What Percentage of an MTG Deck Should Be Land?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of how much land to include in a Magic: The Gathering deck is fundamental to building a consistent and successful strategy. There isn’t a single, perfect answer, as the ideal land percentage is influenced by several factors, including deck size, mana curve, and card draw capabilities. However, as a general rule of thumb, lands should make up approximately 33% to 40% of your deck. This translates to roughly 24-25 lands in a 60-card deck and around 17-18 lands in a 40-card deck. Commander decks, being larger, typically require a land base of between 33 and 42 lands in a 100-card deck. Understanding the nuances behind these figures will empower you to fine-tune your mana base for optimal performance.
Understanding the Baseline: The 33-40% Rule
The traditional guideline of a 33% to 40% land ratio serves as a good starting point. This framework is designed to ensure that you consistently draw land cards to cast your spells without being flooded with too much mana. However, this is merely the beginning of a much more nuanced process.
The Importance of Mana Curve
The mana curve of your deck is a crucial factor when determining land count. A mana curve refers to the distribution of casting costs for the non-land cards in your deck. If your deck is full of low-cost spells (one, two, and three mana), you might be able to get away with slightly less land, perhaps closer to 33%. Conversely, if your deck is packed with expensive spells costing four, five, or more mana, then you’ll require more lands, potentially approaching the 40% mark. A deck with a higher average mana value demands more land to ensure you can cast your spells in a timely manner.
The Role of Card Draw and Mana Ramp
The number of card draw and mana ramp spells also significantly impacts the number of lands you need. Spells that allow you to draw additional cards or accelerate your mana production allow you to see more cards in your deck. The more of these efficient spells you have, the more confident you can be in seeing your lands and the fewer lands you’ll generally need. The rule of thumb in this case is to reduce one land for every three or four efficient card draw spells or mana ramp effects. This helps balance the potential for mana flood by providing you with options to dig for the cards you need.
Adjusting Land Count for Different Formats
Constructed Formats (60-Card Decks)
In constructed formats like Standard, Modern, or Pioneer, the minimum deck size is 60 cards. While the standard 24-25 lands is a good starting point, you’ll need to adjust this number based on your deck’s specific requirements. For example, an aggressive, low-to-the-ground deck might function well with 22 or 23 lands, while a control deck with high-cost finishers might need 26 or 27 lands.
Limited Formats (40-Card Decks)
In Limited formats like Draft or Sealed, your deck will be 40 cards. A land base of 17-18 lands is typical for this type of deck. These limited deck sizes can sometimes feel clunky, but they’re designed to be a more streamlined and less consistent version of a constructed deck. Just like constructed formats, adjust the ratio if your average mana cost is unusually low or high.
Commander (100-Card Decks)
Commander (also known as EDH) decks require 100 cards, and the land count is adjusted accordingly. A range of 33-42 lands is recommended for Commander; this accounts for the larger deck size and the format’s slower, more complex gameplay. The prevalence of ramp spells and powerful mana rocks in Commander often leads players to cut lands, but going below the 33-land mark can be risky. Always consider your commander’s casting cost and the average mana value of your spells when deciding how many lands to include.
Beyond Basic Lands: Special Lands & Mana Fixing
While calculating the right number of lands is crucial, it’s important to go beyond basic lands. Special lands that tap for multiple colors, have unique effects, or provide additional utility can enhance your deck significantly. These include dual lands, fetch lands, and utility lands that can provide an edge in specific situations. When building a mana base, always try to include as many special lands as possible that match the colors of your deck, where feasible.
Utilizing Formulas for Precision
For a more precise approach to land count, consider using formulas that take into account your average mana value, card draw, and ramp. One common formula for a 60-card deck is:
19.59 + (1.90 * Average Mana Value) – (0.28 * Number of Cheap Card Draw/Mana Ramp Spells)
Using this formula as a starting point can provide a helpful estimate for how many lands you need in your deck. Keep in mind that no formula is foolproof, and you’ll need to use your judgment to make sure you adjust your lands for your deck.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is the absolute minimum number of lands I should have in a 60-card deck?
While highly risky, some extremely low curve aggressive decks might function with 20-22 lands but it’s not recommended for most decks. Unless your deck has a very specific purpose, you generally need 23+ lands in a 60-card deck.
2. Is it ever okay to have more than 40 lands in a 100-card Commander deck?
Yes, it can be. Decks with high-cost commanders or expensive mana curves often benefit from having 40+ lands, especially if they do not have lots of mana rocks or ways to tutor for the needed mana.
3. How should I factor in dual lands when counting lands?
Dual lands count as one land each, but their benefit lies in their flexibility. A dual land that taps for two colors can reduce the overall number of total lands needed, due to how it helps mana fix.
4. Does mana ramp reduce the number of lands I need?
Yes, if you have a lot of cheap mana ramp spells you should reduce lands by one for every three to four such spells.
5. What’s the ideal mana curve for a 60-card deck?
The majority of your spells should cost between two and four mana. You generally want to avoid having too many spells with a high mana value.
6. How many lands should I have in a two-color deck?
The number of lands required is not determined by how many colors are in the deck, but more by your average mana cost and card draw abilities, but dual lands are essential for consistent mana bases.
7. Should I count MDFCs (Modal Double-Faced Cards) as lands?
MDFCs that have a land on one side should be partially counted as lands. When using formulas, you might consider counting 1/2 or 2/3 of the MDFC, but use personal judgement.
8. What is the general guideline for a creature, land, and spell ratio?
A quick guideline is 1/3 land, 1/3 creatures, and 1/3 spells, but this can vary widely. The creature ratio can shift up if you use cards with extra abilities.
9. How many mana rocks is optimal for a commander deck?
The “ideal” mana rocks vary depending on your commander. A low-cost commander might not need more than a sol ring and mana dork, while a high-cost commander could need 8-10 mana rocks.
10. Is it bad to have too few lands in MTG?
Yes. Having too few lands means that you risk “mana screwing” and not being able to play your cards. This is one of the biggest mistakes for new MTG players.
11. What is ‘mana flood’ in MTG, and how can I avoid it?
Mana flood refers to drawing too many lands. Card draw and mana sinks can help alleviate this situation.
12. What is ‘mana screw’ in MTG, and how can I avoid it?
Mana screw means not drawing enough lands to play your spells. Increasing the number of lands, especially with lower costs, increases the likelihood of drawing them.
13. How important are card draw spells for reducing the number of lands?
Card draw spells allow you to see more of your deck each game, and thus you can reduce lands by one for every three to four cheap draw spells.
14. How often should I adjust my land count?
Adjust your land count whenever you make substantial changes to the mana curve or card draw of your deck, and adjust according to testing results.
15. What is the biggest mistake when determining land counts?
The biggest mistake is not adapting your land count to your deck’s needs, and not taking card draw or mana rocks into account. Sticking to 24 lands in all 60 card decks is a big mistake, as this will lead to inconsistency.
By understanding these principles and applying them to your deck-building process, you can build a more consistent and effective mana base. Remember that experimentation is key, and the best land percentage is the one that works best for your individual deck and playstyle.