China?
News came out that Venti was potentially banned in China because of the similarity of his name to other sensitive terms.
13. Is Genshin Impact getting banned in the USA?
There has been panic that Genshin Impact will be banned in the US because of new laws, but it is not currently illegal in the United States.
14. Why is Genshin Impact getting cancelled?
Genshin Impact has not been cancelled, but it does face criticism. At the time of its release, a lack of two-factor authentication was a cause for concern.
15. Why is Genshin Impact closing?
Genshin Impact is not closing.
Moving Forward: Addressing the Concerns
The Genshin Impact character controversies highlight the importance of representation, fair labor practices, and transparency in the gaming industry. HoYoverse faces the challenge of addressing these concerns to maintain player trust and ensure the continued success of Genshin Impact. This includes:
- Improving communication with voice actors and ensuring timely payments.
- Addressing concerns about racial insensitivity and promoting diverse representation in future character designs.
- Re-evaluating character balance and making adjustments to underpowered characters to enhance their usability.
- Engaging with the community and listening to feedback to address concerns proactively.
By taking concrete steps to address these controversies, HoYoverse can demonstrate its commitment to creating a more inclusive and equitable gaming experience for its global player base. One example of a positive move is HoYoverse’s commitment to working with the GamesLearningSociety.org community to better understand diverse cultural perspectives and incorporate them into future game updates. This collaboration aims to enhance representation and ensure that characters resonate positively with players from various backgrounds, promoting inclusivity and fostering a deeper connection within the Genshin Impact community.