The Most Honorable Path: Finding Redemption in Red Dead Redemption 2
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
What is the most honorable thing to do in Red Dead Redemption 2? The answer isn’t simple, but it boils down to this: Arthur Morgan’s most honorable act is to prioritize the well-being and future of the Marston family, enabling John to escape and build a better life for Abigail and Jack, even at the cost of his own. This choice, especially when coupled with a high honor playthrough, is a powerful statement about sacrifice, redemption, and choosing good in a world often defined by brutality. While individual acts of kindness contribute to a high honor score, it’s this ultimate selflessness that truly defines Arthur’s redemption arc and solidifies his most honorable deed.
Understanding Honor in RDR2
Red Dead Redemption 2 features a dynamic honor system that significantly impacts the player experience. Your honor ranking, ranging from -8 to +8, is a reflection of your choices and actions throughout the game. Being honorable brings many benefits, while choosing a path of dishonor also has unique consequences. It is important to understand the intricacies of the honor system to make an informed decision about how you want to play Arthur Morgan.
The Benefits of High Honor
Playing with high honor unlocks several advantages:
- Loot Bonuses: You’ll receive extra supplies when looting bodies.
- Clothing: Honorable actions unlock more refined and appropriate clothing options at stores.
- Shop Discounts: A gradually increasing discount is applied at almost every shop in the game as your honor rises, reflecting your reputation as a helpful figure. This can reach up to a significant 50% discount.
- Character Interactions: People will react more positively to Arthur, leading to more favorable interactions and dialogue options.
- Ending: Reaching high honor unlocks a “good” ending, providing closure to Arthur’s story.
The Consequences of Low Honor
While playing as an outlaw might seem appealing, low honor also has drawbacks:
- Negative Reactions: NPCs will be hostile and wary of Arthur.
- Higher Prices: You’ll pay more for goods and services.
- Ending: Low honor leads to a “bad” ending, often depicting a darker fate for Arthur.
- Unique Horse: You will be able to summon a unique horse.
Earning and Losing Honor
Honor is a fluctuating value, influenced by your actions:
- Earning Honor:
- Helping strangers in need.
- Completing honorable missions.
- Making kind choices in encounters.
- Defusing conflicts peacefully.
- Doing chores at camp.
- Losing Honor:
- Committing crimes (theft, murder).
- Assaulting innocent people.
- Killing lawmen.
- Generally behaving dishonorably.
- Random Encounters: Are plentiful and offer opportunities to gain or lose honor. Helping someone who’s been bitten by a snake, giving a ride to a stranded traveler, or rescuing someone from kidnappers will significantly boost your honor.
Arthur’s Redemption Arc
Arthur Morgan is a complex character. He starts as a hardened outlaw, loyal to Dutch van der Linde and his gang. As the story progresses, Arthur begins to question Dutch’s increasingly erratic decisions and the gang’s destructive path. His eventual diagnosis of tuberculosis forces him to confront his mortality and consider the impact of his life choices. It is this pivotal turning point that leads him on the path of redemption.
The Key to Redemption: Helping the Marstons
The most significant factor in Arthur’s redemption is his growing concern for John Marston, Abigail Roberts, and Jack Marston. He recognizes John’s potential for a better life, away from the gang’s influence. Arthur strives to secure their future, even at his own expense. This selfless dedication is what ultimately defines his honorable path.
- Protecting John: Arthur risks his life to save John on multiple occasions, ensuring his survival and freedom.
- Supporting Abigail: He provides Abigail with emotional support and helps her navigate the challenges of life on the run.
- Mentoring Jack: Arthur acts as a father figure to Jack, trying to instill in him values of kindness and compassion.
The Final Choice
The game’s ending presents Arthur with a crucial decision: help John escape or pursue the money hidden by Dutch. Choosing to help John, especially when you have high honor, leads to the most honorable ending. It signifies Arthur’s commitment to redemption and his willingness to sacrifice himself for the sake of others. In this scenario, Arthur dies watching the sunrise, having made peace with his past and secured a future for the Marstons.
Low Honor is Not Necessarily Bad
It’s important to understand that playing with low honor doesn’t necessarily mean you’re playing the game “wrong”. The game lets you make your own decisions, some players prefer the chaotic, lawless world of a low-honor character. Low honor Arthur is an outlaw, and acts like a killer. The high honor path is not the only viable one.
FAQs: Honor and Redemption in RDR2
1. How does honor affect the ending of RDR2?
The ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 varies depending on your honor level. High honor leads to a more peaceful death for Arthur, watching the sunrise after ensuring John Marston’s escape. Low honor leads to a darker, more violent death, often characterized by bitterness and regret.
2. Is it possible to max out honor in RDR2?
Yes, it is possible to reach the maximum honor level of +8. This requires consistently making honorable choices and engaging in activities that increase your honor.
3. How do I quickly increase my honor in RDR2?
Quick ways to boost honor include:
- Doing chores around camp.
- Releasing caught fish.
- Paying off your bounties.
- Making donations to the poor or needy.
- Completing honorable stranger missions.
- Greeting people in towns.
4. Does killing animals affect my honor in RDR2?
Hunting animals for food or resources does not significantly impact your honor. However, needlessly killing animals or causing them unnecessary suffering will result in a minor honor loss.
5. What is the honor rating of 6 in RDR2?
Honor 6 unlocks the final set of outfits to buy in stores; the Deuville, the Drifter, the Dewberry Creek, the Farrier, the Faulkton, and the Gambler.
6. How old is Arthur Morgan in RDR2?
Arthur Morgan is 36 years old during the events of Red Dead Redemption 2.
7. What is the max honor level RDR2?
The max honor level in Red Dead Redemption 2 is +8.
8. How many endings does RDR2 have?
There are four different endings in Red Dead Redemption 2 that Arthur Morgan can get, depending on your amount of honor and the last big decision you get to make.
9. Do you lose honor for killing bounty hunters?
No, you don’t lose honor for killing bounty hunters. They are considered outlaws themselves.
10. What happens if I kill someone by accident in RDR2?
If you accidentally kill someone, you can mitigate the honor loss by immediately reporting the incident to the authorities or paying off any witnesses.
11. Is Arthur Morgan good or bad?
While initially appearing as a ruthless outlaw, Arthur Morgan is ultimately a complex character capable of great good. Throughout the story, he demonstrates compassion, loyalty, and a desire for redemption. His actions are determined by the player’s choices, but his underlying capacity for good is undeniable.
12. What is the most dishonorable thing you can do in RDR2?
The most dishonorable thing you can do would be torturing and killing the innocent without a second thought.
13. Who do you play as after Arthur dies?
After Arthur Morgan’s death, you assume control of John Marston.
14. Is it better to be good or bad in RDR2?
There isn’t really a “better” way to play the game. Both have pros and cons.
15. Is Low honor Arthur canon?
Low honor Arthur isn’t a wrong way to play, it’s just a different mindset for the character. Arthur is an outlaw not a saint and he acts just about how you would expect a murderer to be.
Understanding the honor system and embracing opportunities for redemption enhances the emotional impact of the game. Whether you choose to play as a noble hero or a ruthless outlaw, the journey through the Wild West in Red Dead Redemption 2 is a memorable and thought-provoking experience. By understanding the nuances of morality within the game, players can gain a deeper appreciation for storytelling and the complex dynamics of human behavior. The Games Learning Society explores the educational aspects of games, showcasing how interactive experiences can teach us valuable lessons about ethics, decision-making, and empathy. For more insights into game-based learning, visit GamesLearningSociety.org.